Home | Subscribers Only | AIM | Contact | Mobile | Subscribe | Classifieds | Calendar | Resumes
To subscribe to Capitol Fax, click here. Subscriptions are $350 per year. To advertise on the Capitol Fax Blog, please click here.
Chicago’s coming “Ameren” crisis

Thursday, Jun 28, 2007

* As the deadline approaches for mass transit service cuts and fare increases, Chicago and suburban legislators are getting more and more calls from frantic constituents who are wondering how they’ll get to work. A million and a half people ride the CTA every day and lots more depend on the RTA and PACE. Needless to say, the panic levels are rising in legislative circles as more and more constituents become convinced that they hold the keys to solving this pending crisis.

Without a solution, the mass transit situation has the potential to be every bit as politically explosive for Chicago-area legislators as the Ameren rate hikes have been for Downstaters. So, while yesterday’s CTA union agreement is welcome news, it puts additional pressure on the Statehouse to come up with a real funding solution.

The agreement calls for 10,200 employees represented by 17 unions to receive 3 percent pay raises during the first three years and 3.5 percent in the final two years. The CTA has also agreed to double its pension fund contribution — from 6 percent of payroll to 12 percent to satisfy the Legislature’s demand that a pension fund now 34 percent funded reach 90 percent by 2059.

In exchange for those pay raises and a no-layoff clause, active employees will contribute 3 percent toward retiree health care and double — from 3 percent to 6 percent — their pension contribution.

Employees hired after Jan. 1, 2008, would become eligible for a full pension at age 64 instead of 55.

Illinois’ auditor general would be represented on an 11-member “pension reform trust” and on a seven-member health care trust that would sustain itself through investments and contributions so the CTA could wash its hands of the headache.

The bottom line for CTA unions is an agreement that would force bus drivers and motormen to lose money during the first year, break even in the second and finally start making money in the third year.

* And it turns out that the CTA needs far more money than previously believed…

It had been believed the CTA would need $100 million or $125 million next year to avert a crisis, but CTA President Ron Huberman on Wednesday put the figure at about $200 million to cover health-care and pension expenses and other operating-cost increases.

* Mayor Daley tossed the ball in Springfield’s court yesterday…

“Now it’s time for the governor and the General Assembly to follow through.”

* The governor supports giving the CTA $100 million, which it now turns out will only meet half the need.

The problem with Blagojevich’s plan is that it uses precious state dollars and would only send cash to the CTA, while mass transit advocates are pushing a proposal that would impose a tiny quarter percent sales tax in the areas served by the CTA and the RTA and a real estate transfer tax in Chicago. That proposal would generate far more money over many more years and would help solve the system’s structural problems. But Blagojevich has promised to veto the legislation if it ever reaches his desk…

House Majority Leader Barbara Flynn Currie (D-Chicago) said she doesn’t want to see the proposal for a quarter-cent increase in the regional sales tax called for a vote unless legislative leaders can persuade Blagojevich to not veto it.

“People are not going to want to be on the line for the bill if it isn’t going to happen,” Currie said.

- posted by Rich Miller


15 Comments
  1. - Bill - Thursday, Jun 28, 07 @ 9:09 am:

    The constituents are right. They do hold the key. Quit fooling around. Raise taxes and support the level of services that the Illinois public demands. The employees have done more than their part. These types of concessions are unheard of. There is no excuse for allowing this situation to fester any further.


  2. - fed up - Thursday, Jun 28, 07 @ 9:18 am:

    I never thought bill wold say a semiresonable thing but the tax increase for transportation is needed. I still believe the CTA has far to many middle managers and can be run much more efficantly more needs to be done to fix the structural problems in the cta RTA and metra like merging them into one agency and getting rid of some burecrates.


  3. - GA Watcher - Thursday, Jun 28, 07 @ 9:30 am:

    What’s up, Bill? Not standing behind your man, Milorad, and his pledge to veto any general tax increases?


  4. - Commonsense in Illinois - Thursday, Jun 28, 07 @ 9:44 am:

    I commented on this story yesterday, but it was buried pretty deep. I’m not sure it’s a great idea to put the Auditor General on the Pension Board. It sets up an immediate conflict of interest if the General Assembly, the only entity to whom the General reports, orders an audit of the CTA. As far as the tax goes, it’s either that or a pretty sizable fare increase…choose wisely (as the knight said in the Indiana Jones movie).


  5. - green eyeshade - Thursday, Jun 28, 07 @ 9:58 am:

    Actually, Rich, every cta and rta budget presentation has included the exploding pension costs ($270mm in 2009) as part of the shortfall. The 200m number is included in the sales tax/rta reform bill passed out of the House mass transit committee. Since the union deal is over five years, it has to address the pension shortfall


  6. - Leroy - Thursday, Jun 28, 07 @ 10:05 am:

    The City of Chicago is the biggest (by far) beneficiary of the CTA - via higher property taxes due to higher property values, and due to higher sales taxes.

    Make the city pay more than the $3 million a year it is currently giving the CTA. The city probably makes $3 million a week in tax revenue because of the CTA.


  7. - Captain America - Thursday, Jun 28, 07 @ 10:24 am:

    I agree completely with Rich’s Ameren/mass transit analogy.

    Julie Hamos came up with a modest sales tax solution that with bipartian support that resolves the metropolitan transit funding crisis. Blago has been and is the only impediment to gerring this done.

    Rod’s really behind the eight ball on the mass transit issue, unlike the Ameren situation, in which he has been passive and become irrelevant.


  8. - Tom - Thursday, Jun 28, 07 @ 10:34 am:

    Has Hamos done a roll call? I bet there aren’t 45 votes for the sales tax increase. ROd isn’t coming off it. It would be political suicide since he has repeated his no tax stance 100’s of times. Hamos should come up with something else. Otherwise it’s just uber liberal legislator getting people’s hopes up for nothing.


  9. - plutocrat03 - Thursday, Jun 28, 07 @ 11:09 am:

    The defined benefit pension system is the ruination of any governmental entity.

    The root cause is that many years ago, governmental employees were truly poorly compensated. In order to get employees, the current, overly generous pension systems were developed. Independently, salaries were raised to the point where in many cases governmental compensation substantially exceeds private compensation. (I know of a specific entity where the position of receptionist commands a starting salary of more than 30K with full benefits.) Overly generous pay along with spectacular pensions is a dangerous mixture when compiling a budget.

    When you layer on the cost of the pensions, starting at age 55, the ‘average’ state employee has the interest income of more than $1,000,000 at their disposal. (Just ask your friendly annuity salesman how much a policy yielding the pension income would cost, including annual cola increases.) I realize that there is an employee contribution to the pension plan, but that amount of money would not provide 20% of the resources needed deliver the monthly benefit.

    The days of the defined benefit pension plan are going to end soon because it is unrealistic to provide this type of costly benefit to the state workers while those who pay the taxes have no such benefit of their own.


  10. - patient advocate - Thursday, Jun 28, 07 @ 11:38 am:

    I respectfully disagree with the last post regarding defined benefit pensions. The IMRF pension system is a defined benefit system and is fully funded, because employers made the scheduled payments they were supposed to make. It is not in any sort of crisis and provides good value for employers, workers, and the public.

    The state pension systems are in a hole because over many years political leaders failed to provide for the employer contribution. They are not in a hole because benefits are excessive. The average retired state employee has a pension of about $18,000.

    A defined contribution system for state employees was attempted in Nebraska. It was dropped because participants earned a poor return on investment when compared to funds put in the state’s defined benefit pension fund.

    The fact that defined contribution pensions have become dominant in the private sector is not a good reason for converting the public pensions. Defined contribution pensions are part of a general risk shift from employers to workers that is going to leave many middle class families much worse off when they face retirement.


  11. - plutocrat03 - Thursday, Jun 28, 07 @ 12:38 pm:

    Part of the reason the retirement of the middle class it threatened it the insatiable requirements of the government. Property taxes (dollars, not rates) have been rising at more than 7% per year. That means the Property tax will DOUBLE in 10 years. I have a neighbor who pays half of his social security in property taxes. Why should he be subsidising a system where 100K pensions are common. Seems like he needs the subsidy.

    Defined benefit has become dominant in the public sector because they rely on the infinite pocketbook of the taxpayer. After all these years, perhaps it it no longer infinite.

    The private sector has long recognized that the financial exposure of a defined benefit plan is unquantifiable and as such can kill an organization.

    Of course a governmental organization does not fear dissolution if its legacy costs are excessive


  12. - patient advocate - Thursday, Jun 28, 07 @ 2:09 pm:

    Yes, property taxes are too high. That’s because this state has an unfair and regressive system of taxation that needs to be fixed.

    However, cutting government will not make the middle class more secure. The middle class depends on Social Security for retirement income, Medicare for retiree health care, Medicaid for nursing home care, etc. The fact is, government is central to the retirement security of the middle class.


  13. - plutocrat03 - Thursday, Jun 28, 07 @ 6:06 pm:

    I must respectfully disagree. I do not want to eliminate essential services, I want to improve the efficiency of how the services are delivered.

    Cutting the fat out of the government while still delivering the necessary services should be the goal. The changes in productivity that the private sector has achieved need to be put into place in the public sector.

    This means increase departmental functions to that of the private sector or the jobs get outsourced.

    Unfortunately the managers who are in place do not know how to manage their workloads in any other way than they have. They have no incentive to do better.


  14. - Peoria Pete - Thursday, Jun 28, 07 @ 6:29 pm:

    FYI- property tax rates have not gone up much in any location in the state. The tax bill goes up because of increases in the property value. Folks like plotocrat want to have their cake and eat it too- enjoy rising home values but not pay the taxes associated with their increased wealth. As far as “cutting the fat” goes, that almost always means the person making the comment knows next-to-nothing about any government agency or program and where the money goes. The answer, as always, is “outsourcing”, which means pay Republicans to do the work.


  15. - Jerry - Friday, Jun 29, 07 @ 8:59 am:

    LeRoy - the city provides a lot in the way of services for the CTA, free of charge. Chicago police are primarily responsible for security, unlike METRA, which pays for its own police force. The City has paid for the subway station rehabs that are ongoing downtown.

    And when are the suburbs going to step up and pay for Metra? They benefit from Metra in huge ways. People couldn’t live that far from downtown without reliable transit. Maybe its time for Naperville and Aurora and Joliet and Crystal Lake and Arlington Heights and Palatine and all those other towns to step up and pay for at least as much as the city pays for in regards to the CTA?

    And I generally find the privatization argument to be so off base its hilarious. For starters, why the assumption that the private sector is automatically more efficient? I work for a big corporation. I can tell you that there are huge inefficiencies everywhere. Second, when you privatize, you automatically take at least 10% of the funding and lop it off. There’s gotta be a profit there somewhere, which isn’t the objective of government. Services generally suffer due to cost cutting when a government function is privatized. And, in some cases, costs soar under privatization. Look at military privatization. The Feds are paying mercenaries $300 to $1000 a day in Iraq. Our soldiers don’t get paid that much. And, finally, privatization creates even bigger opportunities for corruption. Crony capitalism and all that. You republicans who hate Blago, do you really want to give him more opportunities to hand out fat contracts to his buddies to run state agencies? Some functions may be more efficient to privatize, but there is a limit.


TrackBack URI

Sorry, comments for this post are now closed.


ON THE BLOG TODAY...
* This just in... Governor wants September special sessions *** Meeks: Do it *** Cook takes another look at Ozinga *** Guv won't march in State Fair parade tonight ***
* Sweet bloggy goodness *** UPDATED x1 ***
* Question of the day
* WMD
* Seeing through the haze
* Morning shorts *** Updated x1 ***
* Morning video
** Yesterday's blog posts

Support The Capitol Fax Blog
Visit our advertisers...

Search This Blog...

Search the 95th General Assembly By Bill Number
(example: HB0001)

Search the 95th General Assembly By Keyword

Quick Links

"Google Ads"



Main Menu
Home
Illinois
YouTube
Pundit rankings
Obama
Subscriber Content
Durbin
Polls

Archives
August 2008
July 2008
June 2008
May 2008
April 2008
March 2008
February 2008
January 2008
December 2007
November 2007
October 2007
September 2007
August 2007
July 2007
June 2007
May 2007
April 2007
March 2007
February 2007
January 2007
December 2006
November 2006
October 2006
September 2006
August 2006
July 2006
June 2006
May 2006
April 2006
March 2006
February 2006
January 2006
December 2005
April 2005
March 2005
February 2005
January 2005
December 2004
November 2004
October 2004

Blog*Spot Archives
November 2005
October 2005
September 2005
August 2005
July 2005
June 2005
May 2005

Syndication

RSS Feed 2.0
Comments RSS 2.0
WordPress
 

  
  » Celio Redfly Now Available in the TreoCentral Store
  » Tip o' the Week: Twitter in your pocket!
  » White Apple Logo Screen of Death Stops iPhones in Their Tracks
  » MacRumors: Remote iTunes Streaming to iPhone or iPod Touch?
  » Ad Hoc iPhone Apps Distribution Guide Published
  » Aquapac Waterproof Case Review
  » So, Will Every Market Less RIM’s Largest Get The BlackBerry Bold In August?
  » Alleged Patent Infringement Triggers Lawsuit
  » The BlackBerry KickStart Is Actually A Gigantic BlackBerry Pearl
  » MacRumors: Apple's Ability to Deactivate Malicious App Store Apps
  » TouchTerm: Simple SSH Client for iPhone
  » iPhone can phone home and kill apps?
Supported by FeedInformer

  » DIY Self-Watering Garden [DIY]
  » Evernote Web Clipper Adds Content from Any Web Page [Featured Firefox Extension]
  » Remove Your Mac's Hard Drive from the Desktop [Mac Tip]
  » Minimem Reduces the Memory Footprint of Unwieldy Applications [Featured Windows Download]
  » Paper Mouse Pad Means You’ll Always Have A Place To Write Notes
  » Magic HotInazma Adapter Makes Your Car Run Better, Stronger, Faster
  » Five Best To-Do List Managers [Hive Five]
Supported by Feed Informer

» Game 114: White Sox (63-49) vs. Tigers (55-58)
» ¡Viva Alexei!
» Strong pitching a relief
» Thome dedicates 500th homer to mother
» Danks is Dino-Mite
» White Sox ready their brooms
» Thome lifts White Sox past Tigers
» Vazquez hosts K's for Kids Gala
» Cora boosts managerial record
» Carrasco puts incident behind him
Generated by FeedInformer


  » IDOT jobs move could be up for a vote next week - The Southern
  » Ground broken for RLC Coal Mining Training Center - Benton Evening News
  » County holds backpack, school supply giveaway - Berryessa Sun
  » Cameras would catch Ill. highway reckless drivers - Chicago Tribune
  » Cameras would catch Ill. highway reckless drivers - Fort Mills Times
  » State Police to help Chicago police stem violence - WTHI
  » Law allows tracking of offenders - Beloit Daily News
  » Virginia Theatre could reap benefits from OTB - Urbana/Champaign News-Gazette
  » Blagojevich Calls for Expanded Health Care - Chicago Public Radio
  » Blago is not the one to 'improve' an ethics bill - Jacksonville Journal Courier
From FeedInformer


  » Judge: Chicago can raze homes, make way for O'Hare
  » Central Illinois motorcycle crash kills 2
  » School officials charged with failing to report abuse
  » Construction begins on new miner-training site
  » Kershaw dominates Cards, Ramirez homers in LA win
  » State fair centers on tradition, with new twists
  » Cameras would catch Ill. highway reckless drivers
  » Lottery Glance
  » Gov.: Lawmakers should find education funding
  » State Police to help Chicago police stem violence
Generated by feed dot informer dot com

  » Moto exec exodus continues
  » Fed Signal fires back at investor in war of words
  » Troopers join Chicago cops on streets — despite Daley mocking
  » Taylor adds former LaSalle exec to board
  » More cost-cuts to follow Sun Times’ gloomy Q2
Succoured by feed.informer.com


  » Protesters detained by Beijing police
  » Man who shot cop won't spend time in jail
  » 'Garfield Minus Garfield' getting published
  » Bin Laden driver to seek leniency from Gitmo jury
  » Dubai World buys 20 percent stake in Cirque du Soleil
  » Tibetan exiles demonstrate against China in Nepal
  » Generals oust Mauritania's elected leader
  » Michigan City lighthouse turns 150
  » Ex-Urbana school superintendent charged
  » Detroit mayor sent to jail
Generated by Feed Informer


  » Fatal high-rise fall in Lake View ruled accidental
  » Congregation to mourn destruction of temple and loss of a hospital
  » Man charged with tending pot farm said the job offer came at a mall
  » Busy morning for bank robbers in Chicago
  » 3 stabbed in Near West Side sandwich shop
  » Cops: Please give us back our beer goggles
  » ComEd says it's just about finished restoring power
  » Fire caused by candle displaces 8 Grayslake families
  » Woman kills boyfriend for drinking her beer, officials say
  » Late documents delay Vrdolyak trial
In Association with feed dot informer dot com


  » Campaign Aims to Free Some Elderly Inmates
  » State Troopers to Work With Chicago Police On Gangs
  » EPA Keeps Ethanol Mandate
  » QB Question Highlights Bears Preseason Opener
  » Unfiltered: Gov. Rod Blagojevich Wants Cameras on State Highways
  » Judge Rules in Chicago's Favor to Demolish Homes Near O'Hare
  » Blagojevich Calls for Expanded Health Care
  » Juvenile Center Initiates New Staffing Program
  » Louder Than a Bomb 2008
  » Farmers Assess Losses from Mississippi Flooding
From FeedInformer


  » Governor won't attend State Fair parade
  » IHOP gets OK to build on west side
  » Kershaw, Ramirez lead Dodgers past Cardinals 4-1
  » Officer found not liable in death of mentally ill man in 2002
  » Decatur call center to double workforce
  » Gov. proposes cameras to catch reckless highway drivers
  » Remembering T.J.'s state fair high-dive photo
  » Springfield sees income growth
  » Talk to Us: Do you have Olympic fever?
  » Personal income on the rise locally
Upholded by Feed Informer


  » Blagojevich suggests post-Labor Day session for education, capital bill
  » Miss Southern Illinois to be crowned Saturday
  » Durbin outlines health care plan for small businesses, self-employed
  » IDOT jobs move could be up for a vote next week
  » Rend Lake College breaks ground on miner training facility
Supported by FeedInformer


» Carpentersville man accused of fondling girl
» S. Elgin missing more blood evidence
» These boots weren't made for walking ...
» Sugar Grove to get new fire station
» Social workers aim to help abuse victims finish school
In Association with FeedInformer


  » A Failed Governor, Failing Illinois
  » GOPUSA ILLINOIS Daily Clips - August 7, 2008
  » Chicago Alderwoman Arenda Troutman, Another Corrupt Democrat
  » Jason Wallace Interview on WJBC
  » NEWS YOU MISSED: The Economy Sucks
  » GOPUSA ILLINOIS Daily Clips - August 6, 2008
  » GOPUSA ILLINOIS Daily Clips - August 5, 2008
  » Illinois constitutional convention needs to amend the redistricting provision
  » GOPUSA ILLINOIS Daily Clips - August 4, 2008
  » GOPUSA ILLINOIS Daily Clips - August 3, 2008
Maintained by FeedInformer

» Rep. Gutierrez's Comparison of Immigration and Customs Enforcement ... - MarketWatch
» Gadfly to run for school board - Hesperia Star
» Drive For Natural Gas Vehicles Faces Big Test In California - CNNMoney.com
» Obama Wades Into Ugly Tennessee House Primary - ABC News
» Updated 8/7: Manzullo speech is the buzz - Cary Grove Countryside
» Politicians to speak at inaugural event hosted by nonprofit ... - Waukegan Journal
» Breaking down the House races: Can the Democrats grab at least 30 ... - BuzzFlash
» High School Notes - Dunn Daily Record
» ICE Chief looking to discipline Congressman for remarks - OhMyGov!
» Schakowsky ahead in raising campaign funds - Wilmette Life
Upholded by FeedInformer

» Ad sales for Olympics tops $1 billion - Variety
» INVESTOR'S BUSINESS DAILY - Investor's Business Daily (subscription)
» Justice, American-Style - Investor's Business Daily (subscription)
» Obama Tells Gilani to Act against Taliban, N Proliferation - India Journal
» 9-Year-Old Gets Chance To Interview Obama - WCCO
» Poll: Nearly half hearing too much about Obama - OneNewsNow
» Obama pokes at McCain over tire-pressure issue - OneNewsNow
» Mr. Green - MauiTime Weekly
» Record number of US voters may cast paper ballots - OneNewsNow
» Obama Sweeps The Open Source Vote - San Francisco Chronicle
Supported by feed.informer.com

» Dick Durbin on Health Insurance - WSIL TV
» Carbon Capture: a bridging technology too far? - Gizmag
» Company and People Notes: Meda will Acquire Valeant's Western and ... - Pharmaceutical Technology Magazine
» Officials lobby Durbin for airport project - The Southern
» Durbin Not Giving Up on FutureGen - WSIL TV
» Canadian National urges decision on railway sale - CNNMoney.com
» Second City Heads To Dem Convention - Chicagoist
» Second City as First Improv Troupe? - Chicago Tribune
» Internet Giants Oppose Censorship, Agree To Code Of Conduct - eFluxMedia
» Home News Feature Uncle Sam’s Land Grab: Does the Clean Water ... - River Cities Reader
Powered by Feed Informer

    » ACORN Fraud in Wisconsin
    » Where has Melissa Bean?
    » Just Say No
    » Obama Supporters Want $10 Gasoline
    » Media: Philly newspaper decides speed up its demise
    » This post is