Home | Subscribers Only | AIM | Contact | Mobile | Subscribe | Classifieds | Calendar | Resumes
To subscribe to Capitol Fax, click here. Subscriptions are $350 per year. To advertise on the Capitol Fax Blog, please click here.
Dump the grandfather clause or apply it to everyone

Monday, May 19, 2008

* I see a huge problem with this US Senate development

The Senate Thursday night voted to nullify a Federal Communications Commission rule that allows media companies to own a newspaper and a television station in the same market.

The unusual “resolution of disapproval,” sponsored by Sen. Byron Dorgan, D-N.D., and 26 other senators, was approved by a voice vote. The measures sponsors include both Democratic candidates for president, Sens. Hillary Rodham Clinton of New York and Barack Obama of Illinois.

Republican FCC Chairman Kevin Martin has described the agency’s action as a “relatively minor loosening” of broadcast media ownership restrictions. The rule was approved by the FCC on a 3-2 party-line vote in December with both Democrats dissenting.

The FCC decision allows one company to own a newspaper and a broadcast station in the nation’s 20 largest metropolitan areas. The TV station may not be among the top four in the market, and post-transaction, at least eight independent media voices must remain. The rule replaced an outright ban on cross-ownership.

* In Chicago, the Tribune is grandfathered into the law so its parent company can own WGN TV/Radio and CLTV. That means the Trib can better weather a downturn in newspaper ad revenues. The Sun-Times, which was once owned by Marshall Field and long ago sold off Channel 32, is not insulated. If you take even a quick look at the Sun-Times Media Group’s financial statements, you’ll see what dire straits that company is in right now. A buyout by a TV station or cable company could save it.

I’m far less worried about cross-ownership than I used to be. The Tribune has shown that it can be a healthy thing for the market.

So, my opinion is either get rid of the unfair grandfather clause, or expand it to everyone else.

What do you think?

- posted by Rich Miller


14 Comments
  1. - Snidely Whiplash - Monday, May 19, 08 @ 11:31 am:

    This one is a double-edged sword. On the one hand, as you said, struggling newspapers would be saved, and markets could potentially be protected from having no major newspaper coverage. On the other hand, you are setting a precedent that could be used to ease anti-trust laws in other industries. Wouldn’t it be fun to sign your paycheck over to a few monopolies each month again?


  2. - Ghost - Monday, May 19, 08 @ 11:38 am:

    The future is here, and the phrase is multimedia. The idea that print is disting from audio which is distinc from visual has long since faded away. In todays modern society cross-ownership represent the inevitable merging of content sourced to multiple methods of delivery. People want news viw the web, tv, radio and print papers. There is no reason you can not have a single source seeking to distribute along all of these avenues.

    get rid of the rule.


  3. - GoBearsss - Monday, May 19, 08 @ 11:50 am:

    What about cross-ownership of Blogs AND Faxes?!?!?!


  4. - wordslinger - Monday, May 19, 08 @ 12:23 pm:

    Ghost is right. It’s on old rule from when everyone only had a choice of Cronkite, Huntley and Brinkley and Howard K. Smith for news. Little relevance to today’s media.


  5. - VanillaMan - Monday, May 19, 08 @ 12:29 pm:

    The ban is obsolete.

    Those against it are also obsolete. This is just another case where Obama proves he really believes next year is 1959, not 2009. Just another political policy of his that reflects the past, not the future. He is so obsolete, he makes Ted Kennedy look like Buck Rogers.


  6. - Levois - Monday, May 19, 08 @ 1:13 pm:

    Perhaps the FCC shouldn’t be the arbitor of whether or not a company can own several different media outlets in a market.


  7. - plutocrat03 - Monday, May 19, 08 @ 1:22 pm:

    Seems like the old ban had good intentions, but is impractical in today’s environment.

    Years ago, there was no other place to get the news outside of the local media. Today if I am not satisfied with the local press, I can get the news from anywhere in the world. The only losers there are the advertisers who advertise in the formerly read publication.


  8. - Ghost - Monday, May 19, 08 @ 2:06 pm:

    In todays world advertisers should be allowed the ability to bundle as well; that is require the media to place adds in more then one medium.


  9. - kimsch - Monday, May 19, 08 @ 4:21 pm:

    The ban should be removed. I think that the “resolution of disapproval” is more to spank media outlets that the Dems don’t like from having multi-media outlets. i.e. Fox News Channel and the Wall Street Journal are now both owned by NewsCorp and Rupert Murdoch.


  10. - keepin up with jones - Monday, May 19, 08 @ 5:18 pm:

    Lets do something before Rupert Murdoch owes everything.


  11. - so-called "Austin Mayor" - Monday, May 19, 08 @ 5:37 pm:

    Perhaps the cross media grandfather clause should be applied by market instead of by property. Thus if the Trib has grandfather protection, the S-T can too.

    – SCAM
    so-called “Austin Mayor”
    http://austinmayor.blogspot.com


  12. - Peter - Monday, May 19, 08 @ 5:44 pm:

    Seeing how consolidation just inside the radio industry is destroying the quality and service of the industry as more and more independent owners disappear, I tend to stand against relaxing restrictions such as this.

    That said, WGN Radio is absolutely the height and quality of radio from both a service and entertainment standpoint. (No I don’t work for them, but I work in radio and know good when I hear it.) Tribune understands how to run a radio station, and the idea that they would have to sell off 720 to another owner - possibly Clear Channel or CBS - is frightening. Whatever the verdict, Trib must keep its clause.


  13. - Arthur Andersen - Monday, May 19, 08 @ 9:52 pm:

    I was going to side with the “it’s obsolete, can it” group until Peter’s post reminded me that broadcast deregulation has generally made a mess of radio, AM in particular. (Exhibit A: WGN, Exhibit B: KMOX, shadow of its once great self, Exhibit C: Jim Leach, insert your own line here)

    Perhaps there is a middle ground or market-based approach (as SCAM suggests) to this that would protect Tribune, help the S-T, but not have national consequences.


  14. - FlackrBackr - Monday, May 19, 08 @ 11:44 pm:

    i can’t say many would benefit from greater consolidation of the media, but also understand economic realities. It’s a tough, unfortunate world. Thankfully, there are blogs for more individuals to express their views, but i must say fewer voices, less divergent views in the mass media is scary.


TrackBack URI

Sorry, comments for this post are now closed.


ON THE BLOG TODAY...
* Reader comments closed until July 30 or 31
* Question of the day
* Notes to readers
* Excuses, ethics and a bit of fun
* Beyond the pale *** UPDATED x1 ***
* Morning Shorts
* SUBSCRIBERS ONLY - Today's edition of Capitol Fax
** Yesterday's blog posts

Support The Capitol Fax Blog
Visit our advertisers...

"Google Ads"

Search This Blog...

Search the 95th General Assembly By Bill Number
(example: HB0001)

Search the 95th General Assembly By Keyword

Quick Links

"Google Ads"



Main Menu
Home
Illinois
YouTube
Pundit rankings
Obama
Subscriber Content
Durbin
Polls

Archives
July 2008
June 2008
May 2008
April 2008
March 2008
February 2008
January 2008
December 2007
November 2007
October 2007
September 2007
August 2007
July 2007
June 2007
May 2007
April 2007
March 2007
February 2007
January 2007
December 2006
November 2006
October 2006
September 2006
August 2006
July 2006
June 2006
May 2006
April 2006
March 2006
February 2006
January 2006
December 2005
April 2005
March 2005
February 2005
January 2005
December 2004
November 2004
October 2004

Blog*Spot Archives
November 2005
October 2005
September 2005
August 2005
July 2005
June 2005
May 2005

Syndication

RSS Feed 2.0
Comments RSS 2.0
WordPress
 

  
  » Share Apps Between iPhones - No Hacks
  » WinPwn 2.0.0.3 successfully jailbreaks iPhone 3G for Windows
  » Treo 800w Voice Dialing Over Bluetooth - Coming Soon
  » iPhone OS 2.1 beta reveals possible turn-by-turn directions
  » 800w Threads are Churning
  » iPhone Game Roundup: Critter Crunch, Zen Pinball, Imangi, and More
  » MacRumors: Hints at iPhone Copy and Paste in Firmware 2.1? [Update]
  » Apple Changes Name Of MobileMe to MobileMess
  » Pac-Man for iPhone
  » Belkin Mini Surge Protector with USB Charger Review
  » PdaParts Disassembles the Centro
  » Better than ICE... Setting WW Standards for Emergency Contact Info
Powered by feed dot informer dot com

  » This Week's Top Downloads [Download Roundup]
  » DIY Floppy Disk Pen Holder [Tip Testers]
  » URLInfo Reveals Hidden Web Site Server Details [Web Utilities]
  » Cool Off with a Frozen Drink [Recipes]
  » Knight Rider KITT Attack Mode Revealed
  » How Coverville's Brian Ibbott Gets Things Done [Exclusive Lifehacker Interview]
  » NASA Image Library Now Available To The Public
In Association with feed dot informer dot com

» Late-inning heroics common for Sox
» Missed It By That Much
» Big innings do damage in White Sox win
» White Sox may stand pat at Deadline
» Hall of Fame class ready for induction
» Konerko out of White Sox starting lineup
» Gossage anticipates emotional day
» Brushing Up On Justin Verlander
» Game 103: White Sox (58-43) @ Tigers (52-50)
» Negro League wages discussed
Upholded by Feed Informer


  » Race disparity sharper in city traffic stops Minority motorist ... - Chicago Tribune
  » Lampe: Plugging the hole - Peoria Journal Star
  » Finke: Ethics bill could block Blagojevich's fundraising - Peoria Journal Star
  » Seneca offers ‘Safe Havens' for unwanted newborns - Morris Daily Herald
  » ‘Saving Pontiac Prison’ - Pontiac Daily Leader
  » Logan Co. businessman trying to clear his name after lawsuit - Bloomington Pantagraph
  » Daley: State needs compromise on capital program - Chicago Tribune
  » Let USSSA games begin - Northwest Herald
  » Blago Calls On Bush To Sign Housing Package - CBS2 Chicago
  » Illinois reduces funding for county fairs - Urbana/Champaign News-Gazette
In Association with FeedInformer


  » News Minute: Here is the latest Illinois news from The Associated Press
  » Man survives jump from bridge
  » UPS driver gets special, final delivery
  » Pujols' 2-run homer in 14th lifts Cards past Mets
  » White Sox hold off Tigers 7-6 for 4th straight win
  » Pitcher charged after minor league brawl in Ohio
  » Obama defends tour, says McCain shifting on war
  » Comets beat Sky, 79-65
  » Lottery Glance
  » Explosion on the Mississippi, 6 survive
Provided by feed dot informer dot com

  » Daley eyes taking control of commercial trash pickup
  » Chicago, state see Q2 foreclosure filings jump
  » S&P downgrades United, American, Northwest
  » Santo retiring from MB Financial
  » Federal Signal posts Q2 loss
Brought to you by feed.informer.com


  » Blame drivers for most dangerous intersection
  » Cops tow van thought to belong to Mya's dad
  » O'Hare's new full-body scanners spur questions about privacy
  » Family, friends, teachers honor 'respectful, conscientious' teen
  » Ex-pal dares Drew to hit him
  » 1919 all over again
  » Obama shows caution on Middle East, rabbi says
  » Misspellings, grammar errors put county mag on ice
  » Holy Name to resume weekend rites Aug. 30
  » Few takers for Mell's gun-register amnesty
Generated by FeedInformer


  » Chicago's gun turn-in program brings in 6,000 weapons
  » Taking city's pulse on a 24-mile artery: Western Avenue
  » Man killed in single-car accident in Batavia
  » Kids get free back-to-school checkups, supplies on West Side
  » Slain girl's father 'a little offended' by police tactics
  » Daley won't rule out layoffs in tough budget times ahead
  » Motorists to pay freight
  » Canadian National deal no deterrent to Metra, Amtrak, report says
  » Bush in Illinois today
  » Male skeleton found in Stickney near water plant
Generated by FeedInformer


  » Obama to Speak to Journalists in Chicago
  » Local Performer Helps College-Bound Students
  » POW/MIA Families Meet with Pentagon in Chicago
  » Congressmen Head to Iowa to Look Into Raid
  » Illinois Foreclosure Filings Jump from Last Year
  » Foreign Business Boosts US Companies
  » Busloads of Chicagoans to March in Iowa
  » Does Chicago’s Gun Turn-In Work?
  » Suburbs Get Rid of Gun Ban
  » Hester Shows Up
Provided by FeedInformer


  » Different expectations sink east-side community center
  » Carlinville plans more efficient hospital
  » Bush told Schock fundraiser crowd he plans to sign bill for Africa
  » Children’s race kicks off annual Springfield Tri Fest weekend
  » Chicago to hold fourth gun buyback
  » Fix receives full-ride, four-year scholarship
  » Six disaster-recovery centers to shut down
  » ISU officials dedicate new alumni center
  » Local foods trend sprouts up in Illinois
  » Hurdle looms for IDOT move
Provided by FeedInformer


  » To thieves, laptops are gold
  » Bring back the Metro? Gas prices boost some older cars' popularity
  » Beer War MillerCoors has eye on 'The King of Beers' crown
  » Scholar: Timing, rules decided pitch of primary battles
  » Inaugural Dale Day spreads message of nonviolence
Supported by Feed Informer


» Maryville at 125: A look back, and ahead
» Courage and inspiration: Teacher and singer battles MS diagnosis
» Aurora University houses large collection of historic prophetic charts
» Tardy utility payments to towns another sign of tough economy
» Neuqua grad places fifth in nation for archery Olympic trials
Powered by feed.informer.com


  » typetext
  » The Heat is On
  » Abboud Reports $13,755 Available for Campaign as of July 1st; Paying Canvassers
  » GOPUSA ILLINOIS Daily Clips - July 25, 2008
  » Blagojevich & Jones: Dumbest Budget Cuts Ever
  » Part 5 - Pervasive Problems at Cook County Jail - Access to Medical and Dental Care
  » GOPUSA ILLINOIS Daily Clips - July 24, 2008
  » Blagojevich's Lost Fundraiser
  » Mexican Consulate Sets Up Shop in Harvard; Drawns Demonstrators; Voter Registration
  » Wingnut Alert!
Provided by FeedInformer

» Let Johnson retire, recover - Sioux Falls Argus Leader
» Who's partisan in the 10th District? - Chicago Daily Herald
» Greenberg honest and intelligent - Chicago Daily Herald
» Vrahnos rallies, among opening day winners - The Times of Trenton - NJ.com
» Bachus to speak in Clanton Aug. 5 - Clanton Advertiser
» Peoria Welcomes Chicago Mayor Richard Daly at Peoria Civic Center - Associated Content
» Critics: Postville raid a political ploy - DesMoinesRegister.com
» Senate passes housing bill to rescue homeowners, mortgage firms - Sioux Falls Argus Leader
» New law allows emergency calls over internet - WJBC News
» Illinois/Wisconsin briefs - Dubuque Telegraph Herald
Powered by Feed Informer

» Presidential hopefuls take time on VP picks - Lansing State Journal
» Not president yet - Belleville News Democrat
» Manmohan, Bush created WTO breakthrough: report - Thaindian.com
» George Diaz | COMMENTARY - Orlando Sentinel
» Democrats hope to unseat Rep. Roy Blunt - News-Leader.com
» Obama’s Workout Makes Others Sweat - Pajamas Media
» Some letters shouldn't be printed - Allentown Morning Call
» Staged campaigns don't give hope - Allentown Morning Call
» Buying Cars In China: The Quick And Hard Sell - Anorak.co.uk (satire)
» Stealing Meaning From Obama's Western Wall Prayer - Beliefnet.com
Succoured by feed dot informer dot com

» Weekend Session Starts With DeMint, Durbin Sparring - Roll Call (subscription)
» Washington Will Miss Ray LaHood - U.S. Daily
» Budding teachers train at IMSA - Chicago Daily Herald
» The Fawning Of A Candidate - Tampa Tribune
» BELTWAY ROUNDUP: Landmark housing legislation approved - MyWebTimes.com
» Environmental impact projected for new suburban rail traffic - ABC7Chicago.com
» Annual Livestrong Summit underway - News 8 Austin
» Senate readies housing bill for passage - United Press International
» Senate GOP Blocks Oil Speculation Bill - RTT News
» Safety Policy Must Allow Producers 'A Livelihood' - FarmWeek
Generated by feed.informer.com

    » Open microphone: Post your Barack Obama jokes here
    » Links for 2008-07-26 [del.icio.us]
    » McCain Bashes Obama or How Not to Run a Campaign
    » Democratic Party Leadership Ushers in Unemployment Spike Statewide
    » Weekend Comic
    » The country's top political Web sites
    » Congressman Shimkus' Bill Signed Into Law
    » Analysis: US now winning Iraq war that seemed lost
    » Let's Have Some Weekend Fun: ChicagoCubs.com vs. WhiteSox.com
    » The John Edwards Love Child Cover-up
    » Obama lands at Midway Airport; returns from Europe, Middle East
    » Gallup Daily: Obama Retains Lead, 48% to 41%
Maintained by feed dot informer dot com





Header Photos...
Wayne Bretl
& UIS

Hosted by MCS