Subscribe to Capitol Fax      Advertise Here     Contact Rich Miller
To subscribe to Capitol Fax, click here. Subscriptions are $350 per year. To advertise on the Capitol Fax Blog, please click here.
Duckworth can’t answer question *** Updated x2 ***

Wednesday, Oct 11, 2006

It’s not often that a candidate, or anyone else for that matter, is asked the question that Tammy Duckworth was asked yesterday. Good for the Daily Herald. [emphasis added]

Sixth Congressional District Democrat Tammy Duckworth tried to capitalize on the recent spate of school shootings by citing them as she criticized her opponent’s record on gun control Tuesday.

But when pressed to name what gun laws could have prevented the attacks in Pennsylvania, Colorado and elsewhere, Duckworth couldn’t name any.

“Yes, there are going to be aberrations, but frankly we need overall better gun laws in this country,” said Duckworth at a news conference at a Lombard park.

The Hoffman Estates Iraq war veteran brought up the school shootings as she criticized President Bush for excluding gun control groups from his Tuesday summit on school violence.

Too often, candidates are allowed to demagogue with a “there oughtta be a law” statement without any sort of journalistic follow-up. Also, too often after major tragedies, people propose solutions that never would have prevented the events in question, yet somehow they are allowed to skate free. Duckworth didn’t get a free pass this time.

*** UPDATE *** Today’s Tribune story of the same press event is a good example of how gun control candidates get off too easy.

*** UPDATE 2 *** Dan Curry, a blogger who also works for the Topinka campaign, noted the above remarks and applied them to today’s AP coverage of Gov. Blagojevich.

Today, AP should have shown similar toughness when giving Rod Blagojevich a free ride on one of his talking points during this campaign — his position in favor of a ban on assault weapons. His attack on Judy Baar Topinka on this issue hardly is news compared to revelations at the Tribune editorial board that a sitting governor refuses to reveal whether he is using the services of a criminal defense attorney. Yet AP played assault weapons higher in the story.

It’s not particularly newsworthy because the Democrats control every lever of power in Illinois. If AP is going to do Rod’s bidding on this issue, it ought to have the journalistic toughness to ask Rod why, with a Democratic Governor and Democratic General Assembly, he couldn’t successfully pass an assault weapon ban in Springfield the last three years?

- posted by Rich Miller


29 Comments
  1. - DOWNSTATE - Wednesday, Oct 11, 06 @ 8:28 am:

    THANK YOU DAILY HERALD for showing that people like her are gun grabbers with no answers.Enland and Canada have some of the toughest laws in the world and they still have problems.This falls right in line with Blago and the rest of the Democrats.


  2. - grand old partisan - Wednesday, Oct 11, 06 @ 8:51 am:

    If only the press had done the same for Blago and Durbin when they went to Englewood to complain about how the NRA killed those two little girls, not the gang bangers who were breaking the unenforced, existing gun laws of the state and city.


  3. - Jechislo - Wednesday, Oct 11, 06 @ 8:51 am:

    Guns don’t kill people, evil people with guns kill people. Take away all of their guns and you still have an evil person bent on killing someone.


  4. Pingback Reverse Spin » AP rolls over on guns - Wednesday, Oct 11, 06 @ 9:25 am:

    […] Rich Miller already noted that Eric Krol of the Daily Herald asked a rare tough question of a Democratic politician attacking a Republican on gun control. […]


  5. - Sceptic - Wednesday, Oct 11, 06 @ 9:28 am:

    Well, though vauge, at least her answer was an honest one, rather than the hem, haw & bluster we get all too often.

    Frankly it’s nice to occasionally have a politician admit to “I don’t know..” rather than making up some BS on the spot.


  6. - HANKSTER - Wednesday, Oct 11, 06 @ 9:32 am:

    Jechislo: that is the most absurd argument. Based on your logic lets legalize WMDs because they dont kill people, if you “take away their WMDs and you still have an evil person bent on killing someone.”

    The right wing “tough on terrorism” nuts such as Peter Pan Roskam think that assault rifles, cop killer bullets, saturday night specials ect ect should all be legal. That would make a very safe country for us and our police.


  7. - Brady Bill - Wednesday, Oct 11, 06 @ 9:44 am:

    Come on Rich did Todd write that for you?


  8. - Rich Miller - Wednesday, Oct 11, 06 @ 9:59 am:

    Brady Bill, there would be no criticism here if she had just answered the question. Sorry, but I just don’t reverently worship at the altar of the usual hot-button issues the way some do.


  9. - NW burbs - Wednesday, Oct 11, 06 @ 10:12 am:

    Will Roskam be asked just as tough a question from his point of view?

    And I wonder how this would tie into the Axley and Kotowski race… The 33rd State Senate does overlap the 6th CD a bit.

    The Amish Schoolhouse shooting may need deeper thinking than a simple “what laws” question (as appropriate as that question is for candidates). But certainly kids bringing guns to school (from 1st graders to high schoolers) can be addressed by strengthening trigger lock laws and other common sense legislation.


  10. - Yellow Dog Democrat - Wednesday, Oct 11, 06 @ 10:19 am:

    Rich, it’s a tough question to answer until we know all of the facts in these cases.

    1) How did a seventh grader get his hands on an AK-47?

    2) How did a man with such obvious mental problems get his hands on guns in Pennsylvania?

    3) How is it that a 15 year-old was able to so easily open his family’s gun cabinet in Wisconsin?

    Clearly, a federal ban on military-style assault weapons might have prevented #1.

    Philadelphia is using new technology to profile people most likely to commit homocides and target resources to homocide prevention. I don’t know if it is applicable here, but with all of the data and all of the technology we have, we can certainly do a better job of screening FOID applicants. A more thorough and far-reaching solution would be to invest appropriately in mental health funding. This guy clearly was carrying alot of grief and didn’t get the help he needed.

    #3 is very easy to solve. Require gun safes to be tamper-proof. If a gun owner puts their guns in a locked cabinet, they should have a reasonable expectation that it will take more than a 15 year-old with a screwdriver to get it open.

    Maybe I should run for Congress?


  11. - Eagle I - Wednesday, Oct 11, 06 @ 10:23 am:

    This is not a gun issue. It is a mental health issue. There are people out there who “have problems in living” as one of my late Psych profs used to say. The instrument, guns, knives, bombs, whatever do not matter. We need to identify these people and get them some help just like we do with any other disease. These school shooters are sick.


  12. - Robbie - Wednesday, Oct 11, 06 @ 10:38 am:

    I think that those who say that taking guns away doesnt eliminate crazy people are totally missing the point.

    While it is a safe assumption that we wont get rid of crazy nut-jobs anytime soon, look at it this way. Guns allow those wachos to take several mroe people with them. Sure that PA guy was crazy. But maybe had he not had such easy access to guns he would have simply committed suicide and not taken innocent lives with him.

    While England and other countries still have problems with guns and violence, I think statistically they are so much lower its hard to say it doesn’t work. I will try and find some stats.


  13. - ArchPundit - Wednesday, Oct 11, 06 @ 10:39 am:

    Good and legitimate question.

    The other side of the question is easy in Illinois–though Roskam wasn’t holding a press conference on it.

    Would you simply extend the FOID requirement to the nation? It doesn’t keep anyone from getting a gun here and could easily reduce straw purchasing and gun running from more lax states.


  14. - Carl Nyberg - Wednesday, Oct 11, 06 @ 10:40 am:

    I’m surprised Duckworth is a gun control Democrat. I thought the party had assimilated the research that showed existing gun control laws had litte effect on crime rates.


  15. - ArchPundit - Wednesday, Oct 11, 06 @ 10:40 am:

    ===The instrument, guns, knives, bombs, whatever do not matter.

    There is an efficiency issue that no one seems to want to admit to here. If you want to take a classroom hostage, a gun is a lot more effective than is a knife.


  16. - Ken in Aurora - Wednesday, Oct 11, 06 @ 11:16 am:

    Hankster, “assault rifles, cop killer bullets, saturday night specials”? Sheesh, using loaded partisan code words like those makes me suddenly go deaf.

    I thought Dems had finally realized that so-called Gun Control is a third rail issue – touch it, and you’ll die. Hot Rod must have missed that particular memo.

    Those of you that are calling for bans… why do you think criminals would follow your new laws? That’s why they’re called *criminals* fer crissake! Those of us that are responsible gun owners and users are the only ones that will be punished. Focus on enforcing the current laws.

    Illinois is already so far out of step with national thinking on guns that it’s not even funny. Rod’s bleatings on the subject are surreal.


  17. - Eagle I - Wednesday, Oct 11, 06 @ 11:30 am:

    There are only two places on the planet that require a FOID card, they are Illinois and Cuba. This is either a source of pride or shame, take your pick.


  18. - archpundit - Wednesday, Oct 11, 06 @ 11:57 am:

    ===#

    There are only two places on the planet that require a FOID card, they are Illinois and Cuba. This is either a source of pride or shame, take your pick.

    Make up stuff much? Seriously, registration of firearms is required in all of Europe. This kind of claim is just shameless.


  19. - HANKSTER - Wednesday, Oct 11, 06 @ 12:01 pm:

    Ken: maybe you have not looked at any polls but Roskam’s stance on guns is a huge vulnerability for him. Roskam’s views on guns are extreme and, like it or not, most people in the district agree with that.

    Once again a gun lover comes up with some terrible logic. According to you now we should not have laws since criminals wont follow them anyway.


  20. - archpundit - Wednesday, Oct 11, 06 @ 12:01 pm:

    ===I thought Dems had finally realized that so-called Gun Control is a third rail issue – touch it, and you’ll die. Hot Rod must have missed that particular memo.

    It’s only a tough issue in rural areas. In urban and suburban areas, gun control including assault weapons bans are popular. Overall, there is a majority supporting stricter laws with the most recent numbers I’ve seen putting it in the mid 50%s.

    The challenge of the issue is that gun advocates tend to be single issue voters and so they have disproportionate influence especially in rural areas. Rod isn’t worrying abou rural areas.


  21. - Dave Barrett - Wednesday, Oct 11, 06 @ 12:29 pm:

    Once again Democrats are being asked tougher questions than Republicans. Why are no journalists asking President Bush and the Congressional leaders which acts of terrorism their proposed fence and new security at the Mexican border would have prevented? They too would be unable to answer the question because there has been no act of terrorism committed by a terrorist who entered the US illegally across the Mexican border.
    Rich, why are you holding Democrats to a higher standard than you hold Republicans?


  22. - Yellow Dog Democrat - Wednesday, Oct 11, 06 @ 12:49 pm:

    Having said all that, I think there should be an admission by gun control advocates that a state-by-state patchwork of gun safety laws has far less efficacy than federal action.

    Banning straw man purchases in Illinois doesn’t do a heckuva lot of good when they’re allowed in Indiana.

    Furthermore, campaigning on gun safety at the state level creates an expectation that the problem can be solved or atleast addressed at the state level, expectations that are difficult to meet and support the NRA’s main argument: we don’t need more laws.


  23. - Ken in Aurora - Wednesday, Oct 11, 06 @ 1:09 pm:

    Hankster: “Once again a gun lover comes up with some terrible logic. According to you now we should not have laws since criminals wont follow them anyway.”

    “Gun lover”? Sticks and stones… I’m a lawful gun owner that is also an independent, and is at odds with the NRA almost as much as I am against the gun control advocates. And how does wanting to enforce existing laws translate to not wanting any laws at all?


  24. - HANKSTER - Wednesday, Oct 11, 06 @ 1:34 pm:

    Ken: you said what will more laws do since criminals dont follow them anyway. That is your logic that I am responding to.


  25. - Old Quack - Wednesday, Oct 11, 06 @ 1:37 pm:

    “Since the assault-weapons ban expired, gunfire has again become the leading cause of death for police officers in the line of duty, surpassing motor-vehicle accidents, Street said.”

    that about says it for me.


  26. - Ken in Aurora - Wednesday, Oct 11, 06 @ 2:47 pm:

    Show me that the officers are being killed by so-called “assault weapons”, and I’ll pay attention. Otherwise it’s a statistical anomaly.

    Bet you can’t.


  27. - Downtown - Wednesday, Oct 11, 06 @ 5:25 pm:

    Ken from Aurora

    Glad to hear you are a law abiding gun owner just like Charles Roberts was until he decided to use his lawfully obtained guns to kill defenseless Ahmish girls. Cut the Law abiding gun owner crap, hoss.


  28. - Ken in Aurora - Thursday, Oct 12, 06 @ 10:40 am:

    Downtown, that is an evil insult and is totally inappropriate.


  29. - So-Called "Austin Mayor" - Friday, Oct 13, 06 @ 11:19 am:

    My two-cents: More gun control laws are are a rural solution to a urban/suburban problem, i.e. rural citizens bear the burden of additional laws that primarily benefit those living in urban and suburban areas.

    Such laws may be the only way to address the problems of gun violence, but this cost-benefit imbalance must be addressed — or at least recognized.


Sorry, comments for this post are now closed.


ON THE BLOG TODAY...
* This just in... No delay in Blagojevich trial
* Question of the day
* *** UPDATED x1 *** Raw videos of Madigan, Quinn and Cullerton
* Blog commenter wisdom
* Statehouse roundup
* Kirk: On the way to making Obama a one-termer
* Morning Shorts
* Morning video - Noonan shaves his head for charity
* SUBSCRIBERS ONLY - Today's edition of Capitol Fax (use all CAPS in password)
** Yesterday's blog posts

Support The Capitol Fax Blog
Visit our advertisers...

Search This Blog...

Search the 96th General Assembly By Bill Number
(example: HB0001)

Search the 96th General Assembly By Keyword

Quick Links


Main Menu
Home
Illinois
YouTube
Pundit rankings
Obama
Subscriber Content
Durbin
Burris
Polls

Archives
March 2010
February 2010
January 2010
December 2009
November 2009
October 2009
September 2009
August 2009
July 2009
June 2009
May 2009
April 2009
March 2009
February 2009
January 2009
December 2008
November 2008
October 2008
September 2008
August 2008
July 2008
June 2008
May 2008
April 2008
March 2008
February 2008
January 2008
December 2007
November 2007
October 2007
September 2007
August 2007
July 2007
June 2007
May 2007
April 2007
March 2007
February 2007
January 2007
December 2006
November 2006
October 2006
September 2006
August 2006
July 2006
June 2006
May 2006
April 2006
March 2006
February 2006
January 2006
December 2005
April 2005
March 2005
February 2005
January 2005
December 2004
November 2004
October 2004

Blog*Spot Archives
November 2005
October 2005
September 2005
August 2005
July 2005
June 2005
May 2005

Syndication

RSS Feed 2.0
Comments RSS 2.0
WordPress
 

  
  » WordPress For BlackBerry 1.1 Now Available With Lots Of New Features
  » Google developer takes on Apple
  » Review: Melatonin for iPhone
  » Apple lets iPhone developers schedule sales
  » Nexus One to call on Sprint too

  » From the Tips Box: DIY Skills, Touchpad Middle Click, and Laundry Drying [From The Tips Box]
  » Remains of the Day: 24 Hours of YouTube Every Minute Edition [For What It's Worth]
  » The High Price of Convenience Foods [Saving Money]
  » Parallels Outdoes VMware Fusion on Most Benchmarks [Virtualization]
  » Cancel a Print Job Without Waiting Years [Annoyances]

» Viciedo among five White Sox cuts
» Jenks says 'Next,' Ozzie on Ron Washington
» Jones' homer powers White Sox win
» Putz, Jenks satisfied with simulated work
» Castro hit by pitch, leaves game

 
     


  » Illinois Senate Candidate Mines Health Care Opposi....
  » Puerto Ricans here need new birth certificates - B....
  » Illinois budget crisis sharpens - World Socialist ....
  » Blunt, Carnahan campaign against the powers that b....
  » Obama Skirts Illinois Visits So Far as Democrats B....
  » GOP uses 'people' strategy in bid to grab Obama se....
  » Health Care Debate: It Would 'Cripple' Ill., State....
  » US consumer protection proposals attacked - Financ....
  » Quinn signs bill to change date of state primary -....
  » Trade show organizers meet with McCormick Place's ....


  » Chicago terror suspected expected to plead guilty
  » Grants available for children's medical expenses
  » New breast cancer study has Illinois connections
  » Proposal to make Ill. historic site national park
  » Cook County clerks likes new primary date
  » Quinn plans to sign bill moving primary to March
  » Blagojevich's trial date to stand, judge rules
  » Kraft to cut salt in food by an average of 10% by 2012
  » Federal Signal to combine units in new division
  » Boeing must update 777's software: FAA

  » New bleachers sign to net Cubs more than $2 million
  » Limited live early round coverage of Woods at Masters
  » Huron Consulting elects new non-exec chairman
  » Navistar gets ratings upgrade from Fitch
  » Trade show organizers meet with McCormick Place's labor leaders


  » Metra releases video of woman, godchild killed by train
  » Cardinal pushing sainthood for first black Catholic priest
  » Hedge fund whose manager faces fraud charges will get back 40 percent of losses
  » Cubs want OK for illuminated Toyota sign at Wrigley Field
  » Strict guidelines for students seeking to be 'principal's pick'
  » Girl, 7, critically injured in Southeast Side shooting
  » Priest accused of sex abuse collapses in court
  » Ind. man jailed in crash that killed construction worker
  » Woman charged with murder collapses after bail set at $3M
  » Minnesota man caught in Chicago after selling wife for sex


  » Semitrailer crashes, spills honey on highway
  » Car chased by Chicago cops crashes; 3 hurt
  » Dolton man dies of gunshot wounds
  » Man shot dead in Burnside neighorhood
  » Fetal remains found in hospital's laundry
  » Parking space gets its own census form
  » Dead man's watch stolen by host, suit says
  » Antioch high school graduate killed in Iraq
  » Wounded veterans heed call for help
  » Frank Lloyd Wright house for sale


  » Aging Gays and Lesbians Face Unique Challenges
  » Cubs Push for New Corporate Logo at Wrigley
  » Judge: Blagojevich Trial Won't Be Delayed
  » Sebelius in Chicago to Rally Support of Health Care Bill
  » Inside and Out: The Mission and the Money of the Department of Juvenile Justice
  » Reports: Daley Questioned By FBI
  » Chicago Police Defend Use of Taser on Chicago Public School Student
  » Chicago Unemployment Rate Increases
  » Blagojevich Attorneys Back in Court in Attempt to Push Back Trial
  » Region's Jobless Rate Jumps in January


  » Large meth lab discovered on North 15th Street
  » New Berlin OKs water plant proposal
  » Hundreds have sought FOIA help from attorney general
  » Quinn on Aging lease: Don't 'hold your breath'
  » Quinn signs bill moving Illinois primary back to March
  » Chicago cardinal seeks sainthood for first black priest
  » Judge again rejects motion to dismiss Watkins' visitation case
  » Republicans will get top spot on Sangamon Co. ballot
  » House strongly rejects electing U of I board
  » Judge says print can't be tested in Slover case


  » ‘Lost’ photos of 1925 devastation discovered
  » Families dealing with hemophilia offer support
  » JALC, unions try to roll back layoffs
  » Local residents protest health care bill
  » Jonesboro lays off 10 teachers


» Bartlett High student tells lawmakers about U-46 cuts
» Round Lake Park man accused of bringing bat to gang fight
» Zoo to help grow snake population in Lake County
» Veterans honor two District 300 teachers
» Military: We still want bin Laden alive


  » Primary date moved back
  » Sen. Hutchinson: "We haven't been doing that for the last 25-30 years"
  » GOPUSA ILLINOIS Daily Clips - March 17, 2010
  » Conversation starters
  » List of demands

» Protests may be public, but they're not alway..
» Kicking it in college - and beyond - Chicago ..
» No Respect Biden Debuts at Radio, TV Correspo..
» QC symposium offers tips on landing contracts..
» US 34 widening project on hold - Galesburg Re..
» Indiana Marine shot by Afghan contractor - AB..
» Idaho first to sign law against health care r..
» Walsh admits missteps before foreclosing on c..
» Idaho first to sign law against health care r..
» Idaho first to sign law against health care r..

» A Setback for Educational Civil Rights - Wall.....
» Protecting Refugees: an American Commitment a.....
» Gage Urges Senators to Defend, Call for TSO C.....
» A Public Option Would Sure Fix Democrats' CBO.....
» Senate Democrats Circulating Letter to House .....

» Blagojevich's request for trial delay has bee.....
» DADT Repeal Still Uncertain - Metro Weekly...
» Jackson leaves Urban League, takes 'gigantic .....
» Dems highlight GOP abuse of filibuster - UPI......
» DADT: Study or stall? - Bay Windows...

    » Let’s be real about Wrigley's feel
    » 14th CD citizens protest Obamacare in Batavia
    » Why is Giannoulias sweating?
    » Booker Rising: Could 2010 Be The Year Of The Black Republican?
    » Oh, Gee! Et tu, Prof. Green?
    » The World's Greatest Podcast: Bad calls & close calls
    » Wdebliography: `Deem and pass.'
    » Contractor/Vendor Job Fair/Workshop
    » Keeping the Ward Clean
    » Should principals be empowered leaders or branch managers?


Header Photos...
Wayne Bretl & UIS


Hosted by MCS