Subscribe to Capitol Fax      Advertise Here     Contact Rich Miller
To subscribe to Capitol Fax, click here. Subscriptions are $350 per year. To advertise on the Capitol Fax Blog, please click here.
More on those robocalls *** Updated x1 ***

Monday, Nov 6, 2006

The deceptive robocalls I told you about last week aren’t confined to Illinois.

The calls, paid for by the National Republican Campaign Committee, are running in 53 US House races, according to the Boston Globe.

The calls beging with “Hello, I’m calling with information about [Democratic candidate’s name here].” Lots of voters tend to hang up after the first sentence, but then they get another call right away from the system, leading some to believe that the Democratic candidate is bombarding them with idiotic calls.

You can listen to some examples of the robocalls done against Tammy Duckworth by clicking here.

Not everyone is blaming the innocent Democratic candidates, however.

Joan Sherrill had not decided how to vote in the 8th Congressional race until she received more than a dozen phone calls from Republican David McSweeney.

At that point, the choice was clear.

“I am voting for (Democrat) Melissa Bean,” the Palatine woman said. “The calls are just too much. They’re annoying.”

Despite all the hooplah on Democratic blogs about the outrageousness of the robocall campaign, as is almost always the case with politics, neither side is completely clean. From Dennis Byrne’s column:

It starts out as a typical poll. “Would you care to answer a few questions about the elections,” the voice on your phone asks. “Whom do you plan to vote for?”

Then it gets weird. As in: “Candidate A beats his wife; does that make you think of him more or less favorably?” Or as my daughter Kati heard when she was called: “Does the fact that Congressman Mark Kirk accepts special-interest money make you think of him more favorably or less favorably?”

So, if you are a supporter of Kirk–the Republican from the north suburban 10th Congressional District who is seeking re-election against Democrat Dan Seals–how are you supposed to answer? Oh, sure, I want my congressman to take special-interest money, so it makes me think more favorably of him.

Which is exactly how Kati, being Kati, answered. Then came four more questions of the same nature, each trying to make Kirk look like he was doing something wrong. And each time, Kati answered that she thinks more favorably of him. She even had the interviewer chuckling. But actually, it wasn’t so funny.

“It’s like Mark Kirk went out and shot 100 people,” she said. “What kind of poll is this anyway?”

The answer is: dirty, low-down and negative.

*** UPDATE *** Pioneer Press has a story up about the robocalls.

Rozanne Ronen, a Barrington resident, got the call — “Hi. I’m calling with information about Melissa Bean …”

Then she got the call again and again and 18 more times, making for a total of about 21 calls since October 24.

“They are very annoying,” Ronen said.

Pat Vockeroth, of Mount Prospect, received the calls too — “Hi. I’m calling with information about Tammy Duckworth …”

“If you only listen to the first sentence, you think they are from the Duckworth campaign,” she said.

But the calls aren’t paid for by Bean, Duckworth or even the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee, they are paid for by the National Republican Congressional Committee.

The media really needs to do something more on this. As other bloggers have noted, this is obviously an attempt at vote suppression.

- posted by Rich Miller


17 Comments
  1. - VanillaMan - Monday, Nov 6, 06 @ 9:38 am:

    We are smarter than this. Any attempt to pull these tricks will backfire.

    I suspect both parties when stories like this blow around. I definately suspect any media that tries to pin it on one of them.


  2. - Jacketpotato - Monday, Nov 6, 06 @ 10:22 am:

    This is nothing new. I believe this Push Polling was a GOP dirty trick from at least the ‘88 Presidential. Leave it to Byrne to make it look like Seals is some sort of political Mephistopheles.

    The more clever robocall is the constantly annoying calls that folks are getting. It’s subtle and under the radar. It also will help supress the vote of indies.


  3. - NW burbs - Monday, Nov 6, 06 @ 10:23 am:

    And did you notice how blissfully unaware Byrne’s column was?

    From the Byrne column: “(Here, I’ll stipulate that both parties probably use such polls.)”
    (emph added)

    VanillaMan, I challenge you to find 53 Democratic House races that are making such calls. And conservatives like Byrne are griping because Dems are using conservative tactics against conservative candidates. Pot, meet kettle.

    One of the most famous push polls was a Republican against a Republican when the Bush 2000 campaign called South Carolina voters asking what they would think of John McCain if they knew he had black babies… (this alluded to his adopted kids, but how is the poll receiver supposed to know they’re adopted).

    Bush won the SC primary.

    And the immediate call-back thing seems to be an attempt to get around telecom laws which force the caller to disconnect within seconds of the call receiver hanging up (so that the receiver can call 911 if needs be).


  4. - the Other Anonymous - Monday, Nov 6, 06 @ 10:28 am:

    I read the Byrne column, and I’m not convinced that the phone calls were “push-polling.” First, if the push is “Kirk takes special interest money,” it’s pretty lame. Second, the ONLY question that Byrne quotes is the special interest question — the rest were, umm, made up.

    A legitimate political polling technique is to ask questions testing various negative lines of attack. This technique becomes a push poll when: 1) the entire purpose of the phone call is persuasion, not surveying; and 2) the questions are loaded unfairly.

    Maybe this was a push poll, but Byrne didn’t provide enough information to make that judgement.

    By the way, some of his other suggestions — like having the sponsor of the survey identified — skew the responses, and would render polls (even more?) meaningless.

    I wish Byrne had taken the time to talk to a pollster before writing this column.


  5. - Pat Hickey - Monday, Nov 6, 06 @ 11:03 am:

    Byrne turned over a rock on the Progressive Travelling All-Stars and really got their collective panties in a twist - ‘Don’t You People Care About Saving This Country???!!!’

    The idea, I thought - dummy me - was to win an election.

    The respnse from the progresives was - ‘Well, what about all the Machine Teams?’ They are part of the Regular Cook County Democratic Organization - the grassroots as it were, Boys and Girls.


  6. - Wumpus - Monday, Nov 6, 06 @ 12:15 pm:

    I got a call from Da Coach, Mike Ditker(a) and Da Mayor, Rudi Giulliani telling me how great McSweeney is.


  7. - Dark Knight - Monday, Nov 6, 06 @ 12:17 pm:

    So you’re saying there are really people whose lives are so shallow and meaningless that they actually listen to these calls rather than hanging up immediately?


  8. - NW burbs - Monday, Nov 6, 06 @ 12:51 pm:

    Dark Knight,

    If you read the links Rich provided, the points to the Republican negative robo-calls are that the computer calls you back immediately several times even if (especially if) you hang up immediately.

    Since people hear “I’d like to tell you some information about (Democratic Candidate)” they assume it’s the Democrats’ campaign that is doing the annoying calls, rather than the Republicans (which you would only hear if you listened to the entire few minutes’ worth of drivel and negativity.


  9. - skb - Monday, Nov 6, 06 @ 12:55 pm:

    The Byrne column is a joke and a pathetic attempt to GOTV for the republicans in IL-10. First off, the statement that Kirk takes special interest money is true and accurate; he does. Byrne didn’t mention any of the other questions, which could also be absolutely true.

    Secondly, I received a call in June and there were similar questions about both candidates in the IL-10 race, not just one candidate. Byrne doesn’t give out any more details about the questions or purpose of the call.

    Byrne decided to smear an emerging campaign one day before the election with the slimmest of information and tons of innuendo.

    He’s also trying to avoid the bigger discussion about the annoying, harrassing robo-calls made by Roskam and the GOP but designed to look like they came from Duckworth.


  10. - Will County Wiseguy - Monday, Nov 6, 06 @ 2:38 pm:

    Dennis Byrne has absolutely no credibility. The guy is a flak for the extreme right wing and to call him a “journalist” is really a stretch. He has made a career out of twisting the truth like a pretzel.


  11. - Lovie's Leather - Monday, Nov 6, 06 @ 3:32 pm:

    Ha ha ha ha ha!!! Excuse me, Mr Seals, but when your top contributor is Kirkland and Ellis, I don’t think you have any room to talk about special interests…


  12. - Carl Nyberg - Monday, Nov 6, 06 @ 3:54 pm:

    Rich, why don’t you look into Dennis Byrne’s claim that he contacted Illinois Dem Network, but the organization didn’t respond?

    According to the Leo, the Illinois Dem Network organizer, Byrne never called or sent an email.

    So, you might want to factor a couple things into Byrne’s claim that all sides are practicing dirty equally.

    1. Dennis Byrne is a partisan hack who never said much of anything thoughtful or original.
    2. Byrne has apparently taken to lying to advocate for his Right Wing GOP views.


  13. - Pat Hickey - Monday, Nov 6, 06 @ 4:05 pm:

    Hey, Carl he sure gave the old progressive cage a rattle and the critters in it are hopping mad. Seems to that the man might be on to something there. Of course as a Regular Democrat ( paid up membership to old Doc Dean and all) standing on the visitors side of that cage, it is amusing. What is afoot? Lands sakes.


  14. - NW burbs - Monday, Nov 6, 06 @ 4:24 pm:

    Rich,

    I’ll back Carl up on that.

    Remember when your QOTD was on what the news media could do to improve their election coverage?

    …This issue is a case in point. (Unfortunately, the Republican dirty tricks bag is much, much worse in Virginia with the Webb-Allen Senate race.)


  15. - 10th Dem - Monday, Nov 6, 06 @ 7:38 pm:

    The Byrne column came up at the Dan Seals HQ (where I have been actively volunteering for weeks now) … the campaign staff was wondering a) if it really exists and is not a figment of Byrne’s overactive imagination; if not, then b)who commissioned it. I guess when both parties have to disclose their final campaign expenditures we will see who the real push-poller was.

    If a Seals supporter had commissioned that poll, the caller would have been told to make much more damning statements about Kirk than that he takes special-interest money. Kirk’s devotion to special-interest money is worth noting, but the Seals campaign tends to focus on much more volatile subjects … Kirk’s votes FOR Bush’s Iraq policy, FOR Bush’s budgets, AGAINST veterans’ benefits … and then of course there’s the infamous Caryn Garber email … yes, the Seals campaign has a lot more to work with than “special interest money”!!


  16. Pingback A new “Fighting Dem” For Illinois 6 « Illinois Reason - Monday, Oct 15, 07 @ 4:16 pm:

    […] The NRCC and/or other allied groups like a 527 or PAC may toss out a slew of annoying, subversive and downright misleading robocalls which seem designed mostly to sour voters and turn them off from the process rather than actually inform anyone of anything substantive […]


  17. Pingback Anti-military GOP: Roskam Rascals Already Attacking Colonel « Illinois Reason - Wednesday, Oct 17, 07 @ 12:28 am:

    […] Hiram Wurf notes the subversive conservative mailer is actually a switcheroo: it appears to be an endorsement of Col. Morgenthaler but ticks off a bunch of negative points. Gee, sounds like those nasty, harassing phone calls that got dumped into the 6th throughout the last campaign. On top of that, Arch notes that the group the card is attributed to (”Patriotic Democrats of DuPage”) appears to be illegal since no such group is listed in FEC filings even as the mailer appears to advocate for a Federal candidate. (PS: Nice typos in the text, ya maroons.) […]


Sorry, comments for this post are now closed.


ON THE BLOG TODAY...
* This just in... No delay in Blagojevich trial
* Question of the day
* *** UPDATED x1 *** Raw videos of Madigan, Quinn and Cullerton
* Blog commenter wisdom
* Statehouse roundup
* Kirk: On the way to making Obama a one-termer
* Morning Shorts
* Morning video - Noonan shaves his head for charity
* SUBSCRIBERS ONLY - Today's edition of Capitol Fax (use all CAPS in password)
** Yesterday's blog posts

Support The Capitol Fax Blog
Visit our advertisers...

Search This Blog...

Search the 96th General Assembly By Bill Number
(example: HB0001)

Search the 96th General Assembly By Keyword

Quick Links


Main Menu
Home
Illinois
YouTube
Pundit rankings
Obama
Subscriber Content
Durbin
Burris
Polls

Archives
March 2010
February 2010
January 2010
December 2009
November 2009
October 2009
September 2009
August 2009
July 2009
June 2009
May 2009
April 2009
March 2009
February 2009
January 2009
December 2008
November 2008
October 2008
September 2008
August 2008
July 2008
June 2008
May 2008
April 2008
March 2008
February 2008
January 2008
December 2007
November 2007
October 2007
September 2007
August 2007
July 2007
June 2007
May 2007
April 2007
March 2007
February 2007
January 2007
December 2006
November 2006
October 2006
September 2006
August 2006
July 2006
June 2006
May 2006
April 2006
March 2006
February 2006
January 2006
December 2005
April 2005
March 2005
February 2005
January 2005
December 2004
November 2004
October 2004

Blog*Spot Archives
November 2005
October 2005
September 2005
August 2005
July 2005
June 2005
May 2005

Syndication

RSS Feed 2.0
Comments RSS 2.0
WordPress
 

  
  » Qik Video Camera app disappears from App Store
  » iPhone Developers Now Able to Schedule App Store Sales in Advance
  » Malware found on another HTC Magic smartphone
  » Review: Rafter for iPhone
  » MacRumors: Apple Banning Screen Protectors in Retail Stores?

  » The High Price of Convenience Foods [Saving Money]
  » Parallels Outdoes VMware Fusion on Most Benchmarks [Virtualization]
  » Cancel a Print Job Without Waiting Years [Annoyances]
  » CapSee Notifies You When Caps Lock is On [Downloads]
  » The Windows 8 Concept Desktop [Featured Desktop]

» Castro hit by pitch, leaves game
» Bullpen decision could be tough
» Mark Teahen Community Projection Results
» Treatment Bound: A Minnesota Twins Preview
» Nix eyes final White Sox utility spot

 
     


  » Governor Quinn Signs Bill to Move Illinois' Primar....
  » Illinois Senate Candidate Mines Health Care Opposi....
  » Illinois Police Institute Proposes Budget That Wou....
  » In Missouri Senate race, meet the `outsiders' - As....
  » Put a stop to red light law - News-Gazette..
  » Quinn is trying to sell tax increase to lawmakers ....
  » Popular Programs Among Proposed Ag Cuts - WGIL Rad....
  » There are ways to get answers from public official....
  » Quinn urges Dems to support tax increase - WLS..
  » Senator calls on state to issue expense checks to ....


  » Judge rejects request to delay Blagojevich trial
  » Indiana surpasses Mississippi in gaming revenues
  » Abuse settlements cost Urbana schools $2.6 million
  » U. of Ill. studies nematodes in biofuel crops
  » Judge refuses to delay Blagojevich trial
  » Kraft to cut salt in food by an average of 10% by 2012
  » Federal Signal to combine units in new division
  » Boeing must update 777's software: FAA
  » Wintrust raises $27.5M more in share sale
  » Oprah must defend defamation suit: judge

  » Trade show organizers meet with McCormick Place's labor leaders
  » ShoreBank names David Vitale executive chairman
  » United pilots, flight attendants pick St. Paddy's Day to picket Aer Lingus venture
  » McDonald's wants to sell $1 drinks
  » Cubs want to put lighted billboard in bleachers


  » Minnesota man caught in Chicago after selling wife for sex
  » Motorcyclist in critical condition after rear-ending semi on Kennedy
  » Police commander charged with harassing cop
  » Judge denies request for delay in Blagojevich trial
  » West suburban man charged with attempting to hit policeman with car
  » 19 displaced by apartment fire in Manhattan
  » Big billboard in left field at Wrigley?
  » Chicago man to plead guilty in terror case
  » Ex-judge on Fire Dept. case
  » Indiana man jailed in crash that claimed life of construction worker


  » Sainthood for founder of Chicago's first black parish?
  » 'TCF Bandit' suspected in string of bank robberies ordered held
  » State primary elections moving back to March
  » Man accused of pimping wife on Craigslist
  » Developer's bribery trial winds down
  » Chicago police commander arrested for harassment
  » DuPage Water Commission treasurer quits after scathing report
  » Illinois primary election moved back to March after Scott Lee Cohen debacle, record low turnout
  » Finally, green earns cachet
  » Playboy editor, model sue Google and Facebook over photos


  » Judge: Blagojevich Trial Won't Be Delayed
  » Sebelius in Chicago to Rally Support of Health Care Bill
  » Inside and Out: The Mission and the Money of the Department of Juvenile Justice
  » Reports: Daley Questioned By FBI
  » Chicago Police Defend Use of Taser on Chicago Public School Student
  » Chicago Unemployment Rate Increases
  » Blagojevich Attorneys Back in Court in Attempt to Push Back Trial
  » Region's Jobless Rate Jumps in January
  » Support for Health Care Bill Shaky Among Illinois Congressmen
  » Guilty Plea Expected in Mumbai Terror Case


  » Judge again rejects motion to dismiss Watkins' visitation case
  » Quinn on Aging lease: Don't 'hold your breath'
  » Quinn signs bill moving Illinois primary back to March
  » Republicans will get top spot on Sangamon Co. ballot
  » House strongly rejects electing U of I board
  » Judge says print can't be tested in Slover case
  » Judge refuses to delay Blagojevich trial
  » Peoria house fire kills mother, son
  » Lawmaker praises Quinn for reviewing Aging lease
  » Business alliance meets Friday


  » New phone scam reported in Williamson County
  » Quinn signs bill moving back primary
  » Howard beats SIC men at national tournament
  » Lawmakers: Don't elect University of Illinois trustees
  » Jonesboro cuts 10 teachers; expects majority to be rehired


» Military: We still want bin Laden alive
» Quinn to sign bill moving back Ill. primary
» Madigan: The party, not Quinn, will make lt. gov. decision
» Bond set at $3 million for woman in Schaumburg hotel shooting
» Priest accused of sex abuse collapses in court


  » Sen. Hutchinson: "We haven't been doing that for the last 25-30 years"
  » GOPUSA ILLINOIS Daily Clips - March 17, 2010
  » Conversation starters
  » List of demands
  » GOPUSA ILLINOIS Daily Clips - March 16, 2010

» House tax writers approve small biz jobs pack..
» Congress Considers Bill To Help Veterans Own ..
» ObamaCare whip count(s): Pelosi in trouble? -..
» No, You Can't Have a Pony - Philadelphia City..
» Who's Going to Lead the Charge on Immigration..
» Detroit to Close One-Quarter of Schools - CBS..
» Jerry Costello Flips into the Stupak Bloc - F..
» New Health Care Whip Count: Still 191 Yes, 20..
» Survey Indicates Doctors' Opposition to Obama..
» Dan Lipinski, Melissa Bean, Luis Gutierrez: I..

» Gage Urges Senators to Defend, Call for TSO C.....
» Protecting Refugees: an American Commitment a.....
» A Public Option Would Sure Fix Democrats' CBO.....
» Senate Democrats Circulating Letter to House .....
» House Democrats want guarantee Senate will vo.....

    » Poll watch, 1960s
    » The Wire(s) in Denver
    » Sen. Hutchinson: "We haven't been doing that for the last 25-30 years"
    » `Deem and pass.' So what?
    » The divide
    » Those Wacky Out-of-Towners II
    » Del Valle's Plans
    » Judge Rejects Request To Delay Blagojevich's Trial
    » Democracy Denied: The Obama Chart
    » O'BRIEN: Blame the Cosmic Rays, Guys


Header Photos...
Wayne Bretl & UIS


Hosted by MCS