Subscribe to Capitol Fax      Advertise Here      Mobile Version    Contact Rich Miller
Untitled Document
To subscribe to Capitol Fax, click here. Subscriptions are $350 per year. To advertise on the Capitol Fax Blog, please click here.
Early primary impact

Tuesday, Sep 11, 2007

* If the Politico had more analytical stories like this one, I might read it more often. A well-done story on the impact of the early primaries is like finding a diamond in a pig pen…

“It’s very conceivable people will go door-knocking around Christmas break,” said Simon Behrmann, spokesman for Jay Footlik, a Democrat seeking the nomination against Rep. Mark Kirk (R-Ill.). “This is definitely something we’ve never seen here in Illinois.” […]

Christine Dudley, the former executive director of the Illinois Republican Party, said it also will be a challenge for congressional candidates to compete for the voters’ attention during a period that is normally dominated by sports. […]

“You’ll be seeing lots of Christmas cards with veiled political messages,” said Dudley. “It’s distracting, and in this media market, people care a lot more about sports than they do about politics.”

The nine-month gap between the primaries and the November election also poses a challenge to many campaigns. One Illinois Democratic campaign manager predicted that he would have to lay off some staff after the primary.

“It puts a premium on doing the work on a campaign much earlier,” the operative said. “I can’t keep my organizers for nine months. There’s not enough news … to pay salaries.”

This uncertain terrain could have far-reaching effects, as Illinois is hosting its share of competitive primaries that could affect the balance of power in the House.

* Could the February primary hurt campaign fundraising for down-ballot candidates?

“Maybe it’s an old wives’ tale, but people usually follow it - usually during that period of time, people are more interested in using their funds for Christmas, for the holidays,” [Kane County State’s Attorney John Barsanti] said.

* The state’s fundraising disclosure calendar has been adjusted to fit the new reality…

Normally, fundraising committees have to submit two campaign finance reports before each primary. The regular semi-annual report is due Jan. 31 and the pre-election report is due 30 days before the election.

As that pre-election report would be due Jan. 5, the measure also combined those two reports into one report, due Jan. 20. This would only take place in even-numbered years.

* This article points out other hurdles

*Illinois (Feb. 5). Cook County needs to train 12,000 poll workers in January, when many retirees have left for Florida or other warm areas. In Rock Island County, about 80% of the 325 poll workers usually are seniors. “We hope we won’t be tearing around the day before the election just trying to find somebody who can fog a mirror,” County Clerk Richard Leibovitz says.

* And…

* Mailing absentee ballots. The ballots, which are sent to as many as 6 million military and civilian voters overseas, must be mailed 45 days before the elections. In states holding early primaries, that could mean during the holidays, when mail delivery is slow, increasing the potential for disenfranchising voters, says Brad Bryant of Kansas, president of the National Association of State Election Directors.

* Negotiating bad weather. Earlier primaries boost the chance of snow and ice, which could make it tough to open, supply and staff polling places. Several cold-weather states are moving their elections into midwinter, including Illinois, New Jersey and New York.

* As Kate Clements points out, we’re not alone

Twenty states, including Illinois, have either adopted a Feb. 5 primary date or are considering doing so.

* And that has forced presidential candidates to adjust, as this admittedly outdated NY Times story attests…

Aides to the candidates said they were debating whether the changes would mean that the nominations would effectively be settled on Feb. 5, by which point easily 50 percent of the delegates are likely to have been chosen, or whether a few strong candidates would divide the Feb. 5 take, forcing the campaign to stretch on for months. That could, oddly enough, make those fewer states sticking to later primaries vital players in the election cycle.

The changes are forcing candidates to decide whether Iowa and New Hampshire, two states with contests before Feb. 5, will become more influential as contenders look for early victories to give them momentum. And with as many as 23 states voting on a single day — more states than are typically considered competitive in a general election — candidates must decide which ones to ignore, given the demands on their time and bank accounts. […]

For Democrats, the prospect of a mega-primary has created a new calculation about the importance of black voters, already a constituency being fiercely courted by Mr. Obama, who is seeking to become the nation’s first black president, and Senator Hillary Rodham Clinton of New York. There are hardly any black voters in Iowa and New Hampshire; by contrast, they could play an important role in California, Illinois, Missouri, New Jersey and New York.

- posted by Rich Miller


21 Comments
  1. - Mr. W.T.Rush - Tuesday, Sep 11, 07 @ 8:49 am:

    Anyone planning to check the rumor about BlunderBloyBlaggo fly around on capital projects? This follows his meeting with VandaliaFrank and following the bright ball for 4 hours.


  2. - Tristan - Tuesday, Sep 11, 07 @ 8:53 am:

    Oh poo-poo….we did this to help Obama.


  3. - Rob_N - Tuesday, Sep 11, 07 @ 9:14 am:

    The siren call of the presidential races (x20) is also sucking up money that would otherwise go to lower-level races; especially challengers.


  4. - bored now - Tuesday, Sep 11, 07 @ 9:22 am:

    i thought the moving up of the primary to severe winter weather was the holy grail of the machine for years (decades?). precinct captain’s weather, they call it (for a reason). for whatever reason, we’ve had more mild march’s, which didn’t help. i have said that obama was the excuse, the opportunity, to do what they already wanted to do…


  5. - Squideshi - Tuesday, Sep 11, 07 @ 9:41 am:

    Four presidential candidates are seeking the Green Party’s nomination in Illinois, there is an effort to draft Cynthia McKinney, who has shown some interest; and I have heard that Ralph Nader is considering running again.


  6. - VanillaMan - Tuesday, Sep 11, 07 @ 9:58 am:

    Any political party that wishes to run the risk of nominating a candidate a year before the General Election may do so at their own risk.

    By setting the primaries so early, both parties expose themselves for the next eight months for another political party to catch the public’s imagination. Or, they run the risk of having their nominee exposed to news elements, or even the Grim Reaper and crashing month before Election Day.

    The first time one of the major party nominees does this, this entire silly season for early primaries will fall out of fashion.

    Why doesn’t Illinois hold it’s future primaries in July - right before the conventions, forcing both parties to justify their front runners? Perhaps instead of a simple majority, our primary can require a win by 15% over the runner up?

    Instead of chasing snowflakes, lets consider the purpose of primaries - getting the strongest candidates. There is no reason to believe that the candidates winning in January or February will be the winners in November. So, Illinois should have a 15% primary hurdle before the nominating conventions to test these early winners and see if they still have the stuff.


  7. - Rich Miller - Tuesday, Sep 11, 07 @ 10:02 am:

    ===Why doesn’t Illinois hold it’s future primaries in July - right before the conventions, forcing both parties to justify their front runners?===

    Because by then the nomination process is long over and nobody cares.

    Plus, that would be terrible for my business. I’m against it. lol


  8. - Squideshi - Tuesday, Sep 11, 07 @ 10:07 am:

    Interestingly, I don’t think that the primary has much of any effect on the Green Party’s nomination, because I don’t believe that the state can force the party’s delegates to vote any certain way at the national nominating convention. It’s the best of both worlds–an early primary AND the ability to later nominate whoever we want.


  9. - Been out in the cold before - Tuesday, Sep 11, 07 @ 10:17 am:

    In Chicago, us city door knockers have been going out in the cold around Christmas time every four years as the non-partisan mayoral and aldermanic races are held in February. That being said, it is pretty much a waste of time knocking on doors before Christmas. But right afterwards many people have the week off and you can find them at home on the weekdays. Also, it is a great time to make sure the college kids get their absentee ballot applications so they don’t get left out. With early voting, some of those kids can even vote before they go back to school.
    Before Christmas the best thing a candidate can do is to go and drink eggnog at as many Christmas parties as he can stomach.


  10. - Truthful James - Tuesday, Sep 11, 07 @ 10:30 am:

    What we should do is schedule the primaries for the next biennial election in the April following the last general election.

    That is, of course ridiculous, but only slightly more that moving the primary dates up. Elections have become radically more expensive, when we should have been minimizing the cost of campaigning and thus the amount of money it takes to buy a candidate.

    Unfortunately, among the leading candidates there is not a dime’s worth of difference, not a new policy proposed, not a set of planks to make a platform.

    And perhaps on both sides of the aisle — excepting Bill Richardson and Ron Paul.

    Me-too ism reigns, and anyone with new and/or better ideas can’t get funded.

    2008 will be perhaps the most important election we have had since 1948, when isue meant something and we decided as a country to internationalize ourselves to stop the spread of communism and left the isolationist mood which despite winning World War II had a not inconsequential following.

    There are major issues out there on which individual candidates can take stands: immigration; energy development; homeland security; overseas deployments; imports; taxes.

    The last has the greatest heat and the least light in the debates. Tax burden is the key to job development

    There is an imbalance between the time alloted to raise issues, select a candidate, write a platform.

    The last is the most important for the race and the voters, and the time between the convention and the election is about right.

    With today’s immediate media we should have foreshortened the period between the primaries and the convention. So what happens if a single candidate hold a majority of the delegate votes? Do we write the platform then and there and use the Convention as a vacation place where the Veep Candidate can be named? After all the Single Candidate will be already running on a platform.

    And if there are two or more winners, none with a majority, what will they day all spring and into the summer that has not been said before?

    No, these best that could have been done was to put all the primaries back to the April election date which exists in nearly every state for local elections and for State primaries.

    But that would have made sense. Right now the leading candidate in both parties is General Apathy — at last in the voters, not in the political structure.


  11. - keep up with the jones - Tuesday, Sep 11, 07 @ 10:38 am:

    Blago has not yet signed Sb662 which contains much needed language changes for election officials. But why hurry Blago; petitions are already out and the election changes are not important to you like everything else.


  12. - Team Sleep - Tuesday, Sep 11, 07 @ 10:40 am:

    I support holding primaries in August. It would be much better for the voters.

    It’s amazing that political consultants and campaign wonks wonder why the electorate don’t pay attention. Could it be that after years of disenfranchisement the public as a whole just don’t care about an eight-to-night month general election campaign? The thought of some campaign calling my house or littering my front door with fliers around Christmas time infuriates me - and I love politics.

    I do agree with the anonymous campaign manager: extended campaigns will only make the need for dollars greater. People are already upset with the role money plays in politics and elections, and an extended primary period could possible exacerbate the issue. How do you keep paying for staff, signs, robocalls, mailers, handouts, etc. when you have a nine-month process? This could keep qualified, competent candidates from running.


  13. - Rich Miller - Tuesday, Sep 11, 07 @ 10:42 am:

    ===years of disenfranchisement===

    Huh?


  14. - Dan Vock - Tuesday, Sep 11, 07 @ 10:54 am:

    Nice of the Politico to catch up. :)

    http://www.stateline.org/live/details/story?contentId=237438


  15. - Rich Miller - Tuesday, Sep 11, 07 @ 10:56 am:

    Dan, you guys should include Illinois in more of your stories. I’d see them then.


  16. - cermak_rd - Tuesday, Sep 11, 07 @ 10:56 am:

    The early primaries only make sense in the context that other states are earlier and a lot of the later voting states finally got tired of being essentially left out of the candidate selection process. Take Iowa and New Hampshire (please), they are fighting tooth and nail to hang onto their first in the nation status because of two things–the outsized (for their populations) political influence it gives them and, probably even more importantly, the tremendous amounts of $$$ they rake in from the reporters, candidates, advisers, et al that flock to them every 4 years. It has been inequitable for a long time, but somehow this year the other states started to notice it and to take action. If this presidential election follows the script from past elections (candidates largely decided by early states), I predict more calendar madness in 2012 or a different system put in place to select a candidate.


  17. - Team Sleep - Tuesday, Sep 11, 07 @ 11:28 am:

    Disenchantment. Disenfranchisement. Whatever.

    Rich, I truly believe people don’t care. And who can blame them? The last three gubernatorial elections have been very expensive, and the current presidential election cylce is set to shatter all spending records.

    As the public becomes more privy to the dirty money involved in politics - legal or not - the Regular Joe seems to drift off and not pay attention. It’s a shame people don’t pay as much attention or get as involved as they could be, but in an open democracy you cannot force the vote or force people to care about public policy or government.


  18. - Rich Miller - Tuesday, Sep 11, 07 @ 11:43 am:

    That’s a huge difference. Taking someone’s right to vote away from them is a lot different than a disenchanted voter.


  19. - hey guv - Tuesday, Sep 11, 07 @ 2:04 pm:

    Please Governor sined SB662 and help the county clerks and other election staffs operate the primary better.


  20. - Dan Vock - Tuesday, Sep 11, 07 @ 2:55 pm:

    We try, we try. :)


  21. - muon - Tuesday, Sep 11, 07 @ 8:31 pm:

    I’d second Team Sleep on the August primary. Many states separate their presidential delegate selection from the primaries for state and federal candidates. A 10 week window for the campaign from primary to election is already used for IL municipal races (incl. Chicago) and could work as well for other offices.


Sorry, comments for this post are now closed.


ON THE BLOG TODAY...
* This just in... Miguel del Valle to run for mayor... Rahm's lame duckiness
* This just in... Emanuel cancels Sunday Chicago event
* *** UPDATED x1 *** Mark Kirk goes up with positive ad
* *** UPDATED x1 - Burris takes himself out *** Three Jackson family members considering mayoral bid, Brown is out, and Daley won't endorse
* Is Cohen the $6 million man? Plus: Read the Cohen oppo book; Third party updates
* Question of the day
* Silver gives Brady 86.7 percent chance of winning
* The Daley explosion
* Morning Shorts
* SUBSCRIBERS ONLY - Supplement to today’s edition
* SUBSCRIBERS ONLY - Today's edition of Capitol Fax (use all CAPS in password)
* *** UPDATED x1 *** Alexi goes up with Obama ad
* This just in... Good news for a change
* Yesterday's blog posts

ADVERTISE ON THE BLOG

Search This Blog...

Search the 96th General Assembly By Bill Number
(example: HB0001)

Search the 96th General Assembly By Keyword

Senate 2010 Poll Tracker

Governor 2010 Poll Tracker

Quick Links


Main Menu
Home
Illinois
YouTube
Pundit rankings
Obama
Subscriber Content
Durbin
Burris
Blagojevich Trial
Polls

Archives
September 2010
August 2010
July 2010
June 2010
May 2010
April 2010
March 2010
February 2010
January 2010
December 2009
November 2009
October 2009
September 2009
August 2009
July 2009
June 2009
May 2009
April 2009
March 2009
February 2009
January 2009
December 2008
November 2008
October 2008
September 2008
August 2008
July 2008
June 2008
May 2008
April 2008
March 2008
February 2008
January 2008
December 2007
November 2007
October 2007
September 2007
August 2007
July 2007
June 2007
May 2007
April 2007
March 2007
February 2007
January 2007
December 2006
November 2006
October 2006
September 2006
August 2006
July 2006
June 2006
May 2006
April 2006
March 2006
February 2006
January 2006
December 2005
April 2005
March 2005
February 2005
January 2005
December 2004
November 2004
October 2004

Blog*Spot Archives
November 2005
October 2005
September 2005
August 2005
July 2005
June 2005
May 2005

Syndication

RSS Feed 2.0
Comments RSS 2.0
WordPress
 

  
  » Verizon Rumored To Be Releasing BlackBerry Curve 3G 9330 September 16th
  » Video: Check Out The New BlackBerry Torch Commercial
  » BlackBerry Curve 3G Now Available On T-Mobile
  » Update: HP Files Lawsuit; Oracle Fights Back...
  » MacRumors: iOS 4.1 Restores Field Test Mode

  » Deal Of The Day: Sony BRAVIA KDL-52EX700 52-inch 1080p For $1,349
  » From the Tips Box: Laptop Contact Info, Lost Smartphones, and Google Voice Search [From The Tips Box]
  » How Much Faster is Google Instant? [Google]
  » Remains of the Day: Stay Healthy at Your Startup [For What Its Worth]
  » Compare Individual Services, Not Bundles, to Save Money [Saving Money]

» Great Falls clinches Pioneer League North
» Danks victimized by 'D' as White Sox fall
» Mark Teahen Should Not Be An Option At 3B For White Sox
» Manny taking a bruising
» Viciedo ready for anything

 
   


  » Time to eliminate township government - Arlington ....
  » Mudslinging left in the dirt by early campaign ads....
  » U.S. Chamber of Commerce launches ad attack on Box....
  » White crusades for fewer traffic deaths - Quad Cit....
  » Southern Illinois murder suspect, 15, gets new law....
  » Alexi Giannoulias embraces Obama in new ad - Carmi....
  » Navistar to stay in Illinois with Lisle HQ - Chica....
  » 2 firms make pitches for running Illinois Lottery ....
  » As Obama's popularity drops, number of Democratic ....
  » Senate candidate stops in Rockford to talk jobs - ....


  » Appeals court lets government halt torture lawsuit
  » Chicago mulls future without Daley power at helm
  » Judge to hold juror names longer at Blago retrial
  » Schroeder guilty on IRS charge
  » Sheriff: Man sought for questioning after 4 killed
  » Gardner Denver moving to PA
  » United Airlines saw fuller planes in August
  » Tribune Co. names general counsel to chief restructuring post
  » Mayor Daley says he won't run again
  » Navistar gets $66M to make more Army vehicles

» Blago judge wants to keep jurors anonymous, delay naming them
» Burris comments about the race to succeed him
» Navistar, state forge deal on Lisle move
» Giannoulias: U.S. should leave Afghanistan quickly
» Edgar kicks off Eureka College's Reagan tribute
» Obama stumps for Giannoulias in new ad
» Madigan opposes promotion of cribs
» Status hearing today for Blagojevich retrial
» Experts say 'open' primary unlikely in Illinois
» Life after 'mayor for life'

  » New Chicago sports site caters to fans
  » Gardner Denver moving to PA
  » United Airlines saw fuller planes in August
  » Daley era ends: What is the fate of future Wal-Marts?
  » City Council approves $1B bonds for O'Hare



  » Mental exam ordered for Riley Fox slaying suspect
  » Post-Daley circus gets started early
  » Oswego man sentenced in drug death
  » Chicago cops seize weapons, pot in suburban bust
  » With Daley's news, eyes also on city's police chief
  » Daley decided more than a month ago not to run again
  » City Clerk Miguel del Valle says he'll run for mayor
  » Election grandstanding likely in City Council as budget talks loom
  » Priest gets 4 years for assaulting suburban boy
  » Remains of Lady Elgin shipwreck trapped in limbo


  » Gary Airport Readies for Takeoff
  » City Council's Black Caucus Strategizes for Mayoral Elections
  » City Council Budget Hearing Could be More Hectic this Year
  » No Endorsement From Daley
  » New Blagojevich Jury
  » Celebrations in Chicago today for Jane Addams' 150th birthday
  » Two Finalists Vying to Manage the Illinois Lottery Make Their Case
  » White House Names Carp Czar, Testimony Over Fish Continues
  » Chicago Aldermen to Vote on Billion Dollar Bond Deal
  » Moore: Daley Replacement Must Be Less Autocratic


  » Letter: Give horse racing tracks cut of new casino's earnings
  » Companies outline proposals to run state lottery
  » Village of Pawnee under boil order
  » Judge to hold juror names longer at Blagojevich retrial
  » Boy in Spiderman pajamas scoots along highway
  » Burris comments about the race to succeed him
  » Police investigating crash east of Springfield
  » Be a high school football ‘Score Spotter’ on Friday night
  » SIU's Simmons Cancer Institute forges alliance with Carbondale-based group
  » Old Farmer's Almanac: Global cooling to continue


  » Take it slow
  » Work coming along
  » House fire under investigation in Harrisburg
  » West City man charged after pit bull attack
  » Refunds now available for unfinished Todd Snider concert


» Ind. activist to head federal anti-carp campaign
» Naperville man found dead in neighbor's yard
» Man arrested in Downers Grove burglary
» Burglar takes chalice from Wheaton religious shop
» Man sentenced to 39 years in Naperville murder


  » Implications of Daley's Decision in the South Suburbs
  » GOPUSA ILLINOIS Daily Clips - September 8, 2010
  » Daley says he won't run again
  » GOPUSA ILLINOIS Daily Clips - September 7, 2010
  » GOPUSA ILLINOIS Daily Clips - September 6, 2010

» Bernard Schoenburg: Former Williamsville pres..
» Lake County briefs - Chicago Daily Herald
» Race heats up for 17th district - cbs4qc.com
» Daley's dogs having their day - Chicago Tribu..
» Guest Edit: New right ignores struggles fough..
» Chicago's next mayor - ChicagoNow (blog)
» Emanuel cancels Chicago trip - Politico (blog..
» Lawmakers put 'fun' in their fundraisers - Ch..
» Hare TV commercial targets trade pact - Gales..
» War of words begins in race for the 17th Cong..

» Michigan officials want action from carp 'cza.....
» Quick Asian carp solution unlikely - Milwauke.....
» Corrections and Clarifications - Charlotte Ob.....
» Dick Durbin Expresses His Concern for Those C.....
» Senate candidate stops in Rockford to talk jo.....

» Connersville comes back home to face South De.....
» Burris has sharp words for Kirk - The State J.....
» Kirk, Giannoulias release TV ads Thursday - A.....
» Burris has sharp words for Kirk - State Journ.....
» Sen. Burris Tries to Keep His Job a Bit Longe.....

    » Do people really believe Eugene Sawyer was the last black mayor ever of Chicago?
    » U.S. Senator Roland W. Burris to hold Small Business Panel Discussion and Expo on Friday, September 10
    » Bananagram: U.S. sliding into Third World income schisms
    » Illinois Judges Foundation to hold Batter Up For Justice Fundraiser
    » No Guarantees
    » Why would Rahm want to be mayor of Chicago
    » Surely you have heard about Mayor Daley...
    » Rahmania Roundup
    » Smart Love Preschool Offering Free Classes
    » C’Mon What About Ricky Hendon?


Header Photos...
Wayne Bretl & UIS


Hosted by MCS