Home | Subscribers Only | AIM | Contact | Mobile | Subscribe | Classifieds | Calendar | Resumes
To subscribe to Capitol Fax, click here. Subscriptions are $350 per year. To advertise on the Capitol Fax Blog, please click here.
Ald.’s son receives $75,000 in City Hiring case

Friday, Mar 28, 2008

* In a follow-up to a post the other day, court-appointed monitor Noelle Brennan has doled out an average award of about $8,400 to more than 1,400 people for the City Hall hiring fiasco. Another 104 people who submitted claims were found ineligible for a half-dozen reasons.

One person got $100,000 from the $12 million pool of money. Brennan also awarded $45,000 to two people; $55,000 to three people; $65,000 to six people; and $75,000 to another half-dozen individuals.

The 18 people in the top tier of awards “provided detailed accounts of discrimination and numerous pages of supporting documentation,” according to her report:

“Some claimants detailed sham interviews in which they were asked irrelevant questions and told that the position was already filled by a pre-selected candidate. Claimants were told that they would never be promoted unless they contributed time and/or money to city-sponsored candidates,” the report states.

You can view the report here, however, none of the people getting money were named in the report.

* One of the biggest winners was the son of Ald. Bernie Stone.

Jay Stone was awarded $75,000 because of his claim that he was a sure loser in his 2003 aldermanic election against Ald. Ted Matlak (32nd) because Matlak had the support of the political army commanded by now-convicted former First Deputy Water Commissioner Donald Tomczak:

“I’m in shock. I’m in awe,” Jay Stone said. “The message is we should hold fair and competitive elections in Chicago. I never stood a chance because I was up against a seasoned political army that was being paid for by the taxpayers of Chicago.”

This strikes me as a little crazy. I can understand the argument for doling out compensation to people who may have lost city jobs or appointments because of a rigged process. (Even though I don’t know if I necessarily agree with that because it hasn’t actually changed the system.)

But to give an alderman’s son $75,000 because he lost an election because “he didn’t have any clout”? If you go by that logic there are people all over the city who should be cashing in. Discuss.

- posted by Kevin Fanning


14 Comments
  1. - Ghost - Friday, Mar 28, 08 @ 10:48 am:

    the whole payout system makes no sense. Giving more money to people because they have better complaints….REGARDLESS of their actual qualifications compared to the other applicants for a position?

    For any single job, only one person can get it. If they really want to do this bizarre settlment, they need to gather the applicants by position, and determine who would have got the job based on qualifications. That single person then gets the reward.

    No money should be given for losing an election. The settlment is just as corrupt as the solution, paying out dead beats and whiners. Il courts are filled with people who had lots of pages of alleged corruption they self servingly created, and lost their claims at summary judgment. This whole thing is a sham.

    Somone should see hom many people are being compensated for the loss of th same job!!! after all only one person could have ever got the position, but unbder this sham every applicant gets paid.

    This is past nuts, it would look like the bad plot to a sopa opera if it were not real life.


  2. - wordslinger - Friday, Mar 28, 08 @ 11:01 am:

    Jay Stone appears to have some clout with Brennan. I guess you can’t blame the guy for asking, but what prompted her to make the award? What in the world does it have to do with Shakman? There are a lot of loser candidates kicking themselves this morning that they didn’t come up with this weird, but successful, complaint.


  3. - Independent - Friday, Mar 28, 08 @ 11:21 am:

    The whole system for awarding the $12 million has been arbitrary and kind of goofy. It’s sad that Daley got so greedy a hiring monitor was needed in the first place.


  4. - Outsider looking in - Friday, Mar 28, 08 @ 11:29 am:

    By this logic, Jim Oberweis and John Cox should be able to recoup the millions they’ve dropped in their respective races over the years, since the insiders and combine denied them office. Brennan and Cox were truly unsuited for this job. OF COURSE Stone was denied a position with City government based on politics when he SOUGHT EMPLOYMENT THROUGH THE POLITICAL SYSTEM!


  5. - Kevin Fanning - Friday, Mar 28, 08 @ 11:32 am:

    I should have known that this post would elicit Combine responses….


  6. - Levois - Friday, Mar 28, 08 @ 12:06 pm:

    Uh-oh I think Mr. Fanning is a believer now! Unless of course that’s sarcasm.


  7. - BannedForLife - Friday, Mar 28, 08 @ 12:07 pm:

    “If you go by that logic there are people all over the city who should be cashing in.”

    starting with fir-instance Bernie Stone challengers Naisy Dolar or Greg Brewer, given that two Stone campaign workers are in court charged with vote fraud?


  8. - Wow - Friday, Mar 28, 08 @ 12:20 pm:

    What a joke. Stone lost 3-1 to Matlak because he was a stooge. Waguespack was a weak candidate, with every bit as much political opposition, and still managed to beat Matlak.


  9. - Napoleon has left the building - Friday, Mar 28, 08 @ 2:19 pm:

    You’re right the Jay Stone thing is just crazy.

    Maybe I should apply for some of that cash because I decided to not run against my Alderman because I knew she would beat me with her machine. That’s a totally ridiculous payout. If I were still a City taxpayer I’d sue over her allocation of that settlement, just beyond stupid. If Jay Stone really wanted a City job I’m sure his old man could have scored him one BTW - LOL.


  10. - Aaron Slick - Friday, Mar 28, 08 @ 2:41 pm:

    Alderman Stone’s kid seems like he meets all of the qualifications for a political job in Chicago: He believes in “entitlements”, he believes in “nepotism”, and he has no sense of shame nor any understanding of the concept of honor & integrity.

    He should go far in Cook County and Chicago politics.


  11. - Captain America - Friday, Mar 28, 08 @ 3:55 pm:

    I thought the purpose of the fund was to compensate applicants and employuees who were denied job opportunities because of pre-selction or other related patronage practices. Givng Stone’s son $75,000 because he lost an aldermanic election that he never had any chance of winning in the first place is absolutely ridiculous. This allocation to Jay Stone leads me to question Brennan’s competence.


  12. - Nero - Saturday, Mar 29, 08 @ 10:49 am:

    This payout to Stone is totally absurd and sets a horrible precedent. This is the type of stunt we’d expect from the Blago or Stroger administrations…not the federal monitor! As a taxpayer of Chicago, there needs to be a public hearing on this and Ms. Brennan needs to completely explain her actions and rationale.


  13. - Outrage - Saturday, Mar 29, 08 @ 6:27 pm:

    This is amazing. There are all kinds of candidates screwed by insiders. Should they all apply for bucks?


  14. - Annon - Monday, Mar 31, 08 @ 11:10 pm:

    Oy…give twelve monkeys a typewriter!

    Just getting way to good at playing the game and not worrying at all about any rammfications for our actions.


TrackBack URI

Sorry, comments for this post are now closed.


ON THE BLOG TODAY...
* Reader comments closed for the weekend
* No respect
* Question of the day
* Budget intrigue
* The politics of violence
* House votes to ban guv's billboards
* Morning Shorts
* SUBSCRIBERS ONLY - Today's edition of Capitol Fax
** Yesterday's blog posts

Search This Blog...

Search the 95th General Assembly By Bill Number
(example: HB0001)

Search the 95th General Assembly By Keyword

Quick Links


Main Menu
Home
Illinois
YouTube
Pundit rankings
Obama
Subscriber Content
Durbin
Polls

Archives
May 2008
April 2008
March 2008
February 2008
January 2008
December 2007
November 2007
October 2007
September 2007
August 2007
July 2007
June 2007
May 2007
April 2007
March 2007
February 2007
January 2007
December 2006
November 2006
October 2006
September 2006
August 2006
July 2006
June 2006
May 2006
April 2006
March 2006
February 2006
January 2006
December 2005
April 2005
March 2005
February 2005
January 2005
December 2004
November 2004
October 2004

Blog*Spot Archives
November 2005
October 2005
September 2005
August 2005
July 2005
June 2005
May 2005

Syndication

RSS Feed 2.0
Comments RSS 2.0
WordPress

 

  
  » First real photo of the Treo 800w
  » Google's Vic Gundotra on the iPhone
  » Free BlackBerry Download: BlackBerry Wallet
  » MegaPhone now PhoneView: an app by any other name would smell as sweet
  » iPhone coming to various African markets, Belgium, more
  » Orange to Sell iPhone in Europe, Middle East, and Africa
  » Orange to grow iPhones in Europe, Middle East, and Africa
  » iStyles now available for the Palm Treo and Centro
  » First Real Treo 800w Picture!
  » John Mayer Spotted With BlackBerry Bold
  » BlackBerry Enterprise Server 4.1.6 Beta Available To Partners
  » Picture of the Treo 800w
In Association with feed dot informer dot com

  » Firefox 3 Release Candidate 1 Released [Beta Beat]
  » This Week's Best Posts [Highlights]
  » Fix Your Photos' White Balance [Photography Tip]
  » Automate Your BitTorrent Extraction and Organization [Organization]
  » Lebendig Animates Your Windows [Featured Windows Download]
  » Mint Tracks Your Investment Portfolio [Personal Finance]
  » The Beta Beatdown [Lifehacker Faceoff]
  » Elevator Quickly Disables UAC for Specific Programs [Featured Windows Download]
  » COOL TOOLS UNTRIED
  » Fedora 9 Puts Your Desktop on a USB Drive [Linux On A Stick]
Generated by Feed Informer

» Chicago Is My Kind of Frown
» White Sox-Giants Preview
» Ex-Diamondback is a hit in Chicago
» Chi White Sox at San Francisco
» Giants come up empty vs. White Sox
» Ramirez's first career homer lifts White Sox
» Alexei Ramirez' First HR Overshadowed by Firings, Federal Investigation
» Ramirez's first homer big for White Sox
» Rowand pays visit to White Sox
» White Sox break up lefties in rotation
Generated by Feed Informer

  » Recall gives people power to reform
  » California gay marriage ruling will affect Illinois
  » Bill targets online ticket hoarders
  » Jurors work half-day; no verdict reached
  » Morrissey truancy initiative coming down to the wire
  » Partly Cloudy: Currently 66° F
  » Thanks for the Add? New MySpace Rules Make It Safer, but Shut Out ...
  » Lawmakers aim at computer hoarding of concert tickets
  » Extra, Extra
  » Fergie added to state fair line-up
Provided by feed dot informer dot com


  » News Minute: Here is the latest Illinois news from The Associated Press
  » Ill. Guard unit returning from Iraq with no casualties
  » Jerry Springer preaches ethics to law school graduates
  » Mom of 5 kids killed in Quincy fire gets 2 years probation
  » US Airways pilots union disapproves of possible United combo
  » Boaters feeling rising fuel costs
  » Fla. lifts ban on Allstate selling new insurance policies
  » Appellate court rules Chicago not liable in club stampede
  » Scruggs ordered to turn over some records to State Farm
  » Lawmakers aim at computer hoarding of concert tickets
From FeedInformer

» Jury done for the day
» Blago memo: Turn over Rezko evidence
» The law the jury must follow
» Rezko trial: Jurors have case, day two
» Rezko trial: First jury question
» Rezko trial: Finally, the real indictment
» Rezko trial: Jury's deliberating
» Rezko calling
» Rezko trial: Feds hit back
» Female-dominated, racially diverse, jury
Supported by Feed Informer

  » Brooklyn Industries opens Bucktown outpost
  » As CME pulls up stakes, one last glance back
  » Commerce summit comes to Chicago
  » Opponents fight CN's request for study deadline
  » Ryan’s swan song at Aon annual meeting
From feed dot informer dot com



  » City has spent $9M on Olympic bid; $22M left
  » Losing racehorses in Puerto Rico condemned to die
  » Battle over swimsuits moves to the courtroom
  » Oil pushed above $127 a barrel for first time
  » Fannie Mae scraps higher downpayment requirements
  » Amputee runner wins right to try for Olympic spot
  » Autopsy: Teen with cystic fibrosis died of neglect
  » Chief: Man prime suspected in Florida fires
  » DeGeneres, de Rossi plan to marry
  » Flight attendant accused of setting fire on plane
Upholded by Feed Informer


  » Motorcycle promoter cancels swap meet over fears of violence
  » Daley's Michigan neighbor says fire may be linked to cougar death
  » Media are denied secret-hearing transcripts in R. Kelly case
  » Chicago's increased murder rate blamed on 3 multiple slaying incidents
  » Boy found with 'bone-deep' bedsores died in homicide, officials say
  » I-190 lanes near O'Hare to reopen Saturday
  » 1 killed, 1 wounded in West Side shooting
  » Man sues Willow Springs police
  » Palatine-based District 211 names new schools chief
  » Foie gras protest at City Hall draws 80
Generated by Feed Informer


  » Chicago Murders Up For 2008
  » Weis Defends Adding M-4s To Police Arsenal
  » FBI Investigating Arson Near Daley's Michigan Home
  » Food Pantries Keep an Eye on Farm Bill
  » Children's Museum Debate Too Fast for One Panelist
  » A Quarter Million People Apply for Housing Voucher Wait-List
  » R. Kelly Records Stay Sealed
  » Plan Commission Gives Nod to Children's Museum Move
  » R. Kelly Jurors Selected
  » Bobby Rush Ready to Run For Re-election
Generated by feed dot informer dot com


  » Jury indicts several
  » Appellate court rules Chicago not liable in club stampede
  » Local Guard unit coming home from Iraq
  » School bus drivers ask for help with problem children
  » Many artists are regulars at Old Capitol fair
  » Cahnman, lawmakers blast pair of bills
  » County may rent voting machines
  » Seniors eye bus to beat gas prices
  » Lawmakers aim at online concert tickets hoarders
  » Phillip Paschal lived several lives before coming here for college
Provided by feed.informer.com


  » Residents voice complaints against Salt Petre Cave at Jackson meeting
  » SIU scholarship fundraiser expected to finish on par
  » Judge hears motions in Sprind case
  » Bauer becomes new SICF executive director
  » Army husband returns in time for wife's graduation
Provided by feed.informer.com


» Neighbors in the News
» Kids art on display in Naperville
» Finding a quiet place to pray brings us closer to God
» Cook Co. religion notes
» Lake Co. religion notes
Generated by Feed Informer


  » Lincoln Bicentennial Special License Plates
  » Utica, Illinois, Political Hot Spots
  » GOPUSA ILLINOIS Daily Clips - May 16, 2008
  » Who's going to connect the dots?
  » Illinois IRV Bill Nearing Adoption
  » Con Con Considerations: Location
  » GOPUSA ILLINOIS Daily Clips - May 15, 2008
  » Jill Morgenthaler and Daniel Frawley’s Companion Security in Iraq
  » Unfunded Mandates Suddenly OK with Chicago Tribune
  » Human rights, ethics and impeacment
From FeedInformer

» Pump It Up
» Their hands form a Nicaraguan village's future
» BELTWAY ROUNDUP: Farm bill, war funding lead up to weeklong recess
» CN Railway wants ruling on EJ&E purchase
» Shimkus talks about energy crisis
» Illinois legislators aim to block expedited environmental rail review
» War Funding "Victory," Bizarro-Style
» Opponents fight CN’s effort to hurry study
» New: Railway company says grade separation not needed
» Haven Healthcare Becomes Lightning Rod In Congress
In Association with FeedInformer

» Roni Deutch Analyzes Tax Views of Remaining Three Presidential ...
» Exclusive: Give Me Libertarianism or Give Me Death
» Exclusive: Saturday, May 17
» Political Notebook by Daniel Scarpinato : Political luck seems to ...
» On the agenda
» Short and snappy comments by anonymous Observer readers on the ...
» Edwards' endorsement
» McCain says Obama, Clinton would weaken rights of gun owners
» Neither bluster nor naivete serve America well when dealing with ...
» What does 'act your age' mean?
Succoured by FeedInformer

» BELTWAY ROUNDUP: Farm bill, war funding lead up to weeklong recess
» CN Railway wants ruling on EJ&E purchase
» Illinois legislators aim to block expedited environmental rail review
» Durbin to keynote Maine Democratic convention
» A future for FutureGen?
» Opponents fight CN’s effort to hurry study
» New: Railway company says grade separation not needed
Provided by feed dot informer dot com

    » The Power of Persuasion
    » Some random thoughts ...
    » Links for 2008-05-16 [del.icio.us]
    » Guillen has healthy attitude toward racist rants directed at himself and other Latinos
    » What was Huckabee thinking?
    » Politics: Ray LaHood is getting sued
    » Tennessee GOP goes after Michelle Obama.
    » Gov. Blagojevich Announces Illinois Products Farmers' Market
    » Obama Demands VA Investigate Allegations of PTSD Misdiagnoses to Reduce Costs
    » Patrick Thompson Acquitted
    » Durbin, Bean: STB Should Reject CN Fast-Track
    » Second acts for losing Democrats?
Powered by Feed Informer





Header Photos...
Wayne Bretl
& UIS

Hosted by MCS