Home | Subscribers Only | AIM | Contact | Mobile | Subscribe | Classifieds | Calendar | Resumes
To subscribe to Capitol Fax, click here. Subscriptions are $350 per year. To advertise on the Capitol Fax Blog, please click here.
Roskam perhaps wonders aloud too much***UPDATED X1***

Monday, Oct 27, 2008

* If this Peter Roskam quote gets picked up, it might do some damage in the closing days

[Roskam] asked in the Pioneer Press interview why women can have abortions if rapists cannot be executed.

Here’s the response from Roskam’s Democratic opponent…

Lumping women who have abortions in with rapists and the death penalty? It’s offensive, demeaning to women and just downright creepy. It tells you all you need to know about Peter Roskam and what he thinks about women, even if he really doesn’t want you to know it.

*** UPDATE 1 *** [Posted by Kevin Fanning] Adding a quote forwarded to us from the Pioneer Press:

Roskam: “You know, my position is the same as Henry Hyde’s. And Henry Hyde put it best when he said, when somebody is the victim of a crime, the law currently says that a rapist can’t be put to death. That’s the law. A rapist under the court doctrines can’t be put to death. He said, why is it that the baby who is the result of that criminal behavior can be put to death? He said, isn’t that a sad, sad thing. So my feeling is, look, in the case of that, that’s the hard case, right? That’s the ultimate painful and difficult case. And what we need to do is love that person and encourage them and support them. But once people are categorized by how they were conceived and the circumstances of their conception, you end up going down a route that ultimately I don’t think we want to be.”

* Roundup…

* Young voters could rock the polls this year

* More than 40,000 turn out for early voting - Naperville home to busiest DuPage polling place

* LaHood unhappy with Schock

* Did Schock fib to a reporter?

* Newcomer, 18th district candidate says she’s not seeking political career

* Schock: Energy, defense, taxes the big issues

* Callahan demands answers from Schock while Durbin asks for funds

* Congressional hopefuls differ on energy, Iraq

* Two seek to unseat Shimkus in U.S. House district

- posted by Rich Miller


15 Comments
  1. - wordslinger - Monday, Oct 27, 08 @ 11:49 am:

    Roskam must have forgot where he was for a moment. That’s a line for when you’re singing to the choir at a private event. Whoops.


  2. - VanillaMan - Monday, Oct 27, 08 @ 11:52 am:

    ==[Roskam] asked in the Pioneer Press interview why women can have abortions if rapists cannot be executed.==

    First verify this. It is such a stupid thing to say, that we first should ensure that the quote is not taken out of context. Then ask for him to respond. It is such a stupid thing to say, we should ensure that he explains himself first.

    If the quote is correct, the context is correct, and he verifies it and doesn’t clarify it.

    Then he should lose this election for his poor judgement and lack of empathy.


  3. - Skeeter - Monday, Oct 27, 08 @ 12:07 pm:

    Wow.Roskam’s gone off the deep end. First the magazines in the PX thing. Now this.
    He makes Henry Hyde look like Ted Kennedy.


  4. - Skeeter - Monday, Oct 27, 08 @ 12:14 pm:

    I read the Roskam thing again. When I first read it, it just seemed creepy. Upon further review, it appears that he is saying that women who have abortions are the moral equalivalent of rapists.

    The implication of course is that Roskam must believe that the death penalty would be appropriate for abortion (or at least the same punishment as a rapist would receive).

    That’s about as extreme a policy as I can imagine.


  5. - shore - Monday, Oct 27, 08 @ 12:39 pm:

    The problem I have with Roskam and Schock if you look at what Roskam said in his Tribune endorsement meeting and that article aboutSchock and Iran, is that there is a lack of any serious thinking. Schock seems to think for some reason national security issues are the same today that they were 20 years ago and Roskam seems to think people still care about the culture wars and it’s a bit annoying to read as a GOP.


  6. - Carl Nyberg - Monday, Oct 27, 08 @ 12:43 pm:

    Wow! Peter Roskam should note how much trouble Michele Bachmann made for herself in Minnesota saying stupid stuff to the media.

    If the national blogs and women’s organizations get this story, Morgenthaler is going to have an extra $500,000 by this weekend.


  7. - Anon - Monday, Oct 27, 08 @ 1:31 pm:

    Actually, it makes some sense in the right context. Many people who oppose abortion on demand still concede that it’s acceptable in the case of rape. A valid question to THOSE people would be, “If it’s ok to kill a baby because it was conceived as a result of rape, why isn’t it ok to kill the rapist?”

    That said, however, the very best you can say about it is that it is incredibly insensitive and I can’t imagine anyone with half a brain asking that question outside a discussion among pro-lifers trying to clarify their own thinking.


  8. - Carl Nyberg - Monday, Oct 27, 08 @ 1:54 pm:

    What does the abortion have to do with the prosecution of the rapist?

    I get the question, if you believe “life begins at conception” then how do you justify making exceptions to abortion restrictions for rape?

    But I don’t see the issue of how to appropriately prosecute rapists as having anything to do with whether or not a woman has the option to seek an abortion.

    Is Peter Roskam willing to look in the camera and say, “I support making it illegal for women who are raped to get abortions”? Is he willing to do that? Because there are Democratic interest groups that would help Roskam get this message to his constituents.


  9. - Six Degrees of Separation - Monday, Oct 27, 08 @ 3:00 pm:

    Carl,

    Roskam is the same guy he was a week ago. Why would a sentence that took 10 seconds to utter get another $500k in donations? Are political donators that trigger-happy? Reminds me of the irrational exuberance and fear of some stock market investors. BTW, if I could shake the money tree with my lips, I’d be a non-stop talker.

    BTW, dumb comment on Roskam’s part in any case.


  10. - Bill S. Preston, Esq. - Monday, Oct 27, 08 @ 5:22 pm:

    What an idiot. Unfortunately, his opponent isn’t really much of one, so it’s unlikely that she’s going to get any traction off this.


  11. - GOP'er - Monday, Oct 27, 08 @ 6:25 pm:

    It’s only surprising to see Roskam taking time away from viciously smearing a second woman who has proudly worn the uniform of our U.S. Military, in as many elections.

    Roskam’s another me, me, me Republican who deserves to be swept out in the coming Obama tsunami in Illinois. We can run a non-trial lawyer in two years who doesn’t have to win by attacking our veterans.

    What does Roskam have against our military anyway? First he tries to take their Playboy magazines and R-rated movies away. Then if you survive your service and run against him, he smears you.

    The guy should quit congress and go over to Iraq to drive a truck or something.


  12. Pingback PoliTrix » Blog Archive » GOP Rep. Roskam: Why Can Women Have Abortions If Rapists Can’t Be Executed? - Monday, Oct 27, 08 @ 6:31 pm:

    […] Republican Congressman Peter Roskam appeared to equate abortion with the execution of rapists during an interview with the suburban Pioneer Press editorial board, a statement that Springfield chronicler Rich Miller believes “might do some damage” to the Wheaton incumbent in the final days of his close race against Democratic opponent Jill Morgenthaler. […]


  13. - wordslinger - Monday, Oct 27, 08 @ 7:14 pm:

    GOP’er, good on you.


  14. - Anonymous - Monday, Oct 27, 08 @ 8:00 pm:

    I’ve read it over and over again and still can’t figure out what it means or was intended to mean.

    I’m going to guess “no traction” because the majority of those who’d be upset by it probably weren’t voting for him anyway.


  15. - mixed meter - Tuesday, Oct 28, 08 @ 1:51 am:

    I read the Roskam thing again. When I first read it, it just seemed creepy. Upon further review, it appears that he is saying that women who have abortions are the moral equalivalent of rapists.

    That’s not how I read it. From what I can tell, his comparison is between the state and the woman, not the woman and the rapist. The state can’t kill a rapist. A woman can kill a fetus. He’s trying to say that if we insist that the state protect the life of the most vile, then why do we allow women to take the life of the innocent? He’s making a sanctity of life argument.

    It’s not my view — I’m pretty staunchly pro-choice. And it’s an odd position for him, since he supports the death penalty. He seems to be using a position he disagrees with to support one that he does agree with. But I imagine if he defines the debate on these terms — having defined an embryo as a life throughout every stage of its development and removing any considerations for the health of the mother — he would pivot by adding, “But we really should execute the bad people, regardless.”

    Abortion and the death penalty are two incredibly emotionally-charged issues. I think conflating these issues dangerously increases rancor in the discourse about them, so much so that it really should only be done by someone who is honestly and completely committed to the sanctity of ALL life argument. (Which I suppose would limit it to pro-life, anti-death penalty pacifists.)


TrackBack URI

Sorry, comments for this post are now closed.


ON THE BLOG TODAY...
* This just in... Froehlich out
* Blagojevich finishes second behind Palin
* Recall warning
* Reader comments closed for the holiday weekend
* *** UPDATED x2 *** Birkett appears in for AG
* Question of the day
* Mother Blowhard
** Yesterday's blog posts

Support The Capitol Fax Blog
Visit our advertisers...

...............

Search This Blog...

Search the 96th General Assembly By Bill Number
(example: HB0001)

Search the 96th General Assembly By Keyword

Quick Links


Main Menu
Home
Illinois
YouTube
Pundit rankings
Obama
Subscriber Content
Durbin
Burris
Polls

Archives
July 2009
June 2009
May 2009
April 2009
March 2009
February 2009
January 2009
December 2008
November 2008
October 2008
September 2008
August 2008
July 2008
June 2008
May 2008
April 2008
March 2008
February 2008
January 2008
December 2007
November 2007
October 2007
September 2007
August 2007
July 2007
June 2007
May 2007
April 2007
March 2007
February 2007
January 2007
December 2006
November 2006
October 2006
September 2006
August 2006
July 2006
June 2006
May 2006
April 2006
March 2006
February 2006
January 2006
December 2005
April 2005
March 2005
February 2005
January 2005
December 2004
November 2004
October 2004

Blog*Spot Archives
November 2005
October 2005
September 2005
August 2005
July 2005
June 2005
May 2005

Syndication

RSS Feed 2.0
Comments RSS 2.0
WordPress
 

  
  » Remember The Executor Keychain From Back In The Day?
  » UK Bank pushes iPhone e-commerce forward
  » Review: Read It Later for iPhone
  » MacRumors: Prototype iPhone 3GS on eBay? (No, No Matte Case) [Updated]
  » iPhone 3GS gets jailbroken, hack available online
  » Deathmatch rematch: BlackBerry versus iPhone 3.0
  » Review: HuffingtonPost.com for iPhone
  » Ngmoco releases Rolando 2 for iPhone, iPod touch
  » Review: Tiki Golf 3D for iPhone
  » Wirefly Offering Verizon BlackBerry Tour For $179.99
  » Skyfire For BlackBerry In Alpha Testing
  » Review: MobileStudio for iPhone
Generated by Feed Informer

  » This Week's Most Popular Posts [Highlights]
  » Celebrate the Fourth of July with a New Desktop Wallpaper [Friday Fun]
  » Get Ready For Summer With Homemade Sunblock [Summer]
  » State of the Airline Industry Chart Compares Airline Service Fees [Saving Money]
  » June 2009's Most Popular Posts [[this Is Good]]
  » Take Better Photos: Fourth of July Edition [Photography Tip]
  » From the Tips Box: Vanity Phone Numbers, iGoogle, and Tortilla Chips [From The Tips Box]
In Association with feed.informer.com

» John Danks Keeps White Sox Rolling
» Danks outduels Greinke in opener
» Quentin to begin rehab stint Saturday
» Quentin off to rehab
» Up
» White Sox Look To Add Significant Upgrade By Trade Deadline
» White Sox set to face Greinke, Royals
» Mark Buehrle Makes It Look Easy
» Buehrle brilliant in White Sox win
» Injured finger keeps Ramirez out
Maintained by feed.informer.com

 
     


  » US: Illinois state budget crisis threatens social .....
  » The saga of Howe - Chicago Tribune...
  » Giannoulias Aide Tied To University Of Illinois Cl.....
  » Report: Treasurer's aide helped get teen in to UI .....
  » Report: Treasurer's aide helped get teen in to UI .....
  » Different governor, but same gridlock at Capitol -.....
  » DuPage prosecutor runs for Ill. AG - WBBM...
  » Report: Giannoulias aide helped get teen into UofI.....
  » Saline, Gallatin counties included in federal disa.....
  » Report: Giannoulias aide helped get teen in to UI .....
Maintained by Feed Informer


  » Ramirez scores 2 runs in first action since injury
  » Cubs' Ramirez, Johnson make rehab starts
  » Man arrested for carrying shotgun near Taste
  » Port-a-potty explodes in Chicago lakefront park
  » Flu cases close Wis. camp; 1 case is swine flu
  » Illinois police promise holiday DUI patrols
  » Happy Havlat checks out new home in Minnesota
  » Report: Illinois nursing home allowed sexual abuse
  » Chicago crime down 10 percent so far this year
  » Bond set at $500,000 for assault on disabled kids
Supported by feed.informer.com

» Giannoulias aide helped priest get friend's daughter into U of I
» Even 'the mighty' will feel budget cuts, Quinn says
» Birkett to run again for attorney general
» Quinn rejects budget, assures worker pay
» Tax hike showdown coming to Springfield
» Suburban service agencies feel the pinch too
» Layoffs and cuts continue at Champaign-area service agencies
» Lawmakers flooded with calls from constitutents
» Union chief says prison cuts will raise overtime costs
» Mattoon Adult Education Center closes from lack of state budget
Upholded by feed dot informer dot com

  » Founders Bank one of six in state to fail Thursday
  » Obama due here for big fundraiser
  » Two more Illinois banks fail
  » Banker, investor Sanford Takiff dies
  » Boeing 2Q jet deliveries on pace with last year
  » Navistar's Ontario workers reject contract offer
  » St. Anthony Hospital splits from parent
  » Global Hyatt changes name to Hyatt Hotels
  » Tribune Co. to run Dallas Morning News ad sales
  » Zizzle auction puts toy firm in play
Powered by feed.informer.com


  » Quinn appeals to legislators on tax increase
  » Chicago homicide, overall crime rate down
  » Fireworks used to blow up portable toilet at Diversey Harbor
  » Officers shoot, kill teen after West Side home invasion: police
  » County Board asks state to close education office
  » Man fatally shot at South Side gas station
  » Theater with Dillinger's bullet holes up for sale
  » Union bets $500 million on Olympic Village plan
  » Stuck in jobs, more workers bullied by bosses: expert
  » Family divided by suit over injury at Beverly school reunion
Upholded by feed dot informer dot com


  » Chicago man charged with criminal sexual assault on siblings 6, 16
  » Man charged with attempted murder after shooting at Chicago cops, prosecutors say
  » Police: Teen slain after Lawndale foot chase had aimed gun at officer
  » Blagojevich urged SIU to let 2 into law school
  » Peddlers balk at move
  » Chicago scrambles to boost tourism after a dip in 2008
  » Source says Cubs sale on track
  » Body found at Southwest Side home
  » Man shot on West Side
  » Soldier comes home to family on holiday
From FeedInformer


  » Real-Estate Magnate Backed Harold Washington
  » A Renaissance Man of Chicago’s South Side
  » Governer Quinn Addresses Flip-Flop Critics
  » Police Fatally Shoot West Side Teen
  » Congressman to Reject Payday-Loan Donations
  » Shelter Turns Away Women, Blames State Budget
  » United Still Recoving From Early Morning Computer Glitch
  » The Ledge Opens at the Sears Tower
  » Quinn's Income Tax Hike Still a Tough Sell to Some Lawmakers.
  » Quinn's "Credibility Gap"
Succoured by feed dot informer dot com


  » Danks dominates Royals in White Sox's win
  » Adventures for the palate at Taste of Downtown Springfield
  » Clouds fail to deter Rock the Dock fans
  » Pujols hits club-record 4th slam in Cards’ win
  » Two days left to enter Drysdale tournament
  » Bases loaded walk gives Cubs win
  » Palin resigning as Alaska governor
  » Southern Illinois toddler drowns in relative’s pool
  » Attorney shuffle continues in triple-slaying case
  » Thefts, damage reported at golf course
Provided by feed dot informer dot com

» Ill. man charged with $10K theft from lottery
» 1st cases of swine flu in St. Clair County
» Roy Blunt touts his insider support; Democrats do, too
» Ill. Gov. Quinn to veto partial budget today; showdown looms
» As new fiscal year begins, Illinois remains without budget
Powered by feed.informer.com

» Watch this clip of tonight's ABC 7 Chicago story highlighting my run f..
» White Sox on a roll...and Quentin will soon be back in the lineup!
» CYRs: Palin's Resignation Has Many Asking, What Next? http://bit.ly/s3..
» ILREALTOR: Taste of Springfield. Pot Roast Slammer, jerk taco, elk bur..
» CYRs: http://bit.ly/XnZqc Rumors fly. All IL GOP staff given walking ..
» ilrepwillburns: I'm ready for Hyde Park 4th of July parade. Yes, we do..
» ilrepwillburns: Progress Illinois has footage from presser where I can..
» DanProft: Froehlich not running for re-elect, good opp. for House GOP ..
» Go Andy! #roddick
» #twill VIDEO: Chicago Tonight on Chicago's Public Schools http://tinyu..
Succoured by feed dot informer dot com


  » Cherokee descendants visit Trail of Tears
  » Blagojevich 0-for-2 at SIU
  » 2009 Fireworks/ Independence Day celebrations
  » Koehn, longtime educator, to retire
  » Bench honors donor, inspires 'Friends'
In Association with feed.informer.com


» Report: Illinois nursing home allowed sexual abuse
» Flu cases close Wis. camp; 1 case is swine flu
» Illinois police promise holiday DUI patrols
» Port-a-potty explodes in Chicago lakefront park
» Hoffman Estates fire under investigation
Generated by feed.informer.com


  » GOPUSA ILLINOIS Daily Clips - June 28, 2009
  » Don't emulate Illinois...
  » GOPUSA ILLINOIS Daily Clips - June 27, 2009
  » Governor signs bill to refinance debt
  » Political Prison in Marion?
  » GOPUSA ILLINOIS Daily Clips - June 26, 2009
  » Budget not the only thing in limbo
  » GOPUSA ILLINOIS Daily Clips - June 25, 2009
  » Everything in limbo
  » GOPUSA ILLINOIS Daily Clips - June 24, 2009
Maintained by FeedInformer

» Illinois ranks 10th in new study of overweigh..
» Shock says VA clinic remains a top priority -..
» Oak Lawn Gets Preview Of Children's Museu..
» Lipinski Wants Options For Health Care - Sout..
» Protestors Want Option And Lipinski's Sig..
» Rep. Jackson holds health reform town hall me..
» MSNBC's Ed Show Covers Hartmarx Victory -..
» MSNBC "THE ED SHOW" INTERVIEW WITH REP. PHIL ..
» Two Ga. congressmen co-sponsor ENDA - Sovo.co..
» Why Reducing Credit Card Debt Now Is So Impor..
Supported by feed dot informer dot com

» NotDickDurbin: Senators Feinstein, Akaka, Fei.....
» NotDickDurbin: Senate Approves Anti-Meth Legi.....
» NotDickDurbin: Photo: Barack at the Bulls/Wiz.....
» Brady Campaign observes Independence Day by l.....
» Its No Secret that the Banks Own the Governme.....
» Cap and tax - Northwest Herald...
» South Elgin student travels to Capitol to adv.....
» Chicago air controllers overworked - People's.....
» Report: Chicago air controllers overworked - .....
» Audit: FAA should address air controller fati.....
Generated by feed dot informer dot com

» A Tourist In Your Own Town (a photo diary) - .....
» Palin's Foolish Resignation - Washington .....
» Gov. Quinn appeals to legislators on proposed.....
» America's political ayatollahs - MPNnow.c.....
» Spillane represents Jo Carroll Energy in Wash.....
» Voice of the Reader 7-3 - The Southern...
» DK Greenroots: Blood Stains on Green Technolo.....
» Cheryle Jackson launches Illinois Senate expl.....
» Complaints arise about White House kibitzing .....
» Ticket Time Lias Madigan for Senate Opens Up .....
Maintained by Feed Informer

    » Land of Linkin'
    » Blagojevich interceded for 2 applicants to SIU
    » Skinner Sued by Northwest Herald
    » Bloggers, not mainstream media, has the scoop on Palin resignation
    » Where’s Sarah?
    » ILGOP staff let go?
    » The Impact on Clearbrook
    » Obama and Mentesti on the economy
    » Froehlich will not seek re-election
    » Fireworks, Buses and Trains
    » Sarah is quitting
    » Small scandal points up a major outrage
In Association with FeedInformer


Header Photos...
Wayne Bretl & UIS


Hosted by MCS