Home | Subscribers Only | AIM | Contact | Mobile | Subscribe | Classifieds | Calendar | Resumes
To subscribe to Capitol Fax, click here. Subscriptions are $350 per year. To advertise on the Capitol Fax Blog, please click here.
Lottery and gaming dreams discussed *** Updated x1 ***

Wednesday, Jan 31, 2007

Filan explains why he wants to lease out the state lottery.

The governor’s idea to lease the Illinois lottery didn’t generate much enthusiasm from state lawmakers last year, but the state’s chief operating officer pushed the idea anew Tuesday, arguing that Illinois must relieve itself of the risk posed by the lottery.

“I think revenue is at risk,” said the state’s new chief operating officer, John Filan, during an appearance before the Union League Club of Chicago. “I’m concerned lottery revenues will go down, not up, over time. I want to pass that risk on to the private market.”

Gov. Rod Blagojevich has suggested that a long-term lease of the lottery could generate new money for schools, but lawmakers are skeptical.

“I think they’re grasping at straws to come up with some plausible explanation as to why they want to sell a state asset, use the money now and not worry about it down the road,” said Rep. Jack Franks (D-Woodstock) who said he has requested hearings on the lottery proposal when lawmakers return to Springfield early next month.

Rep. Brent Hassert (R-Romeoville) questioned why private companies would give a “whole boatload of money for the lottery” if they’re looking at the same risky market.

Filan and the administration claim that current state law ties the state’s hands in expanding the lottery’s revenues. For instance, they’re limited on how much money they can spend on advertising and they can’t pay incentive sales bonuses to vendors or sales people.

The governor’s proposal, as far as we’ve seen, assumes that the General Assembly will remove those restrictions from a private company. I wouldn’t bet on that. As Rep. John Fritchey has noted, the plan also seeks to reduce the number of payouts, another not so popular idea.


Speaking of betting
, Rep. Lou Lang unveiled yet another gaming plan yesterday.

Gov. Rod Blagojevich has agreed not to interfere with a new gambling-expansion bill if it advances in the legislature this spring, the measure’s sponsor said Tuesday.

Rep. Lou Lang, a Skokie Democrat who previously pushed for additional Illinois casinos, said Blagojevich recently told him he would decide the merits of Lang’s latest proposal if and when it reaches his desk.

Blagojevich, a Chicago Democrat, in the past has publicly discouraged lawmakers from even sending him such legislation, by threatening a veto.

“The governor assured me that he was not going to say or do anything that would get in the way of my attempting to move this legislation,” Lang, chairman of the House Gaming Committee, said at a Chicago news conference. “That is what he told me, and that is what I expect will happen.”

Wanna take odds on the governor keeping his word?

*** UPDATE *** Mayor Daley’s response, via Chicago Public Radio.

- posted by Rich Miller


17 Comments
  1. - zatoichi - Wednesday, Jan 31, 07 @ 9:37 am:

    Filan have any evidence from other states that Lotery revenues go down over time?

    Lang get an MOU?


  2. - Fan of the Game - Wednesday, Jan 31, 07 @ 10:29 am:

    Open up gambling and become the “Vegas of the Midwest.”

    Selling the lottery produces a one-time money pot that helps balance the budget now but depletes the revenue stream. The state needs more revenue streams and/or fewer expenses.


  3. - Bluefish - Wednesday, Jan 31, 07 @ 10:32 am:

    My bet is that Blago would be hard pressed to say no to a casino bill that creates new revenue without raising taxes. But does Lang’s bill have any chance to make it to his desk?


  4. - Political insider - Wednesday, Jan 31, 07 @ 10:51 am:

    It seems like a heck of a way to try to sell something — announce that the future for the game is bleak before accepting any bids. If what Filan says is true, not many companies would be willing to pay a premium for the game. Oh wait, the governor says they are willing to. Could it be that the state is trying to sell a valuable resource for a onetime infusion of cash? Of course not. Blago and Filan say its not so. And we all know their numbers are believable…


  5. - Yellow Dog Democrat - Wednesday, Jan 31, 07 @ 11:07 am:

    We don’t have to take odds on whether or not the Gov will keep his word. From Crain’s:

    But Gov. Blagojevich has no plans to expand gaming, according to a spokeswoman in his office.

    “We’re putting our budget proposal together now and we aren’t proposing more gaming, but we’ll look at lawmakers’ ideas,” the spokeswoman said.

    Lest we forget, the Illinois House voted last year to abolish casinos. I have great respect for Lou Lang’s legislative finesse, and Emil Jones’ desire to see a casino can’t be underestimated. But the fact remains that Lang’s proposal wouldn’t even make a dent in the state’s structural budget deficit, the gap in school funding, our pension debt, or our obligation to provide property tax relief.

    That means that gambling expansion would still require some sort of tax hike to fill the budget void. You can’t pass the tax hike without rural Democrats and Republicans on board, and while most of them will vote for a modest tax hike to provide property tax relief and more money for schools, it is unlikely in the extreme that they would support gambling expansion.


  6. - Cassandra - Wednesday, Jan 31, 07 @ 11:12 am:

    There sure must be a lot more potential gamblers out there, not to mention current gamblers willing to spend even more money.

    Otherwise, how are all these additional gambling venues going to make money. Or are Blago/Filan a little too optimistic in their assumption
    that the ever-pluckable Illinois taxpayers will pour into those additional gambling places and spend ever more money.

    Maybe not.


  7. - anon - Wednesday, Jan 31, 07 @ 11:19 am:

    Cassandra. All one needs to do is go to the northwest Indiana riverboat parking lots and take a look at the license plates. Last time I went to the Hammond boat I saw 48 Illinois plates out 50 that I counted. There obviously a pent up demand helping out Indiana’s budget.


  8. - Truthful James - Wednesday, Jan 31, 07 @ 11:33 am:

    Political insider is correct.

    Bidders will discount the range of future earnings to come up to the price. Prospective buyers are not risk takers.

    Let us not forget as well the discount rate will include both the taxable cost of funds and the required return on equity investment. With capital assets, some benefit is obtained by using depreciation as a tax shelter.

    On the other side of the equation, the State would discount the future flows at some tax exempt rate. (If the state needed the money it could borrow iut at that rate and secure it with future revenues.

    This is a current money play, pure and simple. Filan is being disengenuous.


  9. - Yellow Dog Democrat - Wednesday, Jan 31, 07 @ 11:56 am:

    Not only is Filan being disengenious, his own revenue numbers don’t support his claim. Illinois Lottery revenues have been growing at a steady clip, and unless he’s suggestion that global warming or a meteor impact are somehow going to have an impact on the lottery, we have to expect that they will continue to grow.


  10. - Anonymous - Wednesday, Jan 31, 07 @ 12:07 pm:

    Exactly! Their own bid documents talk about how much MORE growth the lottery could be realizing with additional advertising and some other tweaks. They are shamelessly trying to have it both ways.


  11. - John Ruberry - Wednesday, Jan 31, 07 @ 12:27 pm:

    Lang, my rep, is in bed with casiso interests.


  12. - Pinkie Ring - Wednesday, Jan 31, 07 @ 12:43 pm:

    lottery = football
    Lang = Charlie Brown
    Blago = Lucy Van Pelt
    We’ve seen how this turns out


  13. - Pinkie Ring - Wednesday, Jan 31, 07 @ 12:45 pm:

    Duh, I just transposed this wrong, it was supposed to be inthe Casino thread, but you get the idea.


  14. - Commonsense in Illinois - Wednesday, Jan 31, 07 @ 12:53 pm:

    So, let’s see now. 1. John Filan says the reason the state wants to sell the lottery is because the revenues are suspect and he wants somebody else to get left holding the bag. What a great sales pitch that’ll be. 2. The Governor has promised Rep. Lang he’ll stay out of a gambling expansion debate. Well we all know that the governor is a man of his word and would never double cross a legislator in the name of self promo…never mind. 3. Additional casino revenues will not address the state’s debt situation…good point, but I agree for a different reason. For this administration, there is no state debt OR revenue deficit, so any additional money is “found” and can be used for nifty new programs. Is this a great state or what!?


  15. - Cassandra - Wednesday, Jan 31, 07 @ 1:00 pm:

    So can we look forward to a border gambling war with various casinos in Illinois and border states
    trying to develop even better, glitzier casinos to attract a floating population of gamblers.

    But what if Illiois loses the war?


  16. - Commonsense in Illinois - Wednesday, Jan 31, 07 @ 1:10 pm:

    Cassandra–Illinois cannot “lose” a casino war to Indiana based on population alone. Chicago gamers will simply stay in Chicago and that’s more than 1 million customers. What it does affect, though, is the idea that casino gaming will draw tourists. The reality is that gaming is so wide spread that it’s really a local market industry now (Las Vegas and to some extent Atlantic City still being exceptions). Bigger, glitzier…okay, but the real question is payout to customers on the basic games…slot machines, video poker, keno, etc. The odds on table games stay the same, and if Lang’s efforts are for boats in Cook/Lake counties, don’t look for large poker rooms…you need a lot of space and tables to make it profitable for the casino. Long and short; Illinois loses because of the tourism angle and increases to the number of problem gamblers because the state is offering additional venues for addicts to feed their gambling habit. (It’s not a large number, usually about 3%, but they are there.)


  17. - Tzedek - Wednesday, Jan 31, 07 @ 7:43 pm:

    Ruberry, you got it wrong on Lang. If you disagree with what Lang is proposing with the casinos, fine, disagree all ya want. But don’t sling any mud toward Lang–it’s uncalled for. He’s not in bed with any interests, as you stated. Lang is simply concerned with generating revenue for education and other worthy causes. He’s a kind, decent legislator and deserves more respect.


TrackBack URI

Sorry, comments for this post are now closed.


ON THE BLOG TODAY...
* Meeks: School boycott will happen, governor to blame
* Carnage
* Not to spoil the hugfest, but...
* Peace and love? *** UPDATED x6 WITH VIDEO AND PHOTOS *** Rep. Miller, Sen. Jones embrace *** MJM & RRB are convention seatmates ***
* Official amendatory veto of ethics bill now available
* Mid afternoon convention roundup
* Jones sort of apologizes, disappeared by Dems, upbraided by Halvorson
* Morning Shorts
* Emil Jones' mouth strikes again
* Governor rewrites ethics bill
* A look ahead at the Senate Democratic fight
* Reader comments closed for a while
** Yesterday's blog posts

Support The Capitol Fax Blog
Visit our advertisers...

Search This Blog...

Search the 95th General Assembly By Bill Number
(example: HB0001)

Search the 95th General Assembly By Keyword

Quick Links


Main Menu
Home
Illinois
YouTube
Pundit rankings
Obama
Subscriber Content
Durbin
Polls

Archives
August 2008
July 2008
June 2008
May 2008
April 2008
March 2008
February 2008
January 2008
December 2007
November 2007
October 2007
September 2007
August 2007
July 2007
June 2007
May 2007
April 2007
March 2007
February 2007
January 2007
December 2006
November 2006
October 2006
September 2006
August 2006
July 2006
June 2006
May 2006
April 2006
March 2006
February 2006
January 2006
December 2005
April 2005
March 2005
February 2005
January 2005
December 2004
November 2004
October 2004

Blog*Spot Archives
November 2005
October 2005
September 2005
August 2005
July 2005
June 2005
May 2005

Syndication

RSS Feed 2.0
Comments RSS 2.0
WordPress
 

  
  » China Mobile to Subsidize iPhone
  » TreoCentral TreoCast Episode 51
  » Walk-n-Charge
  » eReader Launches Mobile Site
  » AT&T BlackBerry Bold To Launch September 12th?
  » MacRumors: Apple and AT&T Discussing Official Tethering Option for iPhone?
  » Body Glove Side Case Review
  » The 14 Silliest Smartphone Accessories
  » Treo Software Roundup - v082908
  » Browse and buy eBooks from your mobile
  » MacRumors: Details of iPhone 2.0.2 Firmware 3G Connectivity Improvements?
  » MacRumors: Apple Confirms September iPhone Update
From feed.informer.com

  » PureText Strips Formatting from Your Clipboard When You Paste [Featured Windows Download]
  » Are You Concerned About Bandwidth Caps? [Ask The Readers]
  » Spoonflower
  » Operate Your Computer with Wii Controllers [Nintendo Wii]
  » Please Don't Block Us. (Please?) [Faceoff Followup]
  » Offer Small Discounts to Get Freelance Pay On Time [Freelancing]
  » Game Key Revealer Finds the Keys for Your Games [Featured Windows Download]
Brought to you by FeedInformer

» MLB official reveals obstruction call incorrect
» On your 26th Birthday...
» Thome and his dad visit Hall of Fame
» Thome, Junior set sights on elusive ring
» One Game Up, With 29 To Go
» White Sox feel ready to play Red Sox
» Danks Struggles, Sox Slumber
» White Sox can't come back in loss
» Thome and father making trek together
» Quentin gets rare day off before break
Brought to you by feed dot informer dot com


  » Friday, Aug. 29, 2008, Open Line - Jacksonville Journal Courier
  » Twenty runners are 20-for-20 in the 20k - New Haven Register (subscription)
  » Millions spent on prison slated for closure - KHQA
  » The War Against Luis - La Prensa San Diego
  » Northern students may foot the bill for repairs - Sauk Valley Newspapers
  » JJC prepares for the worst during shooter drill - Morris Daily Herald
  » Three area state parks among list to close up - Morris Daily Herald
  » Administration lays off 450 employees - Kankakee Daily Journal
  » Budget ax falls on Hennepin Canal, Illini State - LaSalle News Tribune
  » New Trier To Open One Campus For School Boycott - CBS2 Chicago
Succoured by FeedInformer


  » Winfrey to open season with 150 Olympians
  » Police destroy $1.2 million worth of pot
  » No charges filed after 55 dogs seized near Arthur
  » Litchfield man killed in backhoe accident
  » Zook finds his kicker, at least for this week
  » Potatoes
  » Peoria Livestock
  » Attorney says second client was abused by priest
  » Stocks fall on personal income data
  » Who would fill Obama's Senate seat?
Succoured by feed dot informer dot com

  » Oprah opens season with Phelps, 150 Olympians
  » Moto’s Brown has millions of reasons to see cell phone spinoff
  » Argonne nabs funds to market research
  » NBC5 Video: Barack Obama's opening comments
  » SF firm courts Mayer Brown again
Brought to you by feed.informer.com


  » Jury acquits former Marine in killing of Iraqis
  » Helping others realize 'Hispanic American Dream'
  » Can Drew get fair trial in Will County?
  » Park District faces up to 300 job cuts
  » Suspected 'Time Bandit' held without bail
  » City plumbing inspector convicted of taking bribe
  » Haircuts on hold as history unfolds at Obama's barbershop
  » Studies: Students party hard at 21
  » Two U.S. gold medalists to be on Wheaties box
  » Diaper saves life of boy plunging from window
Provided by Feed Informer


  » Bears cornerback Tillman details daughter's heart transplant surgery
  » $400,000 bail for 2 teens charged in armed bank heists
  » Obey city's curfew law: Police, school and clergy urge
  » Illinois GOP says Palin pick surprising but bold
  » Illinois GOP says Palin pick surprising but bold
  » Lake Shore Drive resurfacing set to expand
  » LSD project expands to northbound lanes
  » Bolingbrook top cop new chief of Naperville parks
  » Truck crushes Berwyn garage worker
  » Illinois convention delegats jockey in Denver
Generated by FeedInformer


  » Illinoisans Say the Long Wait for Obama Speech was Worth It
  » Democrats Leaving Denver in Droves
  » McCain Picks Palin as Running Mate
  » Chicago Republicans React to Obama's Convention Speech
  » Obama Speech A Hit In Gary
  » DNC Speeches: Jan Schakowsky
  » Hundreds of Chicagoans to Protest in St. Paul
  » Obama Accepts Democratic Presidential Nomination
  » Instant Replay Arrives at Wrigley
  » DNC Speeches: Luis Gutierrez
Generated by feed.informer.com


  » Decision on cutback vote objections to wait another week
  » No charges filed after 55 dogs seized near Arthur
  » Talk to Us: Comcast planning download limits
  » Litchfield man killed in backhoe accident
  » Lions’ new leader, others ready for Week 1
  » Thief takes copper from air conditioner
  » Two teens arrested after alleged robbery
  » Speculation over McCain veep turns to Alaska gov.
  » Vote now for the Pet of the Year
  » AAA: Less travel expected
From feed dot informer dot com


  » NIU faculty member to lead workshop at SIUC on violence
  » Family completes renovations to SIUC Student Center lounge
  » Obama says he'll fix Washington - Nominee addresses huge crowd in Denver
  » Delicious Du Quoin
  » Shawnee National Forest prepares to raise fees
Upholded by FeedInformer


» St. Charles teen accused in fatal DUI may be jailed
» Winfield girl hit by car
» Des Plaines' first family prepares to leave
» Addison Park District fixing storm-damaged golf dome
» Bond set for 2nd man in Link petition forgery case
Provided by FeedInformer


  » GOPUSA ILLINOIS Daily Clips - August 29, 2008
  » Governor Makes Another Stupid Decision
  » Dick Durbin Speaks to the Illinois Delegation
  » GOPUSA ILLINOIS Daily Clips - August 28, 2008
  » Jackson: Democrats will Reconcile, Unify
  » Rod Blagojevich Speaks to Illinois Delegates
  » Dan Hynes Speaks before Illinois Delegates
  » Gaines' perspective
  » Mayor Daley Talks about Unity
  » Radical Make Over for Chicago Tribune
From feed.informer.com

» LaHood: Ill. 336 from Macomb to Peoria vital for region - Quincy Herald Whig
» • Obama camp says Palin lacks experience - KXRM
» Reaction to McCain choosing Palin as running mate - The Associated Press
» McCain Spokeman Tucker Bounds Is Interviewed on CNN - CQPolitics.com
» Palin's age, inexperience may undercut best Republican attack on Obama - The Canadian Press
» Will residents witness Obama make history - Bolingbrook Sun
» GOP VP Choice: McCain Ready to Run With Palin - CQPolitics.com
» McCain on Palin: “She’s Exactly Who I Need” - CBS News
» Conservative Palin brings record of reform, Republicans say - CNN
» Jesse Jackson Jr.'s Tears In Denver Show Strength - Huffington Post
Provided by Feed Informer

» TV audience swells Thursday - Denver Post
» Analysis: Obama shows grit and guts - Denver Post
» And If Obama Loses? - Post Chronicle
» Palin has taken historic steps - Newsday
» McCain takes big gamble in choosing Palin - McClatchy Washington Bureau
» McCain picks female Alaska governor as running-mate - InTheNews.co.uk
» NARN, State Fair #4: The Palin Edition - Hot Air
» Dems here give Obama's speech a big 'thumbs up' - Greater Milwaukee Today
» Ms. Alaska - New York Times
» Campaign & Election News - Covering Key Races Around the Country - Swing State Project
Maintained by feed.informer.com

» Ben Affleck's Unconventional Convention Week - People Magazine
» DU reports from the Democratic National Convention, August 25-28 2008 - Democratic Underground
» US: New media makes an impact at political conventions - editorsweblog.org
» Campaign notebook for Aug. 29, 2008 - DesMoinesRegister.com
» Donor courtship thriving - Denver Post
» Dem dilemma: Attack but protect image - Denver Post
» 'The Change We Need Is Coming' - Washington Post
» Another man, another dream - St. Louis Post-Dispatch
» Watching the Speech from a Watch Party - Washington Post
» The Clintons: a stage with no exit - USA Today
Powered by Feed Informer

    » Sen. Brady Accuses Governor of Mis-management
    » PI @ DNC: Interview With Rep. Phil Hare
    » Shut Up & Sing
    » Jewish Republicans Applaud Palin Pick for VP
    » Illinois Conservatives Heart Palin
    » Sierra Club Responds To State Park Closures
    » Trib: Uptown LSD Resurfacing Expanding to NB Lanes
    » Why It Couldn’t Be Pawlenty
    » Only One Former Legislator on National Ballot
    » Tightening Belts in Oregon
    » Danielle Quayle?
    » International Day of Peace events in Springfield
In Association with feed dot informer dot com




Header Photos...
Wayne Bretl
&