Subscribe to Capitol Fax      Advertise Here     Contact Rich Miller
To subscribe to Capitol Fax, click here. Subscriptions are $350 per year. To advertise on the Capitol Fax Blog, please click here.
There he goes again *** UPDATED x1 ***

Tuesday, Apr 15, 2008

* You will recall the kerfluffle last week after atheist activist and Green Party state legislative candidate Rob Sherman wrote this on his website and then deleted it

“Now that Negroes like Representative Monique Davis have political power, it seems that they have no problem at all with discrimination, just as long as it isn’t them who are being discriminated against.”

Sherman was referring to Rep. Monique Davis’ tirade against him during a House committee hearing, for which she was given Keith Olbermann’s daily “Worst Person in the World.” She later apologized for the remark, according to Sherman.

* Sherman, however, refused to apologize for his own comments. Sherman told me last week that he deleted those words after receiving an e-mail from 2006 Green Party gubernatorial candidate Rich Whitney.

Sherman claimed that at the time he “didn’t know there was anything wrong with the phrase negro.” And in the same conversation with me he went on to explain his original comment while refusing to apologize…

“Now they are blacks and have political power, so discrimination is OK, but then, when they were called negroes and had no political power, discrimination was an outrage.”

* Last night, Olbermann aimed his dart at Sherman, giving the Green Party candidate yesterday’s “Worst Person in the World” award….

* Sherman responds today on his website…

In a desperate attempt to maintain their popularity with the non-atheist majority, several Caucasian journalists have desperately grasped at a phony excuse to criticize me by condemning me for referring to Rep. Monique Davis, who is a Negro, as being, of all things, a “Negro.” […]

Rep. Davis seemed to be OK, two weeks ago, with discrimination against my group, because her group has political clout and my group doesn’t, but she retracted those statements last week. The White journalists have demanded that I apologize to Rep. Davis for not using a euphemism that Caucasian journalists approve of.

Go read the whole thing if you have the stomach.

* Zorn wrote this last week…

Sherman’s beef was with Monique Davis, legislator. Not Monique Davis black legislator or black legislators in general.

* I agreed with Zorn then and I agree even more so today after reading Sherman’s latest bizarre tirade. Sherman was and remains way, way out of bounds.

The Green Party folks have claimed that they’ve worked hard to make sure they have candidates which reflect their party’s values. This is their first test. Rich Whitney apparently stepped up to the plate once, but Sherman seems to have since ignored his advice after once briefly agreeing with him. Let’s see if Whitney or somebody else in the Greens does so again.

*** UPDATE *** Zorn weighs in

(E)very effective crusader needs to be able to tell the difference between when he’s fighting the good fight and when he finds himself where Sherman finds himself today, on the wrong side of a bad fight.

- posted by Rich Miller


26 Comments
  1. - Anonymous - Tuesday, Apr 15, 08 @ 7:28 am:

    I am REALLY uncomfortable with the rationalization that if someone uses a racial epitaph, that person’s beef can be with “the individual”, and might not be with the racial minorities in general.

    Zorn & Rich - you guys tolerating this is unacceptable. You are opening the door to allowing racial epitaph to be used against individuals, and merely writing them off as “bizarre tirades”. Dangerous ground, gang.

    Please, please, please….rethink this. I know Zorn is buddies with Sherman, but we cannot allow the media (especially the Chicago Tribune) to sanction such hatred.

    The ONLY acceptable course of action here is to unconditionally condemn Sherman, and other people motivated by such racial hatred.

    If the Green Party does not kick Sherman out for this outrage, I will seriously question their ability to hold any political office.

    And please do not tell me to ‘lighten up’. I feel very strongly about this issue.

    Thank you.


  2. - downhereforyears - Tuesday, Apr 15, 08 @ 7:35 am:

    Like I said last week on this blog….he loves the attention….lets let him fade into oblivion where he belongs…not because of his beliefs….but because he is just an unhappy, ignorant soul with nothing better to do.. Mr.Sherman you have had your 15 minutes!


  3. - Yellow Dog Democrat - Tuesday, Apr 15, 08 @ 7:39 am:

    Is this the best leader that the Green Party and atheists can find? Sad, sad, sad.


  4. - Rich Miller - Tuesday, Apr 15, 08 @ 7:41 am:

    ===Zorn & Rich - you guys tolerating this is unacceptable.===

    I won’t speak for Eric, but I haven’t given him a pass on anything. Not sure what you’re talking about.


  5. - Believer - Tuesday, Apr 15, 08 @ 8:14 am:

    Sherman is a fool for any number of reasons, to me in this case for his “group” collectivist ideology, as in “her group” versus “my group”, immediately lumping all blacks together into one monolithic group and all of “his group” together into one homogeneous group, as if they all think and act alike, and share the same preferences. It’s collectivist ideology at its worst.

    That said, criticism for using the term “Negro” is more problematic. Yes, it is dated and has in many areas fallen into disuse, but to my knowledge is not an insult. Many words in the Oxford English dictionary fit this criteria, but are not stricken from th English language.

    But I’ll take any reasonable excuse to laugh at the buy.


  6. - Ghost - Tuesday, Apr 15, 08 @ 8:38 am:

    This is the big problem most have with thinking of the green party seriously, too many fringe canidates. Every party has its share of persons everyone wishes was not in the party, but the greens have such a small number of canidates to begin with they come across as having a higher percentage of questionable canidates. This guy sounds more like a member of the KKK pushing white power. I am convinced that a government with sherman in it is one that will target minorities because they are minorities. Speaking in a derogotory way based upon sterotypes made based upon a discrminatory attitude is hardly the vehicle upon which to have a real discssion. The Greens need to kick this guy out or start wearing their white hoods on the campaign trail.


  7. - Wumpus - Tuesday, Apr 15, 08 @ 9:00 am:

    The problem is that Davis identifies her self as an AA legislator (to Anon, the pirst response). As for Olberman, he is silly and childish. Still not Squidishi?


  8. - Anonymous Green - Tuesday, Apr 15, 08 @ 9:14 am:

    As someone who helped and worked with the Green Party in 2006, I must say that this latest twist in this story is extremely unfortunate. After feeling spurned given Mr. Sherman’s experience with Rep. Davis, he chose to “push back” and used some terribly chosen words, and behind those words are some inherently horrid ideas.

    While none of this is criminal, it is certainly not the kind of discourse that anyone seeking public office should pursue. (Similarly, this could be said of the dismissive nature of Rep. Davis’ comments, as pertaining to atheists, but at least she had the proper sense to realize she went to far and apologized for her comments.)

    The Greens ought to cut this guy loose. From what I understand, they have had considerable progress in recruiting candidates to run for office this election cycle, but their fledgling party would be far better served by purging him, rather than keeping him in their ranks as a candidate. Considering how this started, Mr. Sherman looked to be the victim, but the manner in which he chose to fight back illustrates either an inability to keep a cool head, or underlying attitudes not in line with his party’s ethos which he expressed on a public medium.

    The argument he should have made would be about how our public representatives should not have the right to question or condemn the privately-held beliefs of the citizens whom they represent. Instead, he decided to make the argument that he felt discriminated against, and that he seemed to view it as an act of great temerity that this discrimination was coming from an African-American. In a foolish attempt to bolster his claim, he brought the legislator’s race into the argument, and in doing so, publicly discredited himself in a horrible fashion.


  9. - Rob_N - Tuesday, Apr 15, 08 @ 9:17 am:

    Rich writes, “The Green Party folks have claimed that they’ve worked hard to make sure they have candidates which reflect their party’s values. This is their first test. Rich Whitney apparently stepped up to the plate once, but Sherman seems to have since ignored his advice after once briefly agreeing with him. Let’s see if Whitney or somebody else in the Greens does so again.”

    …Hmmm, I wonder why Mr. Sherman felt the cold shoulder from Dems…

    His atheism has nothing to do with his abrasive personality, and vice versa.

    And now the Greens have seen fit, out of political expediency, to give his abrasive personality a platform for the next 6 1/2 months (or more).

    Who’s next, Libertarians? I think Scott Bludorn moved to New Hampshire for a bit (or maybe he’s back already)….


  10. - Greg - Tuesday, Apr 15, 08 @ 9:18 am:

    I think Anon 7:28 is mis-reading Zorn’s comment about legislator versus black legislator. He/she is believing to be a defense what is actually far from it. So rather than lighten up, the commenter probably ought to re-read the post. The coverage has hardly been “tolerant.”


  11. - Napoleon has left the building - Tuesday, Apr 15, 08 @ 9:44 am:

    I’m with YDD (again). Sherman has done a world of dis-service for the Greens and for atheists in general. Now the only atheist that most people can name, and maybe the only Green they can think of is out there touting his use of a word that most of us consider racist. He’s gone from being a guy with different beliefs who fights for his rights to a complete nut who is a bigot in 10 days. That wasn’t a far fall for him.

    Way to go Greens!

    That’s about five steps backward for your party.


  12. - wordslinger - Tuesday, Apr 15, 08 @ 9:45 am:

    I’m certain that Sherman is lying when he says he did not know that the term negro is offensive.

    I don’t understand why the Greens recruited him in the first place. What values does he represent?


  13. - No Peotone Airport - Tuesday, Apr 15, 08 @ 9:57 am:

    “Sherman responds today on his website… Go read the whole thing if you have the stomach.”

    I tried reading Sherman’s response and found that I, in fact, DID NOT have the stomach to read the whole thing. Now I’m curious… did anybody?


  14. - Pat Collins - Tuesday, Apr 15, 08 @ 10:16 am:

    Hey, isn’t “consensus” a part of the Green way of doing things? And so, its not like Rob S won a primary, a BUNCH of Greens thought it a good idea that he be their guy. So they just can’t dump him quickly, they need to agree on it…..


  15. - Greg - Tuesday, Apr 15, 08 @ 10:18 am:

    It wasn’t my stomach that interfered with my reading of Sherman’s post…it’s that the guy’s writing is terrible. I mean, he sets out to write what he knows will receive attention, and comes up with nuggets like “Dr. King was my # 1 hero”. Is this Borat? He also labels “black” and “African-American” euphemisms. Now, I object to “African-American” occasionaly, but calling it a “euphemism” I do not. While it may fit the technical definition, the word is more appropriately used to describe nouns like “collateral damage,” not races. I suppose I shouldn’t quote his rambling, awfully-constructed sentences, or else I’d be pasting the entire piece.


  16. - RMW Stanford - Tuesday, Apr 15, 08 @ 10:37 am:

    I dont know Mr. Sherman so I have no idea if he is a racist or not or choose his words poorly while speaking out of anger. Either way he has soon very poor judgment and the more attention that he get out of it the more damage it will do to the Illinois Green party, they should cut get rid him.


  17. - Team Sleep - Tuesday, Apr 15, 08 @ 10:52 am:

    What does Mr. Sherman hope to accomplish with his rhetoric? Does he want a continual tit-for-tat with the black members of the GA? He should have let the matter drop. Now he looks like a doofus.


  18. - Mountain Man - Tuesday, Apr 15, 08 @ 11:55 am:

    Well, team sleep, if it looks like a doofus, walks like a doofus and sounds like a doofus….

    You’d have to be a doofus to not know that the word “Negro” is a racially charged word.


  19. - Sango Dem - Tuesday, Apr 15, 08 @ 12:15 pm:

    Does Whitney think Vic Roberts represents Green Party values? The guy is a nutty conspiracy theorist. Just ask him what he thinks about the Federal Reserve.


  20. - South Side Mike - Tuesday, Apr 15, 08 @ 12:15 pm:

    About the only thing he didn’t say (though he indirectly did by referencing his phone call to his “friend”), was “I know Negroes. I like Negroes. Negroes are some of my closest friends.”


  21. - Say WHAT? - Tuesday, Apr 15, 08 @ 1:45 pm:

    Last week I defended Mr. Sherman’s rights. This week he comes off as ignorant, and needs to be ignored like a naughty child throwing a temper tantrum. Two wrongs don’t make a right. Rep. Davis has apologized for her comments. NOT very statesmanlike of Mr. Sherman. Its always good to see what someone is made out of BEFORE casting a vote. HeeHaw


  22. - Rich Miller - Tuesday, Apr 15, 08 @ 1:46 pm:

    Where’s Squid today? Hmmm


  23. - Trail Runner - Tuesday, Apr 15, 08 @ 8:58 pm:

    Who really cares what Keith Olberman thinks anyway. He was a groundbreaking ESPN anchor, but a simplistic news anchor.


  24. - Arthur Andersen - Tuesday, Apr 15, 08 @ 9:01 pm:

    Rich-have you seen this dude’s truck? It’s kinda like a modern version of the the one that old huckster Mr. Haney had on Petticoat Junction. You know, with the scam of the week on old windowshades. Sherman’s rig is a little fancier and looks like he can live, campaign, broadcast, book travel, plan vacations, and do light hauling (up to 6 pallets!) all at the same time!

    I just don’t see how a ride like that is very Green, though.


  25. - T.J. - Wednesday, Apr 16, 08 @ 8:13 pm:

    There is a difference between “epitaph” and “epithet,” correct?


  26. Pingback Ill Reviewers earn their dunce caps « Illinois Reason - Wednesday, Apr 23, 08 @ 5:12 pm:

    […] John “Poopy Head” Ruskin compares a journalist — Rich Miller — who covers Springfield and other Illinois political matters to Ted Kaczynski, the Unabomber. Why? Because Miller posted a few facts that put the lie to the spin being promoted by a comrade of Ruskin’s. In his role as a reporter, Miller has gone after Dems, GOPs and even Greens with equal aplomb when they fib, flop or go flakey, as Sen. Steve Rauschenberger has been doing of late in his anti-Obama zeal. This isn’t the first time the pseudonymous Ruskin has flailed around spewing crap instead of keeping his bizarre inanities to himself… (What’s that? There’s a financial stake for the denizens of Illinois Review to prop up the head of the United Republican Fund, an organization that so many of them also help operate? Go figure…) […]


TrackBack URI

Sorry, comments for this post are now closed.


ON THE BLOG TODAY...
* Still nervous? You should probably calm down
* ITLA ad, Durbin on Madigan and lots of campaign videos
* Question of the day
* This just in... Hynes not interested in LG spot
* This just in... Gianulis dies
* Who's to blame? And what way forward?
* Report: Hynes would consider LG offer
* An almost perfect week
* Morning Shorts
* SUBSCRIBERS ONLY - Today's edition of Capitol Fax (use all CAPS in password)
** Yesterday's blog posts

Search This Blog...

Search the 96th General Assembly By Bill Number
(example: HB0001)

Search the 96th General Assembly By Keyword

Quick Links


Main Menu
Home
Illinois
YouTube
Pundit rankings
Obama
Subscriber Content
Durbin
Burris
Polls

Archives
February 2010
January 2010
December 2009
November 2009
October 2009
September 2009
August 2009
July 2009
June 2009
May 2009
April 2009
March 2009
February 2009
January 2009
December 2008
November 2008
October 2008
September 2008
August 2008
July 2008
June 2008
May 2008
April 2008
March 2008
February 2008
January 2008
December 2007
November 2007
October 2007
September 2007
August 2007
July 2007
June 2007
May 2007
April 2007
March 2007
February 2007
January 2007
December 2006
November 2006
October 2006
September 2006
August 2006
July 2006
June 2006
May 2006
April 2006
March 2006
February 2006
January 2006
December 2005
April 2005
March 2005
February 2005
January 2005
December 2004
November 2004
October 2004

Blog*Spot Archives
November 2005
October 2005
September 2005
August 2005
July 2005
June 2005
May 2005

Syndication

RSS Feed 2.0
Comments RSS 2.0
WordPress
 

  
  » BlackBerry Curve #1 Selling Smartphone In The States… Again… I’m Calling BS Just Little Bit…
  » Apple releases iPhone OS 3.1.3, jailbroken a week later
  » Neo Nectaris strategy game arrives on the iPhone
  » iHound aims to help you find your missing iPhone
  » Review: McSweeney's for iPhone

  » Samsung TicToc Shakeable MP3 Player
  » zoomIt Adds Storage Expansion To The iPhone
  » From the Tips Box: Backyard Igloos, Sink Mats, and Taskbar Arrangement [From The Tips Box]
  » Remains of the Day: Netflix Streaming's 1080p Upgrade Edition [For What It's Worth]
  » TweetDeck Updates with YouTube and Flickr Support, Improved Column Navigation [Updates]

» White Sox Un-Retire #11, Vizquel to wear Aparico's number with his ble..
» Vizquel to wear Aparicio's No. 11
» Hey, who wants to sit around and talk about 2005?
» South Side Sox 2010 Fantasy Baseball Challenge
» Boyer: Any buzz must translate to wins

 
     


  » Rep. John Murtha, voice for veterans, dies at 77 1....
  » The Perfect Storm for Illinois Dems - FrumForum..
  » Click here to view the Whig Gallery - Quincy Heral....
  » Now vacant: Lt. governor nomination - Peoria Journ....
  » Cohen's Out -- Who's Next? - WGNtv.com..
  » Illinois politics again cause spinning in Lincoln’....
  » Continued: Quinn: Anyone who wants to be Illinois'....
  » Quinn: Anyone who wants to be Illinois' Dem. lieut....
  » Quinn: Ill. lt. governor hopefuls should speak up ....
  » If you want lieutenant gov job, speak up, Quinn sa....


  » Group makes deal to buy land near Hollywood sign
  » Boeing's 747-8 freighter completes first flight
  » Northern Illinois braces for snow storm
  » Chicago Transportation Authority reduces service
  » Biggest Boeing 747 ever takes to the sky
  » US Gives $78.5M to Fight Carp
  » United Airlines sees January traffic rise
  » Dow closes below 10,000 points
  » Motorola backs social music service TuneWiki
  » Bally's new marketing chief from United Airlines

  » United Airlines sees January traffic rise
  » State Farm claims it warned feds of Toyota problem in '07
  » Derivatives banned from Ill. public pension funds under proposed bill
  » Former Boeing engineer gets 15-year prison sentence
  » Feds eye traffic restrictions through Chicago locks to keep out Asian carp



  » Pace route cuts hit suburban bus riders
  » Report: Zion-Benton high school dean faces drug charges
  » Snow, CTA cuts could leave commuters struggling
  » Murder victim's family sees suspect in 1984 crime
  » 3 kids, adult hurt in Southwest Side crash
  » Feds may close locks to stop Asian carp
  » Murder victim found in Little Village alley was Stickney man
  » Missing girl last seen at Prosser H.S. returns home
  » Hanover Park man gets 20 years for home invasions
  » Smoke sends crews to Tinley Park Mental Health Center


  » Blue Monday for Some in Indiana
  » Quinn: No Money Deal for Cohen
  » Durbin Says Giannoulias Should Answer Questions About Family Bank Involvement
  » Rider Outrage at CTA Service Cuts
  » CTA Cuts are Here
  » Cohen Ends Troubled Candidacy, Dems Jockey to Replace Him
  » Democratic Lt. Gov. Candidate Scott Lee Cohen Exits Race Amid Furor
  » A Mixed Reaction from Cohen's City Council Supporters
  » Cohen Could Lose Another Endorsement Monday
  » Emergency CTA Summit Fails

» Ex-Cohen girlfriend: 'Politicians should be beyond reproach'
» Blago lawyers refused prosecution trial plans
» Downstate Democratic leader dies
» State senator threatened with eviction from suburban office
» Hynes would consider spot on ticket with Quinn if asked


  » Sullivan, Koehler say no contact about lieutenant governor nomination
  » Cohen move gives Democrats a rare do-over
  » Regional changes could have altered primary election results
  » Judge denies early look at prosecution evidence in Blagojevich case
  » Ashland asks residents to conserve water
  » Snow to make for messy morning commute
  » Virden man gets 4 years for helping wife with bank robbery
  » Quinn: Lt. governor hopefuls should speak up
  » Lincoln monument unveiling Tuesday at Amtrak station
  » Lincoln alderman, 29, dies


  » Nation can’t afford Obama’s spending plan
  » Winter weather strikes again
  » Southern Illinoisans stock up ahead of snowstorm
  » SIC students help build Habitat For Humanity house
  » Dream Baskets is inaugural honoree of WISBDC campaign


» Man guilty in Gurnee car burglaries
» Annual Lake Co. senior day to be leaner
» Naperville to cut ribbon on 10th fire station
» Police release Batavia bank robber photos
» Prosecutors seek do-over in ex-Aurora coach's verdict


  » Dems must pick new lt. gov candidate
  » GOPUSA ILLINOIS Daily Clips - February 8, 2010
  » GOPUSA ILLINOIS Daily Clips - February 7, 2010
  » GOPUSA ILLINOIS Daily Clips - February 6, 2010
  » A look back at recounts and the lt. governor's post

» RI County Democratic powerbroker dies - Quad ..
» FTC probing CVS Caremark's prescription drug ..
» The Election File: Those 19 men and 19 women ..
» Walsh, local activists center stage at tea pa..
» 'Landmark' International Violence Against Wom..
» Chicago Daily Observer - Chicago Daily Observ..
» Women Thrive Applauds Introduction of Biparti..
» Quinn: Ill. lt. governor hopefuls should spea..
» Yakima Valley college offering college fair -..
» US to commit $78.5M to try to halt Asian carp..

» Tuesday Ten: Is Congress Convalescent? - The .....
» Attempt to Combat Global Warming Falls Victim.....
» US to commit $78.5M to try to halt Asian carp.....
» Michigan Dems "Wouldn't Embark On Any Race" W.....
» Plan would give businesses tax credit for new.....

» Column: I'll take the Senate seat for $500! -.....
» Voters should step up, be more involved in st.....
» What is it about Illinois politicians? - Wash.....
» Durbin to serve as campaign chairman for Gian.....
» Durbin backs Giannoulias in Illinois - CNN Po.....

    » Feeling sorry for Cohen and others
    » `Mike Mulligan is almost certainly dead'
    » Using Scott Lee Cohen
    » Naming that tune: `Soldier's Joy'
    » Juliet to return to Michigan Ave? Montgomery Ward balconies are back.
    » The Quiet War: Architecture and Digital, plus the Marquettes Tiffany mosaics - 2 more February events
    » Michigan Dems "Wouldn't Embark On Any Race" Without Vetting Candidate
    » More Details On The Cohen Replacement Process
    » Good Question
    » Federal, State Officials Unveil Asian Carp Strategy


Header Photos...
Wayne Bretl & UIS


Hosted by MCS