Home | Subscribers Only | AIM | Contact | Mobile | Subscribe | Classifieds | Calendar | Resumes
To subscribe to Capitol Fax, click here. Subscriptions are $350 per year. To advertise on the Capitol Fax Blog, please click here.
Recall Roundup

Wednesday, Apr 30, 2008

* I live-blogged this yesterday, so let’s do a quick wrap-up of what we already know and move from there

Senate Democrats on Tuesday advanced their own version of a proposal to let voters remove the governor and other elected officials, a move critics said was aimed at throwing the recall effort off track by running out the clock.

The competing Senate recall legislation would add local officials such as judges, mayors and county board presidents to the public servants who could be booted.

It also would require both the governor and lieutenant governor to be recalled together rather than just one or the other. That’s because they run together as a team in general elections, said Sen. Rickey Hendon (D-Chicago), the new plan’s architect.

* Quinn’s reaction

Lt. Gov. Pat Quinn, a Blagojevich critic and a strong proponent of the recall measure, criticized that provision in committee testimony. “I don’t believe I should have my record judged'’ based on the governor’s record, Quinn said. But he supported the measure anyway, calling it “a moment in history'’ for Illinois.

* There’s no guarantee yet that this will pass

All 22 Senate Republicans figure to support the plan. But the question will be if or how hard Jones works to keep at least 14 of his members off the ballot initiative to keep it from getting the necessary 36 votes to move to the House.

* And there’s also a disagreement on when Gov. Blagojevich might be recalled if the voters approve it in November…

…the soonest Blagojevich could be recalled would be the 2010 primary, said Sen. Dan Cronin (R-Elmhurst), the amendment’s chief Senate sponsor.

Quinn, however, said a gubernatorial recall could occur as early as “late summer or early fall” of next year.

* There is some hope among Blagojevich allies that this recall proposal might lance the boil and stop or slow talk of impeachment, and Quinn seems to be helping that along

Despite allegations of potential wrongdoing, it’s too early to launch impeachment proceedings against Gov. Rod Blagojevich, his running mate said Tuesday.

As talk of impeachment echoes through the Statehouse, Lt. Gov. Pat Quinn said he’d rather see the state Senate give voters the opportunity to recall elected officials.

“I think its time to trust the people,” Quinn said.

* On a related note, Michigan has a recall law, and some angry voters in that troubled state are raising money and organizing to recall the House Speaker and other state legislators….

A group aiming to recall state lawmakers for approving tax increases reports raising more than $100,000 since late October.

The recall effort recently has focused on House Speaker Andy Dillon, a Democrat from Wayne County’s Redford Township.

* There’s also a recall move against Detroit’s mayor

Wayne County officials approved language for a recall campaign against Mayor Kwame Kilpatrick, green-lighting the second effort to oust him since the $8.4 million whistle-blower scandal broke this year.

* The Senate’s somewhat about-face on recall was due in no small part to exploding voter anger. And that helps explain why a constitutional amendment to do away with the state’s flat-tax mandate failed so miserably yesterday. Here are a bunch of stories on that front…

* Illinois Senate rejects sliding income tax proposal

* Legislators reject possible tax overhaul

* Senate rejects income tax amendment

* Senate Dems Chicken Out on Income Tax Hike Measure

- posted by Rich Miller


19 Comments
  1. - Angry Chicagoan - Wednesday, Apr 30, 08 @ 9:49 am:

    What a pretty pickle we’re in here in Illinois when the debate is over whether to impeach the governor or recall him.


  2. - Rob_N - Wednesday, Apr 30, 08 @ 9:53 am:

    The more I see Recall Fever heating up the more I think it’s a horrible idea.

    Folks seem to be running with it on raw gut emotion and sure, it sounds like a wonderful populist attempt to expand democracy, but in practice it clearly is simply a handout to narrow special interests.

    In California, one wealthy individual drove the recall process. (Yes, Darrell Issa had help, but he was in the driver’s seat in terms of funding, etc.)

    In Michigan right now anti-tax hard liners are trying to recall their state’s Speaker simply because he moved forward with a tax increase (have to pay the bills somehow).

    Recall is a tool that is too easily manipulated to hold an entire state hostage to the whims of narrow special interests.

    Impeachment is a more measured, and more readily available, tool.

    Recall won’t go on the ballot til this fall and even if it passes likely wouldn’t be able to be implemented til sometime in 2009 (the spring muni elections in April?).

    Impeachment is available right this second.

    Those editorial boards ought to be calling for impeachment, not recall.


  3. - Rob_N - Wednesday, Apr 30, 08 @ 9:54 am:

    PS: I wrote, “Recall won’t go on the ballot til this fall and even if it passes likely wouldn’t be able to be implemented til sometime in 2009 (the spring muni elections in April?).”

    Blago may be on trial or even in lockup by then…


  4. - Rich Miller - Wednesday, Apr 30, 08 @ 9:58 am:

    ===Blago may be on trial or even in lockup by then===

    Highly, highly doubtful.


  5. - Crimefighter - Wednesday, Apr 30, 08 @ 10:12 am:

    Rob_N why does who funded the recall effort in California’s matter? How does that demonstrate that the ouster of Gray Davis and election of Arnold was a complete disaster for the state?


  6. - wordslinger - Wednesday, Apr 30, 08 @ 10:29 am:

    Recall is the flavor of the month. It’s a pander to voters by legislators who are mad at Blago but don’t have the guts — yet — to impeach.

    Be careful what you wish for, too — The GOP pushed through the XXII amendment to preclude another FDR. What they prevented were third terms by Ike and Reagan.

    I think the Tribune editorial board is trying to show Zell that they have some populist moxy (ties off everybody, the boss is here).

    I hear there’s a move against Gov. Conan in Cally — A Total Recall. They want to terminate him, but he vows, “I’ll be back.”


  7. - T-Rex - Wednesday, Apr 30, 08 @ 10:29 am:

    Too bad all these clowns are not putting as much energy into a capital bill. I guess their personal agendas are not as important as our economy or public safety.


  8. - John Bambenek - Wednesday, Apr 30, 08 @ 10:30 am:

    Special interests *might* be able to get a recall on the ballot, but in the end the voters have to say yes. If you are arguing that the voters are too stupid to not realize what they are doing and simply get their strings pulled by special interests, it sounds like your real bone of contention is the prudence of having universal suffrage.


  9. - Q-C Transplant - Wednesday, Apr 30, 08 @ 10:35 am:

    A couple of items. I believe that the House and Senate cannot have a Reading of a Constitutional Amendment on the same day. If I am correct and this is the case, the House would have to have a 1st Reading on Friday, 2nd Reading on Saturday and 3rd Reading and final vote on Sunday. Also, is the House allowed to convene on non-scheduled days? I know we see this all the time at the end of session but I thought those meetings were always highly suspect since they were not scheduled and would this not be a violation of the Open Meetings Act? I know they can declare an emergency under the OMA. However, for this purpose to place a recall amendment on the ballot that would include judges, if an individual or association attempted to challenge the legality of the passage of the recall constitutional amendment, I would assume that there may be more than a few smypathetic judges.


  10. - McGruff - Wednesday, Apr 30, 08 @ 10:36 am:

    Sorry if I just overlooked this, but I haven’t noticed anybody bringing up the gubernatorial line of succession since the Senate vote. Enjoy…

    http://www.ilga.gov/commission/lrb/con5.htm


  11. - Garp - Wednesday, Apr 30, 08 @ 10:50 am:

    Why not eliminate the Lt Governor’s office completley if he doesn’t take office in the event of the Governor being removed. Isn’t that the whole point of the office?


  12. - Chanson - Wednesday, Apr 30, 08 @ 12:50 pm:

    This is all for naught; nothing will happen.


  13. - The Doc - Wednesday, Apr 30, 08 @ 3:00 pm:

    I applaud Quinn for calling Hendon’s bluff. Hollywood is no doubt pandering to Emil Jones, and crafted the Senate proposal with the idea that Quinn, the state’s most vocal proponent of recall, would denounce it, therefore providing cover to the legislators when it didn’t pass. Truly despicable political grandstanding.


  14. - Rob_N - Wednesday, Apr 30, 08 @ 3:06 pm:

    Leave it to Bambenek to completely misrepresent what I and others are saying.

    My contention is that it ain’t broke so don’t fix it. We have impeachment in this state. If the goal is simply to remove Blagojevich, instead of getting worked up about something that is a stretch to accomplish in the first place (because it doesn’t yet exist) our energy as citizens ought to be focused on demanding impeachment.

    The lege already has grounds given what Blago did with executive orders and budget transfers last year.

    Crimefighter, the point is that a wealthy individual (or organization) could rather easily bankroll a recall effort.

    Yes, the voters can ignore it or vote it down, but the cognitive capital wasted in alternatively promoting or opposing any given future recall will be a huge drain on the state (something “drown the government” types may favor regardless).

    There’s a reason impeachment is both difficult and easy.

    It’s difficult in that it is not directly implemented by the citizenry — it has to be initiated by one or the other chamber. This means we, as citizens, need to compel our legislators to make it happen. (In essence, a recall initiative would be a cop-out on the lege’s part.)

    It’s easy in that it is available right now (no need to wait til November to vote on creating the power) and there are no defined parameters for an impeachable offense. A given governor could sneeze funny and it would be grounds for impeachment (not saying that would be strong grounds for impeachment, but it could be used as a rationale nonetheless).

    We already have impeachment powers in Illinois.

    If you feel strongly about recall, you ought to feel stronger about impeachment — and get on the horn with your leges.

    Rich, your point is well taken, but Fitz’ pattern of past prosecutions seem to be leading in that direction regardless. Only time will tell.


  15. - Rob_N - Wednesday, Apr 30, 08 @ 3:11 pm:

    McGruff,

    The passage you’re referring to is:

    ARTICLE V, SECTION 6. GUBERNATORIAL SUCCESSION
    (a) In the event of a vacancy, the order of succession to the office of Governor or to the position of Acting Governor shall be the Lieutenant Governor, the elected Attorney General, the elected Secretary of State, and then as provided by law.

    …I haven’t read the entire Senate version of the bill, but if it mimics California’s recall provisions then a replacement is voted on at the same time as the recall itself.

    But good point that the Speaker’s daughter is two steps away from the Gov’s office right now.


  16. - Rich Miller - Wednesday, Apr 30, 08 @ 3:15 pm:

    ===But good point that the Speaker’s daughter is two steps away from the Gov’s office right now.===

    It’s not a good point. Blagojevich and Quinn would have to both vacate through resignation or dual impeachment/removal, or they’d have to be recalled and LM would have to run for guv in the recall election.


  17. - Rob_N - Wednesday, Apr 30, 08 @ 5:25 pm:

    Rich, That’s what I was referring to in the sentence before the one you quoted: “if it mimics California’s recall provisions then a replacement is voted on at the same time as the recall itself.”


  18. - Loop Lady - Wednesday, Apr 30, 08 @ 9:30 pm:

    I don’t think Madigan necessarily wants his daughter to take over…he just wants Blago gone…I and lots of other folks couldn’t agree more…


  19. - anon - Thursday, May 1, 08 @ 12:00 am:

    Good God..all this state needs is Madigan controlling the Dem Party, the House and the Gov’s mansion. Thankfully, Pres. Obama will not let that happen!


TrackBack URI

Sorry, comments for this post are now closed.


ON THE BLOG TODAY...
* 93 percent of AFSCME members vote to ratify state contract
* Rep. Watson's welcome home party
* SUBSCRIBERS ONLY - Internal House Democratic memo on Lottery lease, capital plan (Use all caps in password)
* Question of the day
* Congressional updates *** UPDATED x1 ***
* Reform and Renewal, Part 9,691 and beyond
* Old bulls attempt GOP diagnosis, names floated for guv
* Morning Shorts
* SUBSCRIBERS ONLY - Today's edition of Capitol Fax
** Yesterday's blog posts

Support The Capitol Fax Blog
Visit our advertisers...

Search This Blog...

Search the 95th General Assembly By Bill Number
(example: HB0001)

Search the 95th General Assembly By Keyword

Quick Links


Main Menu
Home
Illinois
YouTube
Pundit rankings
Obama
Subscriber Content
Durbin
Polls

Archives
September 2008
August 2008
July 2008
June 2008
May 2008
April 2008
March 2008
February 2008
January 2008
December 2007
November 2007
October 2007
September 2007
August 2007
July 2007
June 2007
May 2007
April 2007
March 2007
February 2007
January 2007
December 2006
November 2006
October 2006
September 2006
August 2006
July 2006
June 2006
May 2006
April 2006
March 2006
February 2006
January 2006
December 2005
April 2005
March 2005
February 2005
January 2005
December 2004
November 2004
October 2004

Blog*Spot Archives
November 2005
October 2005
September 2005
August 2005
July 2005
June 2005
May 2005

Syndication

RSS Feed 2.0
Comments RSS 2.0
WordPress
 

  
  » iPhone Tethering: Why All the Drama?
  » A peek inside the ACCESS Linux Platform
  » Jabra BT530 Review
  » Speed Up Sync Time By Bypassing USB Hub
  » Your Smartphone Can Open Doors - Literally
  » Treo Software Roundup - v090508
  » Free ebooks from Harlequin, Small Beer Press, Night Shade and more
  » MacRumors: Apple Licensing Imagination's PowerVR Graphics Cores for Future Products?
  » Tip o' the Week: MiniTones
  » Palm Treo Pro Review Roundup
  » iPhone 3G signal still lame for many; Apple: “go closer to a window”
  » Sprint's Green and Rose Centros
Upholded by feed.informer.com

  » This Week's Best Posts [Highlights]
  » LabelLinks4Gmail Nests Labels in Gmail and Then Some [Featured Greasemonkey User Script]
  » Mazzick Puts Mouse Gestures on Your Thumb Drive [Featured Windows Download]
  » Latest Version of Gmail Rolling Out for IE6 [Gmail]
  » The three kinds of FREE
  » Carbon Planet Flight Emissions Calculator Determines the Footprint of your Flight [Environment]
  » Pricing sweet spots: $0 and $Lots (Yet another reason to forget micropayments)
Brought to you by feed.informer.com

» 'Play along on the treadmill to nowhere.'
» Image FanShot
» The worst-case scenario
» Quentin out, will have wrist surgery
» Carlos Quentin to undergo surgery Monday
» Is Carlos Quentin Lost for the Season?
» Voyagers bring knockout punch to postseason
» Latest on Quentin
» Halos, White Sox to face off on TBS
» White Sox confident in October showing
From FeedInformer


  » Ill. governor targets 2 care facilities for closing - St. Louis Post-Dispatch
  » Death penalty still in limbo in Illinois - The Southern
  » Lobby to save historical sites - Galesburg Register-Mail
  » Getting an education - Change of Subject - Chicago Tribune Blog
  » Threatening letters to public officials net eight more years in prison - Pontiac Daily Leader
  » Summary Box: Privatizing Illinois lottery - Chicago Tribune
  » Ill. House moves closer to privatizing lottery - Chicago Tribune
  » Blago: Lawmakers need to address school funding - WJBC News
  » State chamber of commerce head mulling run for governor - Clout Street - Chicago Tribune Blog
  » Ill. state workers' union OKs 4-year contract - WTHI
From feed dot informer dot com


  » Chicago man gets 15 years for fatal hit-and-run
  » Authorities outside bank in suburban Chicago
  » Police block off streets outside bank in suburban Chicago
  » Problem with radar causes delays at O'Hare
  » Hostage drama hits Wheaton
  » Man admits trying to have witnesses killed
  » Chicago Ford plant to eliminate 600 part-time jobs
  » AFSCME approves 4-year deal with Illinois
  » Promoter of safe driving for teens killed
  » Blagojevich tries to restrict campaign donors
Brought to you by feed dot informer dot com

  » Boeing talks fail; machinists to strike
  » SEC accuses suburban man of $1.2M in fraud
  » Hostage drama hits Wheaton
  » AFSCME approves 4-year deal with Illinois
  » UR Chicago mag to cease print, go Web only
From feed.informer.com


  » Doctor delivers baby in front seat of Camry
  » Doc is heart of Korean community
  » Grueling Navy SEAL drill not for meek
  » CHA makeover boost: $10,000 for home buyers
  » Police union rips moves to tighten reins on cops
  » Witnesses help cops nab suspect in 'Secondhand Bandit' robberies
  » Gang revenge led to girl's slaying: prosecutors
  » County may buy golf course from commissioner's family
  » City replaces sewer inspection firm linked to mayor's family
  » Wrongfully convicted Logan wants apology from Daley
From FeedInformer


  » Authorities ordered to return Craig Stebic's truck
  » Hostage situation ends after SWAT team enters Wheaton bank
  » State chamber of commerce head mulling run for governor
  » Wheaton officials confirm bank hostage situation
  » 2 people hospitalized after cab crashes into shop at O'Hare Airport, police say
  » Craig Stebic to get back seized truck, not firearms
  » Howe Developmental Center in Tinley Park to close
  » Fire breaks out at Portage Park rehab clinic
  » More than 150 take City Hall buyouts
  » 1 found fatally shot in Hoffman Estates home
Brought to you by feed.informer.com


  » Olympian Pays a Surprise Visit to a Chicago High School
  » Hillary Clinton Supporter Undecided
  » Obama Supporters React to McCain Speech
  » Schools Report High Attendance Amid Boycott
  » John McCain Accepts the GOP Nomination
  » Vaccine Choice, or Risky Move?
  » No New Trial for Alton Logan: 'It's Over With'
  » Schock Steps on the Big Stage
  » Some Hoosiers Undecided In Presidential Pick
  » LaHood: Illinois GOP Can Get 'Back on the Map'
Succoured by Feed Informer


  » State changing mental health services
  » Sparrow in Sangamon County found to have West Nile
  » LPGA backs down on English requirement
  » Pawnee's Cole making up for lost time
  » AFSCME members approve new contract
  » State Chamber of Commerce head considering gubernatorial run
  » City looking at buying gravel pit for backup water supply
  » Rev. Jesse Jackson released from Chicago hospital
  » Jobless rate jumps to 5-year high of 6.1 percent
  » Fire at vacant house under investigation
Provided by feed dot informer dot com


  » Dean wants research in the hands of superintendents
  » Man admits to plotting to have witnesses killed
  » Death penalty still in limbo in Illinois
  » Carbondale to open new maintenance, environmental services building
  » Officials return to the subject of new jail in Williamson County
Supported by feed.informer.com


» Man accused in courthouse bomb threat now charged in conspiracy scheme
» Friday farming: Playing your requests ...
» Reward offered as armed robber strikes Schaumburg again
» No Lowe's, Meijer for Rand Road property
» Teen safety program earns Crystal Lake cop international accolade
Supported by feed.informer.com


  » Friday follow-up
  » Exploring Ideology and Partisanship in Political Polling
  » Unemployment Numbers: Good News for Obama, Bad News for Rod
  » GOPUSA ILLINOIS Daily Clips - September 5, 2008
  » Illinois and the Republican National Convention--and my upcoming radio appearances
  » Dr. Blagojevich, you’ve created a monster!
  » GOPUSA ILLINOIS Daily Clips - September 4, 2008
  » Distributing School Resources in Chicago
  » 11th Congressional Candidate Debate
  » Dick Tracy for McHenry County Seal
Generated by Feed Informer

» Rockford Police Getting Money to Hire More Officers - WREX-TV
» Dems Pounce On New Unemployment Numbers - CBS News
» JUSTIN AKERS CHACON: Stop the workplace raids - Belleville News Democrat
» Kirk, Sizemore Win in Speedrome World Figure 8 Kick-Off - WhoWon.com
» Dems pounce on new unemployment numbers - Politico
» Illinois' Schock could become youngest congressman - Chicago Tribune
» Waiting for Obama at Invesco, Scha
» Hog roast focuses on 34 Voices - Burlington Hawk Eye
» Hare ready to fight for Illinois - Burlington Hawk Eye
» Hare addresses Higher Education Act - Western Courier (subscription)
Supported by feed.informer.com

» Sarah Palin brings hope to the misdirected GOP - Canada Free Press
» Barack Obama — Magna Cum Saudi? - Investor's Business Daily (subscription)
» US election at-a-glance: 5 Sept - BBC News
» Oprah Denies Shutting Out Palin - AOL News Newsbloggers
» Most Clinton backers say Palin's too far a stretch - WAND
» Sarah Palin for President: Support Base Grows - Gambling911.com
» A new age dawns for political oratory - WA today
» Local Reaction to McCain Speech | KXNet.com North Dakota News - KXMC
» Biden campaigns in Pennsylvania - 6abc.com
» USA ISRAEL September Surprise for Attack on Iran - Pakistan Daily
In Association with FeedInformer

» Extra, Extra - Chicagoist
» Illinois' Schock could become youngest congressman - Chicago Tribune
» Ground Noise and Static - American Thinker
» Texbook Law Will Help College Students Shop Around, But Not Until 2010 - WBBM780
» Who will be the new stars in Illinois GOP? - Beep
» Springfield tourism numbers down; closings won't help - Southtown Star
» Bill aims to raise funds for mental health care - Daily Illini
» Editorial: Let's get sold on solar - Daily Eastern News
» Durbin Wants Textbook Cost Accountability - WGIL Radio News
» Faith and politics - Belleville News Democrat
From feed.informer.com

    » McCain isn't the only one shaking things up
    » New Spy: Scared of Ghosts?
    » Getting an education
    » "Labor Is"
    »