Subscribe to Capitol Fax      Advertise Here     Contact Rich Miller
To subscribe to Capitol Fax, click here. Subscriptions are $350 per year. To advertise on the Capitol Fax Blog, please click here.
Most underreported story of the month

Thursday, Feb 8, 2007

The lead story in Capitol Fax yesterday was about widespread rumors that the governor will call for a “gross receipts tax” on Illinois business to pay for all of his ideas. Business lobbyists are gearing up like crazy to fight the idea, which the governor’s office won’t confirm even exists.

I didn’t notice yesterday that Small Newspapers also had a very good story on this topic until the reporter pointed it out to me. So, here it is

Gov. Rod Blagojevich is reportedly considering a gross receipts tax on Illinois businesses to pay for a plan to provide state-subsidized health insurance to state residents without coverage. […]

Depending on its final form, a gross receipts tax could hit every business in the state, from barbers to manufacturers. The barber, for example, would pay the gross receipts tax on whatever he took in, likely apart from any income tax he might have to pay.

Even if the business was losing money, the gross receipts tax could apply.

Business lobbyists contend a gross receipts would be passed to consumers, and in the case of manufactured products could add significantly to the cost of finished goods.

“You could go from your raw material to your final product and it could get taxed five times in-between.” said Kim Maisch, Illinois director of the National Federation of Independent Businesses. “The concept of a gross-receipts tax is really anti-free enterprise.”

The tax revenue estimate I heard earlier this week was over $9 billion a year.

Thoughts?

- posted by Rich Miller


40 Comments
  1. - Carl Nyberg - Thursday, Feb 8, 07 @ 9:10 am:

    If a gross receipts tax is superior to an income tax or a sales tax, why isn’t Illinois using it already? Why aren’t other states?

    If the tax makes less sense than the sales tax or income tax, does it make sense to enact it just so a politician can say, “I didn’t raise the sales tax or the income tax”?


  2. - If It Walks Like a Duck... - Thursday, Feb 8, 07 @ 9:14 am:

    Wow, read the comments following the linked article, too. Looks like they ain’t forgetting in Forgotonia.


  3. - Voice of Reason - Thursday, Feb 8, 07 @ 9:15 am:

    The article in Small Newspapers presents only the negative side of the gross receipts idea, and printed comments only from the “business community.” Given that our current business taxes are inefficient and idiosyncratic (for example, how many businessess actually pay any/substantial state corporate income taxes?), and that our sales tax applies to only the sales of goods, which is a declining sector compared to services, why shouldn’t we consider an alternative system of taxation? Many other states are–recently Ohio instituted a form of gross receipts tax, and they are under debate in other states–and several states already have gross receipts taxes, instead of corporate income taxes. Some also have a sales tax and some don’t. The point is that the powerful business lobbies have a vested interest in painting the most negative picture of this, without any analysis of actual impact. A low rate gross receipts is unlikely to result in prices that are 10-15% higher–and a rigorous economic analysis would be required to verify any tax impact assumptions.


  4. - DOWNSTATE - Thursday, Feb 8, 07 @ 9:29 am:

    All the increases on small businesses the last 4 years,high rates on comp insurance,almost double utilities and now a special tax.Two questions!How many small business owners will throw in the towel and how many corporations will find it cheaper to move out of state.This current bunch of Democrats want to crate a welfare state to increase votes for the party but it soon becomes a liabity.Didn’t their parents teach them that ‘nothing is free.


  5. - Voice of Reason - Thursday, Feb 8, 07 @ 9:34 am:

    Indeed, nothing IS free, including education, transportation infrastructure and health care–all of which benefit the public good and not only select individuals.

    A gross receipts tax can be structured so that it exempts the first $000,000 of receipts, in order to protect small businesses. And in addition to considering the elimination of the corporate income tax, the state could rescind some of the fees that have distortionary economic effects.

    NO ONE wants their taxes to go up, for any reason. That is why government is not the “private market” since in that case the public good is not served by purely individual best interests.


  6. - fedup dem - Thursday, Feb 8, 07 @ 9:38 am:

    This is a disgutingly-regressive tax idea, one so bad that I wouldn’t even expect it from the most rabid Republicans around, much less an alleged Democratic progressive like Gov. Sleazy.


  7. - Truthful James - Thursday, Feb 8, 07 @ 9:39 am:

    Desperation is the mother of all chaos.

    Perhaps they could tax campaign contributions and bribes as well.


  8. - Commonsense in Illinois - Thursday, Feb 8, 07 @ 9:59 am:

    Truthful James has a point. Why wouldn’t contributions to a political campaign fund be considered part of gross receipts? (Methinks the Governor just blanched…)


  9. - VanillaMan - Thursday, Feb 8, 07 @ 10:12 am:

    The last thing Illinois needs is another tax.

    Blagojevich knows this. That is why he has been promising no new taxes.

    This administration is driving away businesses and forcing up the cost of living. This is bad government.

    Stop promising freebies for votes. Start governing like adults.


  10. - FESTER - Thursday, Feb 8, 07 @ 10:14 am:

    Would that include contract lobbiest gross receipts? Hmmmm.


  11. - Carl Nyberg - Thursday, Feb 8, 07 @ 10:35 am:

    Reason, your logic would be more convincing if the gross receipts tax was part of a simplification package that was revenue neutral.

    But as proposed it sounds like a way for the Blagojevich administration to get $9 billion/year in new revenue while being able to claim “no increase of sales or income taxes”.


  12. - Anon from BB - Thursday, Feb 8, 07 @ 10:54 am:

    This sounds like a value-added tax.

    Bad idea, especially for the Dems. The people that will be most hurt by this tax are the ones that can least afford goods and services.

    Just another reason why I’m planning to leave the state after I get my grad degree…


  13. - Bill - Thursday, Feb 8, 07 @ 10:59 am:

    Sounds like A PLAN!!!


  14. - RMW Stanford - Thursday, Feb 8, 07 @ 11:23 am:

    This a flat out bad idea for the state, Illinois has over the Blagojevich term has developed an increasingly hostile climate to business, this will just add to it and hurt economic and job growth here . Its one thing to tax business on there profits, but its another thing to tax them on their revenues, so that business that do not earn a cent in profit and suffer loses will also have an added tax liability. I am going to guess that the plan is to add this tax on top of the sales and corporate income tax. In the long run taxes are paid by people, not by firms, even if the tax results only in a prices increase of 105-15%, what would ended being a 10%-15% across the board price increase for business in the state Illinois would have the effect of lowering the real income of everyone in Illinois, rich, middle class and poor likely. Would have the large effect on the poorest sections of society, who spend almost all of their income on goods and services and in turn would see their real income decline by more than the middle and upper class who usually save and invest some of their income.


  15. - This Guy - Thursday, Feb 8, 07 @ 11:29 am:

    Wow. Some plan.

    “Let’s stick it to the businesses who serve the people so we can say we’re not sticking it to the people we say we’re serving.”

    Business as usual.

    “Bill”: I admire your steadfast loyalty, but Stevie Wonder could see through this snake-oil salesman.

    Q: What’s the chief physical difference between Blago loyalists and blind people?

    A: Blind people have souls.


  16. - anon - Thursday, Feb 8, 07 @ 11:34 am:

    A way around this is to not make anything in Illinois and only pay the tax when it finally comes to the state in the form of a finished product for sale. A gross receipts tax will be at a very small percentage, usually under 1%, so that should avoid a heavy increase in the final price of a certain product. Also, the higher the price of a particular product that has this tax hidden in the final price, the more the state sales tax will bring in. Unless you’re captive to buying products entirely made and sold in this state, it would be cheaper to just buy it in another state or only buy products in this state made in another state. But who really knows what those are. Go by the retail price.


  17. - Truthful James - Thursday, Feb 8, 07 @ 11:58 am:

    The hard cheese is taxing businesses who are losing money already. At the margin a restaurant going out of business as it tries to build it revenues over time to breakeven, is going to put people on the street.


  18. - RMW Stanford - Thursday, Feb 8, 07 @ 12:05 pm:

    “A way around this is to not make anything in Illinois and only pay the tax when it finally comes to the state in the form of a finished product for sale”

    It will certainly encourage that, along with encouraging firms and consumers to make large purchases in neighboring states, instead of in Illinois. As it already been mention this will push business that are at the margin and trying to build up a costumer base out of the market and may well make some business that have a lower profit margin, unprofitable. This will be flat out bad for the state’s economy and the poorer sections of the state populace will be hit the hardest.


  19. - Gene Parmesan - Thursday, Feb 8, 07 @ 12:09 pm:

    I’d love to see if this will apply to agriculture in Illinois. If it does, farmers are going to be hit hard. Farmers take in a lot of revenue, but don’t necessarily make a large profit due to the large costs involved. This idea will destroy rural economies, as farmers can hardly ‘move’ their land out of Illinois.

    Who else will this not apply to as well? Whoever can cough up the most cash?

    This idea may be just what the Republican Party needs in Illinois. Business groups will all get together and fight this with furor.


  20. - Love the madness - Thursday, Feb 8, 07 @ 12:16 pm:

    Indiana, Wisconsin, Iowa, Missouri and Kentucky all support this idea. They welcome all the Illinois businesses that will be coming to their states!


  21. - Utility Infielder - Thursday, Feb 8, 07 @ 12:48 pm:

    Voice, all good points. But..first what’s the chances they will structure the bill with the protections for the small business’. Secondly, retail has shrunk, especially near the boarders. Why do we think that service businesses wouldn’t follow. My doctor moved a few blocks over the boarder because of insurance reasons. Now my mechanic, accountant,masseuse ect. will follow.


  22. - Truthful James - Thursday, Feb 8, 07 @ 12:56 pm:

    Gentlemen (and ladies):

    We are all wrong.

    The most underreported story has to do with the removal of pork from the budget on a large scale, the development of efficiencies in government operations, the use of increasing sales and income tax revenues (resulting from the Bush tax cuts) to be assigned to capital and pension funding rather than hiring more people.

    Didn’t hear about that? Neither did I. Which must be why it is clearly underreported.


  23. - Citizen A - Thursday, Feb 8, 07 @ 12:57 pm:

    …”a plan to provide state-subsidized health insurance to state residents”… - If the state is going to provide health insurance then businesses would be well served to discontinue providing group plans. Shift the entire health costs to the taxpayers ? The governor is STUPID ! Like a little boy playing with matches . . . or in his case, himself.


  24. - Lovie's Leather - Thursday, Feb 8, 07 @ 1:09 pm:

    It is pure insanity. It is an invisible sales tax, and I just bet Bill won’t understand why his $10 haircuts turn into 12, or 15 bucks. He will probably blame it on business.


  25. - Yellow Dog Democrat - Thursday, Feb 8, 07 @ 1:13 pm:

    This is Mr. “No New Taxes”, right? Now that Rod’s $9 billion tax increase on businesses and consumers is floating around out there, the more modest education funding reform plan that includes property tax relief and closes our pension debt must look pretty good to the business community.


  26. - Citizen A - Thursday, Feb 8, 07 @ 1:18 pm:

    The gov should have his numbers guys at CMS and BOB figure out how much $$$ businesses need to cover their costs and then simply confiscate the rest. That apparently is the democrat master plan, both state and federal. Just DO it and put a stop to this drip drip drip chinese water torture approach to “governing”.


  27. - i d - Thursday, Feb 8, 07 @ 1:26 pm:

    Governor Foolish Ultimate Politician of Madness.


  28. - Truthful James - Thursday, Feb 8, 07 @ 2:03 pm:

    Citizen A –

    That was the old Ted Kennedy plan…The government has the right to 100% of GNP and all taxes thereon. Then it can decide whhat part of the national income may be delivered to its citizens. It really is simpler that way.


  29. - Guy Fawkes - Thursday, Feb 8, 07 @ 2:58 pm:

    What happens when there are no businesses left to tax? Don’t worry, Governor Blagojevich won’t, he’ll be long gone.


  30. - steve schnorf - Thursday, Feb 8, 07 @ 3:00 pm:

    I think Bill is right. If it is proposed by the Governor, it at least represents a plan; in fact, the only plan. Perhaps it will elicit counter-proposals or alternatives from some of our other leaders. Until Meeks re-introduced 750 today (so I heard) not another government leader had suggested any plan to deal with our structural budget imbalance.


  31. - Truthful James - Thursday, Feb 8, 07 @ 3:24 pm:

    Steve –

    Thanks for admitting that 750 is not a supposed tax swap, but merely a way to increase taxes for a supposed structural imbalance.

    Still looking for the unreported stories to which I earlier referred.

    When a “balanced budget” can be adopted and specific appropriations do not include the windfall each year from increasing income and sales taxes, it would seem that the structural imbalance lies on the side of surplus — until, that is, the covert appropriations using up all that surplus are made to benefit the governor playing Johnny Appleseed, and the incumbents providing much quid for a future quo.


  32. - Concerned Voter - Thursday, Feb 8, 07 @ 3:33 pm:

    Wow, hit the small business owners with increases in the minimum wage and then with this, we’ll be seeing more empty shops & restaurants.


  33. - the old republican - Thursday, Feb 8, 07 @ 7:17 pm:

    Didn’t Laura Lunt Prussing, the Dem. one term state rep.from Champaign have an idea like that or taxing about everything in sight a few years ago?


  34. - Citizen A - Thursday, Feb 8, 07 @ 7:20 pm:

    Maybe we don’t need a PLAN - Just don’t spend the state into poverty! This is Blago’s crisis - without him we might not be in such a terrible financial delemna. Hope Mike and Emil have the balls to reign in this megalomeniac. God help us if they don’t. Blago is NOT the solution - he IS the problem.


  35. - Nostradamus - Thursday, Feb 8, 07 @ 8:33 pm:

    We don’t need a new tax. If the state would collect sales tax on magazines and newspapers,we
    would have plenty of $$$$$ for education. Then we
    wouldn’t have to sell the lotto and tollways. All
    the states that are contiguous to us charge sales
    tax on those two items. Just think of all the
    magazines that are sold daily, the subsriptions
    and all the papers. Mega millions !!!!


  36. - Bill Baar - Friday, Feb 9, 07 @ 7:02 am:

    Wow, beware the progressives.


  37. - Concerned Taxpayer - Friday, Feb 9, 07 @ 7:59 am:

    Gross receipts taxes are discredited taxes that are making a comeback solely because they allow a state to hide the tax burden, either by embedding it into business to business transactions or by using the gross receipts tax to collect revenue from “outsiders.”

    Gross receipts taxes used to be very widespread but most states repealed them (including Indiana as recently as 2002) because they were so harmful.

    These two articles contain numerous economic reasons why they should be rejected:

    http://www.taxfoundation.org/publications/show/2180.html
    http://www.taxfoundation.org/publications/show/2061.html


  38. - Aris - Tuesday, Jun 5, 07 @ 4:42 pm:

    Cool!


  39. - Augustinos - Tuesday, Jun 5, 07 @ 8:28 pm:

    Nice…


  40. - Georges - Thursday, Jun 7, 07 @ 2:24 pm:

    Cool.


Sorry, comments for this post are now closed.


ON THE BLOG TODAY...
* This just in... No delay in Blagojevich trial
* Question of the day
* *** UPDATED x1 *** Raw videos of Madigan, Quinn and Cullerton
* Blog commenter wisdom
* Statehouse roundup
* Kirk: On the way to making Obama a one-termer
* Morning Shorts
* Morning video - Noonan shaves his head for charity
* SUBSCRIBERS ONLY - Today's edition of Capitol Fax (use all CAPS in password)
** Yesterday's blog posts

Support The Capitol Fax Blog
Visit our advertisers...

Search This Blog...

Search the 96th General Assembly By Bill Number
(example: HB0001)

Search the 96th General Assembly By Keyword

Quick Links


Main Menu
Home
Illinois
YouTube
Pundit rankings
Obama
Subscriber Content
Durbin
Burris
Polls

Archives
March 2010
February 2010
January 2010
December 2009
November 2009
October 2009
September 2009
August 2009
July 2009
June 2009
May 2009
April 2009
March 2009
February 2009
January 2009
December 2008
November 2008
October 2008
September 2008
August 2008
July 2008
June 2008
May 2008
April 2008
March 2008
February 2008
January 2008
December 2007
November 2007
October 2007
September 2007
August 2007
July 2007
June 2007
May 2007
April 2007
March 2007
February 2007
January 2007
December 2006
November 2006
October 2006
September 2006
August 2006
July 2006
June 2006
May 2006
April 2006
March 2006
February 2006
January 2006
December 2005
April 2005
March 2005
February 2005
January 2005
December 2004
November 2004
October 2004

Blog*Spot Archives
November 2005
October 2005
September 2005
August 2005
July 2005
June 2005
May 2005

Syndication

RSS Feed 2.0
Comments RSS 2.0
WordPress
 

  
  » Qik Video Camera app disappears from App Store
  » iPhone Developers Now Able to Schedule App Store Sales in Advance
  » Malware found on another HTC Magic smartphone
  » Review: Rafter for iPhone
  » MacRumors: Apple Banning Screen Protectors in Retail Stores?

  » The High Price of Convenience Foods [Saving Money]
  » Parallels Outdoes VMware Fusion on Most Benchmarks [Virtualization]
  » Cancel a Print Job Without Waiting Years [Annoyances]
  » CapSee Notifies You When Caps Lock is On [Downloads]
  » The Windows 8 Concept Desktop [Featured Desktop]

» Castro hit by pitch, leaves game
» Bullpen decision could be tough
» Mark Teahen Community Projection Results
» Treatment Bound: A Minnesota Twins Preview
» Nix eyes final White Sox utility spot

 
     


  » Governor Quinn Signs Bill to Move Illinois' Primar....
  » Illinois Senate Candidate Mines Health Care Opposi....
  » Illinois Police Institute Proposes Budget That Wou....
  » In Missouri Senate race, meet the `outsiders' - As....
  » Put a stop to red light law - News-Gazette..
  » Quinn is trying to sell tax increase to lawmakers ....
  » Popular Programs Among Proposed Ag Cuts - WGIL Rad....
  » There are ways to get answers from public official....
  » Quinn urges Dems to support tax increase - WLS..
  » Senator calls on state to issue expense checks to ....


  » Judge rejects request to delay Blagojevich trial
  » Indiana surpasses Mississippi in gaming revenues
  » Abuse settlements cost Urbana schools $2.6 million
  » U. of Ill. studies nematodes in biofuel crops
  » Judge refuses to delay Blagojevich trial
  » Kraft to cut salt in food by an average of 10% by 2012
  » Federal Signal to combine units in new division
  » Boeing must update 777's software: FAA
  » Wintrust raises $27.5M more in share sale
  » Oprah must defend defamation suit: judge

  » Trade show organizers meet with McCormick Place's labor leaders
  » ShoreBank names David Vitale executive chairman
  » United pilots, flight attendants pick St. Paddy's Day to picket Aer Lingus venture
  » McDonald's wants to sell $1 drinks
  » Cubs want to put lighted billboard in bleachers


  » Minnesota man caught in Chicago after selling wife for sex
  » Motorcyclist in critical condition after rear-ending semi on Kennedy
  » Police commander charged with harassing cop
  » Judge denies request for delay in Blagojevich trial
  » West suburban man charged with attempting to hit policeman with car
  » 19 displaced by apartment fire in Manhattan
  » Big billboard in left field at Wrigley?
  » Chicago man to plead guilty in terror case
  » Ex-judge on Fire Dept. case
  » Indiana man jailed in crash that claimed life of construction worker


  » Sainthood for founder of Chicago's first black parish?
  » 'TCF Bandit' suspected in string of bank robberies ordered held
  » State primary elections moving back to March
  » Man accused of pimping wife on Craigslist
  » Developer's bribery trial winds down
  » Chicago police commander arrested for harassment
  » DuPage Water Commission treasurer quits after scathing report
  » Illinois primary election moved back to March after Scott Lee Cohen debacle, record low turnout
  » Finally, green earns cachet
  » Playboy editor, model sue Google and Facebook over photos


  » Judge: Blagojevich Trial Won't Be Delayed
  » Sebelius in Chicago to Rally Support of Health Care Bill
  » Inside and Out: The Mission and the Money of the Department of Juvenile Justice
  » Reports: Daley Questioned By FBI
  » Chicago Police Defend Use of Taser on Chicago Public School Student
  » Chicago Unemployment Rate Increases
  » Blagojevich Attorneys Back in Court in Attempt to Push Back Trial
  » Region's Jobless Rate Jumps in January
  » Support for Health Care Bill Shaky Among Illinois Congressmen
  » Guilty Plea Expected in Mumbai Terror Case


  » Judge again rejects motion to dismiss Watkins' visitation case
  » Quinn on Aging lease: Don't 'hold your breath'
  » Quinn signs bill moving Illinois primary back to March
  » Republicans will get top spot on Sangamon Co. ballot
  » House strongly rejects electing U of I board
  » Judge says print can't be tested in Slover case
  » Judge refuses to delay Blagojevich trial
  » Peoria house fire kills mother, son
  » Lawmaker praises Quinn for reviewing Aging lease
  » Business alliance meets Friday


  » New phone scam reported in Williamson County
  » Quinn signs bill moving back primary
  » Howard beats SIC men at national tournament
  » Lawmakers: Don't elect University of Illinois trustees
  » Jonesboro cuts 10 teachers; expects majority to be rehired


» Military: We still want bin Laden alive
» Quinn to sign bill moving back Ill. primary
» Madigan: The party, not Quinn, will make lt. gov. decision
» Bond set at $3 million for woman in Schaumburg hotel shooting
» Priest accused of sex abuse collapses in court


  » Sen. Hutchinson: "We haven't been doing that for the last 25-30 years"
  » GOPUSA ILLINOIS Daily Clips - March 17, 2010
  » Conversation starters
  » List of demands
  » GOPUSA ILLINOIS Daily Clips - March 16, 2010

» House tax writers approve small biz jobs pack..
» Congress Considers Bill To Help Veterans Own ..
» ObamaCare whip count(s): Pelosi in trouble? -..
» No, You Can't Have a Pony - Philadelphia City..
» Who's Going to Lead the Charge on Immigration..
» Detroit to Close One-Quarter of Schools - CBS..
» Jerry Costello Flips into the Stupak Bloc - F..
» New Health Care Whip Count: Still 191 Yes, 20..
» Survey Indicates Doctors' Opposition to Obama..
» Dan Lipinski, Melissa Bean, Luis Gutierrez: I..

» Gage Urges Senators to Defend, Call for TSO C.....
» Protecting Refugees: an American Commitment a.....
» A Public Option Would Sure Fix Democrats' CBO.....
» Senate Democrats Circulating Letter to House .....
» House Democrats want guarantee Senate will vo.....

    » Poll watch, 1960s
    » The Wire(s) in Denver
    » Sen. Hutchinson: "We haven't been doing that for the last 25-30 years"
    » `Deem and pass.' So what?
    » The divide
    » Those Wacky Out-of-Towners II
    » Del Valle's Plans
    » Judge Rejects Request To Delay Blagojevich's Trial
    » Democracy Denied: The Obama Chart
    » O'BRIEN: Blame the Cosmic Rays, Guys


Header Photos...
Wayne Bretl & UIS


Hosted by MCS