Home | Subscribers Only | AIM | Contact | Mobile | Subscribe | Classifieds | Calendar | Resumes
To subscribe to Capitol Fax, click here. Subscriptions are $350 per year. To advertise on the Capitol Fax Blog, please click here.
Buck a pack tax by the numbers

Wednesday, Jul 18, 2007

* The State Journal-Register has an editorial today that lists the benefits of a dollar a pack increase in the state’s cigarette tax. The numbers were provided by the American Lung Association…

* Cigarette pack sale decline in Illinois — 123.3 million.

* Number of current adult smokers in Illinois who would quit — 57,700.

* Increase in total number of kids alive today who will not become smokers — 130,800.

* Long-term health-care savings in Illinois from adult and youth smoking declines — $2.8 billion.

* The paper adds…

Illinois with its current 98-cents-per-pack tax raised about $634 million last year. That’s a significant revenue source, akin to the amount raised by the state lottery. A $1-per-pack increase is estimated to bring in about $412 million more annually. […]

While we sincerely doubt a $1-per-pack tax increase will gain the needed support, if legislators become serious about any significant increase in the cigarette tax, they should demand that some of the money raised be used to underwrite cessation efforts on the part of smokers. Yes, it might cut into the state’s take in the short run, but in the long run it makes both fiscal and moral sense.

* But Joe Calomino of Americans for Prosperity, Illinois, posted these numbers in comments yesterday…

The Effect of a $1/pack Cigarette Tax Hike on Illinois Retailers

* Tobacco Sales are Important to Illinois Retailers – Illinois stores sold 657 million packs of cigarettes in FY 2006, with a gross retail value of nearly $3.2 billion. Illinois merchants earned nearly $560 million in gross profits on these sales.

* Tobacco Sales Support Illinois Jobs - It is estimated that nearly 8,000 Illinois retailer and wholesaler jobs were supported by in-state tobacco sales (based on estimated gross profits). […]

* In spite of large recent tax increases of the Illinois, Cook County, and Chicago cigarette taxes, some are proposing an Illinois cigarette tax hike of $1/pack. This would raise the Illinois state tax to $1.98 per pack. Illinois residents outside of Cook County could save $18.10/carton in Missouri, $16.80 in Kentucky and $9.85 in Indiana. In Chicago the total state and local cigarette tax would be $4.66/pack. A Chicago resident could save over $44.90/carton in Missouri or over $36/carton in Indiana. A van-load of cigarettes from Missouri would have a profit potential of nearly $255,000. Such bootlegger incentives could create a situation reminiscent of the days of Al Capone.

* Loss in Cigarette Sales Volume – Cigarette volume is estimated to fall by nearly 25% on an annualized basis or by 164 million packs due to the proposed $1 tax hike in FY 2008.

* Loss in Sundry Product Sales - Sundry product sales, or products normally bought in conjunction with tobacco products, could fall by nearly $140 million due to the $1 tax hike.

* Loss in Illinois Gross Profits (value added) - Gross profits lost to Illinois retailers and wholesalers are estimated at approximately $116 million due the proposed $1 tax hike.

* Convenience Store Losses - Cigarette sales at C-stores would fall by 100 million packs due to the $1 tax hike. Gross profit losses could average about $15,000 per store

* Revenue Impact - It is estimated that Illinois will gain about $320 million from the $1 tax hike. […]

Taxes Per Pack In Chicago After a $1 IL Tax Hike and 61 cent Federal Tax Hike

Federal Tax/ Pack $1
State Tax/Pack $1.98
Cook County Tax/Pack $2.00
Chicago Tax/Pack .68
State, County, Local Sales Tax .77

Grand Total $6.43

Go here to read more. Joe said he’s working up a post for his Website and it will be up soon.

Thoughts?

- posted by Rich Miller


17 Comments
  1. - WhoSaidThat - Wednesday, Jul 18, 07 @ 10:09 am:

    I have never trusted numbers sited in news articles because I have always felt that they never tell the whole story. This appears to be a perfect example.


  2. - keepmeoutofIL - Wednesday, Jul 18, 07 @ 10:15 am:

    So Joe’s argument against the tax hike is all of the number of jobs lost? While I think it’s always important to compare the long-term effects of a law versus the short-term effects on the people it seems incredibly callous to compare job numbers to number of lives potentially saved. The Al Capone argument is false also because most people are not going to start searching for the man on the corner with the out-of-state cigarettes. It’s just like gas prices - people pay it because they are addicted to driving their cars everywhere. The reality is that cigarette smoking does contribute to the state’s health costs so smokers should contribute more money to health care in the state.

    Now do I believe IL has any possibility of actually putting the money toward health care like they are proposing? Maybe some of it, but not as much as they are saying.


  3. - FED UP - Wednesday, Jul 18, 07 @ 10:29 am:

    Add a nickle to the tax to raise a little more money while not chasing all the mokers across state lines


  4. - Skeeter - Wednesday, Jul 18, 07 @ 10:38 am:

    The numbers are nice, but incomplete.

    What about the impact of the health care required for the smokers? If uninsured smokers are having heart attacks and suffering lung cancer on the Medicare/Medicaid, it effectively raises all of our taxes.

    The proposed bill simply shifts the burden to those using the services.


  5. - Justice - Wednesday, Jul 18, 07 @ 10:40 am:

    These numbers are all impressive but the real problem, as I see it, is that we continue to look for ways to raise more money to spend when we haven’t done a thorough analysis of the many, many programs that have been in place for years. Many have most likely outlived their usefulness, are duplicated in one form or another, and have huge overhead administering them. It’s as simple as “tax and spend” with no end in sight. It is admirable that the governor wants to do so much for so many with so little. But we need to first focus on the ape in the room and get spending under control and pay our existing bills. The cigarette tax is simply a tax that distracts us from what we should be discussing…fiscal responsibility.


  6. - one of the 35 - Wednesday, Jul 18, 07 @ 10:44 am:

    Rich: If a merchant is operating a business and expects to increase tobacco sales in light of the medical knowledge that has been assembled, then I think the merchant is not being realistic. Our Country is doing everything possible to discourage smoking. The handwriting is on the wall. The tobacco industry is dying. Everyone should understand this. We should all make appropriate economic plans to acknowledge this fact.


  7. - Captain America - Wednesday, Jul 18, 07 @ 10:45 am:

    Joe’s just doing his job. I certainly have nothing against Illinois retailers. But I suggest that everyone should see the movie, Thank You for Smoking, to get a healthy, hilarious, and entertaining perspective about this issue.

    I think the other states should tax cigarettes as highly as we do. Smoking is a really terriible addiction, and exorbitant taxes seem to be a sound long-range strategy to reduce the number of nicotine addicts.


  8. - VanillaMan - Wednesday, Jul 18, 07 @ 10:50 am:

    Even though we clearly see that raising the tobacco tax as proposed would not be an improvement, a number of the bloggers here so desperately want to find a funding source for their health care solution, they are unwilling to admit these figures are worrisome.

    You have to wonder what it would take to get these people to start seeing the light.

    The goose that lays the golden eggs is dead.
    Lets stop pretending we can just vote free health care for ourselves, OK?


  9. - grand old partisan - Wednesday, Jul 18, 07 @ 10:51 am:

    This is what has always bothered me about the Lung Association. Their support of increased taxes in order to discourage smoking is short sighted and counter-productive. While some smokers will probably quit as a result of the increased cost, the state will become even more financially reliant on the revenue generated by the continued smoking of the rest (this is even more problematic when you consider that the money is to be used to make a permanent entitlement program fiscally solvent). This puts the government in the position of being unable to ever completely ban tobacco use (which, I would assume, is the Lung Associations ultimate goal).


  10. - Jechislo - Wednesday, Jul 18, 07 @ 11:42 am:

    Why, according to these figures it would almost be cheaper to smoke “illegal drugs”.


  11. - Anonymous - Wednesday, Jul 18, 07 @ 11:55 am:

    Passing increased tobacco tax, only means the state is more dependent on the bad habits of the state citizens, but don’t call this a measure to decrease smoking in Illinois. If we are serious about stopping smoking, then - Just outlaw the sale of tobacco products in the state of Illinois. No wait a minute What would the state do without all that revenue from tobacco sales to fund all of our social goodies.

    Best thing to do is to approach a smoker and thank him for contributing to the state coffers.


  12. - Budget Watcher - Wednesday, Jul 18, 07 @ 12:16 pm:

    Joe should also point out that the other taxing entities, especially Cook County, will see a decline in their revenue base. That’s significant to a county that already has severe budget issues.


  13. - Fake Bill - Wednesday, Jul 18, 07 @ 12:25 pm:

    - Justice - Wednesday, Jul 18, 07 @ 10:40 am:

    Hit the nail on the head. I know of one program that costs the State 3.7 million dollars. The people being served… reside in a different State. Once a program is started it’s almost impossible to cancel it, needed or not.


  14. - c-rock - Wednesday, Jul 18, 07 @ 1:15 pm:

    We need to tax politicans.


  15. - Squideshi - Wednesday, Jul 18, 07 @ 1:58 pm:

    I think that addicts’ time would be better spend trying to get off the tobacco than complaining about the taxes that they choose to pay by buying. It’s not like cigarettes are a necessity–they’re an addictive, harmful drug that damages public health and reduces the efficiency of our workforce.


  16. - Crimefighter - Wednesday, Jul 18, 07 @ 3:05 pm:

    Grand Old Partisan got it right…the problem with cigarette taxes is in order to collect the tax you have to have people smoke.


  17. - steve schnorf - Wednesday, Jul 18, 07 @ 7:35 pm:

    I don’t see anything wrong with a tax no one has to pay, be it tobacco, liquor, gambling, whatever.


TrackBack URI

Sorry, comments for this post are now closed.


ON THE BLOG TODAY...
* This just in... Froehlich out
* Blagojevich finishes second behind Palin
* Recall warning
* Reader comments closed for the holiday weekend
* *** UPDATED x2 *** Birkett appears in for AG
* Question of the day
* Mother Blowhard
** Yesterday's blog posts

Support The Capitol Fax Blog
Visit our advertisers...

...............

Search This Blog...

Search the 96th General Assembly By Bill Number
(example: HB0001)

Search the 96th General Assembly By Keyword

Quick Links


Main Menu
Home
Illinois
YouTube
Pundit rankings
Obama
Subscriber Content
Durbin
Burris
Polls

Archives
July 2009
June 2009
May 2009
April 2009
March 2009
February 2009
January 2009
December 2008
November 2008
October 2008
September 2008
August 2008
July 2008
June 2008
May 2008
April 2008
March 2008
February 2008
January 2008
December 2007
November 2007
October 2007
September 2007
August 2007
July 2007
June 2007
May 2007
April 2007
March 2007
February 2007
January 2007
December 2006
November 2006
October 2006
September 2006
August 2006
July 2006
June 2006
May 2006
April 2006
March 2006
February 2006
January 2006
December 2005
April 2005
March 2005
February 2005
January 2005
December 2004
November 2004
October 2004

Blog*Spot Archives
November 2005
October 2005
September 2005
August 2005
July 2005
June 2005
May 2005

Syndication

RSS Feed 2.0
Comments RSS 2.0
WordPress
 

  
  » Remember The Executor Keychain From Back In The Day?
  » UK Bank pushes iPhone e-commerce forward
  » Review: Read It Later for iPhone
  » MacRumors: Prototype iPhone 3GS on eBay? (No, No Matte Case) [Updated]
  » iPhone 3GS gets jailbroken, hack available online
  » Deathmatch rematch: BlackBerry versus iPhone 3.0
  » Review: HuffingtonPost.com for iPhone
  » Ngmoco releases Rolando 2 for iPhone, iPod touch
  » Review: Tiki Golf 3D for iPhone
  » Wirefly Offering Verizon BlackBerry Tour For $179.99
  » Skyfire For BlackBerry In Alpha Testing
  » Review: MobileStudio for iPhone
Succoured by FeedInformer

  » Tips, Projects, and Great Eats for Your Fourth of July Weekend [Summer]
  » This Week's Most Popular Posts [Highlights]
  » Celebrate the Fourth of July with a New Desktop Wallpaper [Friday Fun]
  » Get Ready For Summer With Homemade Sunblock [Summer]
  » State of the Airline Industry Chart Compares Airline Service Fees [Saving Money]
  » June 2009's Most Popular Posts [[this Is Good]]
  » Take Better Photos: Fourth of July Edition [Photography Tip]
Generated by FeedInformer

» Podsednik an All-Star?
» White Sox mourn death of Takiff
» White Sox winning streak halted
» Buehrle to make two starts before break
» Lunchtime Fireworks
» This Week in White Sox Minor League Baseball
» Floyd looks to keep streak alive
» John Danks Keeps White Sox Rolling
» Danks outduels Greinke in opener
» Quentin to begin rehab stint Saturday
Supported by feed dot informer dot com

 
     


  » Clout goes to college - Chicago Tribune...
  » How reform failed in Illinois - Chicago Tribune...
  » New UC Davis leader denies wrongdoing in inquiries.....
  » UI chancellor to testify Monday in admissions prob.....
  » Quinn fires head of hospital board - Naperville Su.....
  » Quinn fires head of health board - Chicago Sun-Tim.....
  » US: Illinois state budget crisis threatens social .....
  » The saga of Howe - Chicago Tribune...
  » Giannoulias Aide Tied To University Of Illinois Cl.....
  » Report: Treasurer's aide helped get teen in to UI .....
Powered by Feed Informer


  » Lugar co-hosts forum for young undocumented aliens
  » FBI investigates staffing at Ill. juvenile center
  » Car rams crowd at Ill. fireworks show, killing 1
  » Ill. gears up for Fourth of July fireworks
  » A few US cities hope to host Gitmo transplants
  » Champaign marathon back for 2010 with a new date
  » Mom, child killed in N. Ill. head-on crash
  » Calif. bullet train hits criticism on SF Peninsula
  » Ramirez scores 2 runs in first action since injury
  » Cubs' Ramirez, Johnson make rehab starts
Generated by Feed Informer

» 7,000 Illinoisans use interlocks under DUI law
» Quinn fires health board director
» Giannoulias aide helped priest get friend's daughter into U of I
» Even 'the mighty' will feel budget cuts, Quinn says
» Birkett to run again for attorney general
» Quinn rejects budget, assures worker pay
» Tax hike showdown coming to Springfield
» Suburban service agencies feel the pinch too
» Layoffs and cuts continue at Champaign-area service agencies
» Lawmakers flooded with calls from constitutents
Supported by feed dot informer dot com

  » State budget stalemate could cost non-profits billions
  » Tribune Co. profitability continues to deteriorate
  » Local winners and losers in global warming bill
  » Mediation firms thrive in slow economy
  » Founders Bank one of six in state to fail Thursday
  » Obama due here for big fundraiser
  » Two more Illinois banks fail
  » Banker, investor Sanford Takiff dies
  » Boeing 2Q jet deliveries on pace with last year
  » Navistar's Ontario workers reject contract offer
Provided by feed.informer.com


  » Dad fights son's school suspension over T-shirt
  » Juvenile detention staffers face crackdown
  » Man arrested at Taste of Chicago with sawed-off shotgun
  » Alcohol found in car that killed mother & son on Tri-State
  » CTA train fatally strikes deer near Skokie
  » Crook tally hits 2 million
  » Could Gitmo transplants end up in Illinois prisons?
  » Kirk Homes bankruptcy leaves homeowners in limbo
  » Colleges adding fees for paying by credit card
  » Mortgage lien kept in limbo for a spell
From feed dot informer dot com


  » Chicago police say teen slain after Lawndale foot chase had aimed gun at officer
  » U. of I. athletic boosters get special treatment
  » How reform failed in Illinois
  » Ads fuel fight over cemetery blocking O'Hare expansion
  » Face to face with Obama's past
  » Sometimes summer is short on bliss
  » A lurid past, new law limits teen sex offender's future
  » Worst summer ever?
  » Ex-NFL MVP Steve McNair found shot dead
  » Gun, knife arrests at Taste of Chicago
From Feed Informer


  » Real-Estate Magnate Backed Harold Washington
  » A Renaissance Man of Chicago’s South Side
  » Governer Quinn Addresses Flip-Flop Critics
  » Police Fatally Shoot West Side Teen
  » Congressman to Reject Payday-Loan Donations
  » Shelter Turns Away Women, Blames State Budget
  » United Still Recoving From Early Morning Computer Glitch
  » The Ledge Opens at the Sears Tower
  » Quinn's Income Tax Hike Still a Tough Sell to Some Lawmakers.
  » Quinn's "Credibility Gap"
Provided by FeedInformer


  » Comptroller's documents detail history of IFDA trouble
  » Downtown fireworks decision to be made by 9 p.m.
  » Callaspo drives in 3 as Royals beat White Sox 6-4
  » McGehee pounds 4 hits, Brewers rip Cubs 11-2
  » Owings lifts Reds to 5-2 win over Cardinals
  » Lincoln Museum reaches 2 million visitors
  » A few Illinois cities hope to host Guantanamo transplants
  » Photojournalist donates images to SIUE
  » Serena tops Venus again for third Wimbledon title
  » Champaign marathon back for 2010 with a new date
Maintained by feed dot informer dot com

» Ill. man charged with $10K theft from lottery
» 1st cases of swine flu in St. Clair County
» Roy Blunt touts his insider support; Democrats do, too
» Ill. Gov. Quinn to veto partial budget today; showdown looms
» As new fiscal year begins, Illinois remains without budget
Provided by feed.informer.com

» johnfritchey: @rstoup It's a pretty quick read.
» RutherfordDan: Independence Day... I like the sound of that!
» johnfritchey: @bridgetdooley Right back at ya!
» RepMendoza01: is in NYC w/ my mom for her early b-day celebration. We'..
» CYRs: IL YR Charman Dennis Cook to run for statewide office. http://bi..
» DanProft: Steve McNair shot to death. Just terrible. Wonderful talen..
» Happy 4th!
» #twill Harlan on Blogger & Twitter http://tinyurl.com/n63wvv
» #twill "Grand Corssing at a Crossroads" http://tinyurl.com/l7aghn
» johnfritchey: Happy Independence Day everybody!! Hope you're making it..
Generated by FeedInformer


  » Gubernatorial candidate speaks at Patriots Rally in Carbondale
  » Body found; Marion police investigate
  » Carbondale, Murphysboro fireworks rescheduled; Rend Lake still on
  » Closing of auto plant leaves Fenton, Mo., with a huge void
  » Chestnut wins NY hot dog eating match
Upholded by Feed Informer


» Oak Brook man charged with shooting at Chicago cop
» Palin keeps low-profile after surprise news
» Letters link Son of Sam and victims' advocate
» No injuries in Des Plaines-area fire
» Chestnut downs record 68 franks in holding hot dog eating crown
Upholded by FeedInformer


  » GOPUSA ILLINOIS Daily Clips - June 28, 2009
  » Don't emulate Illinois...
  » GOPUSA ILLINOIS Daily Clips - June 27, 2009
  » Governor signs bill to refinance debt
  » Political Prison in Marion?
  » GOPUSA ILLINOIS Daily Clips - June 26, 2009
  » Budget not the only thing in limbo
  » GOPUSA ILLINOIS Daily Clips - June 25, 2009
  » Everything in limbo
  » GOPUSA ILLINOIS Daily Clips - June 24, 2009
Provided by feed dot informer dot com

» Summer Fiction: Road Signs as Paid Political ..
» Jackson death reaction lost perspective - Aug..
» Ups and Downs - The Southern
» Illinois ranks 10th in new study of overweigh..
» Shock says VA clinic remains a top priority -..
» Oak Lawn Gets Preview Of Children's Museu..
» Lipinski Wants Options For Health Care - Sout..
» Protestors Want Option And Lipinski's Sig..
» Rep. Jackson holds health reform town hall me..
» MSNBC's Ed Show Covers Hartmarx Victory -..
Upholded by FeedInformer

» Lugar's office to host DREAM Act forum - .....
» NotDickDurbin: RT @ObamaNews: Happy Independe.....
» Lugar co-hosts forum for young undocumented a.....
» NotDickDurbin: Happy Independence Day! The St.....
» A few US cities hope to host Gitmo transplant.....
» A few US cities hope to host Gitmo transplant.....
» Yes, in my backyard: Illinois town among few .....
» Marion among few US cities hoping to host Git.....
» As we enjoy our freedoms, remember others are.....
» NotDickDurbin: Senators Feinstein, Akaka, Fei.....
In Association with FeedInformer

» Sidestepping Madigan - Chicago Sun-Times...
» A Tourist In Your Own Town (a photo diary) - .....
» Palin's Foolish Resignation - Washington .....
» Gov. Quinn appeals to legislators on proposed.....
» America's political ayatollahs - MPNnow.c.....
» Spillane represents Jo Carroll Energy in Wash.....
» Voice of the Reader 7-3 - The Southern...
» DK Greenroots: Blood Stains on Green Technolo.....
» Cheryle Jackson launches Illinois Senate expl.....
» Complaints arise about White House kibitzing .....
Supported by Feed Informer

    » Asleep on the subway
    » Harlan on Blogger & Twitter
    » GOP at the Wheaton Parade
    » "Grand Crossing at a Crossroads"
    » Why Sarah Palin resigned and what it means
    » Sarah Palin resigns, July 3, 2009. Transcript
    » "Public Enemies" puts Illinois on the big screen
    » Celebrating Freedom
    » A Secret 4th of July
    » I second this euphemism
    » Quincy 4th of July 2008 Celebration Redux
    » Burn, Burn, Burn Like Fabulous Yellow Roman Candles
Provided by feed dot informer dot com


Header Photos...
Wayne Bretl & UIS


Hosted by MCS