Subscribe to Capitol Fax      Advertise Here     Contact Rich Miller
To subscribe to Capitol Fax, click here. Subscriptions are $350 per year. To advertise on the Capitol Fax Blog, please click here.
Question of the day

Monday, Nov 30, 2009

* Treasurer and Democratic US Senate hopeful Alexi Giannoulias released his tax returns last week

The first-term treasurer has been criticized by Democratic Senate opponent David Hoffman for large Broadway Bank payouts to him and his family.

In all, there were $70 million in payouts in 2007 and 2008. Giannoulias’ campaign said the payouts were was triggered by the 2006 death of Giannoulias’ father, Alexis, who founded Broadway Bank. His will called for estate and income taxes to be paid for with dividend payments from the sale of Broadway shares, the campaign said.

Alexi Giannoulias’ portion of those payouts totaled $2.5 million — $1 million of which he has said went to pay income taxes. The campaign has noted that Alexi Giannoulias didn’t have a say in whether to sell the shares because he divested himself of his voting shares when he was elected treasurer.

GOP gubernatorial candidate Bob Schillerstrom says he won’t release his returns

“I feel strongly about full disclosure in government, but I do not believe posting my personal tax returns, or the tax returns of the other candidates for governor, would further the public interest in any tangible way. I have yet to hear anyone make a compelling argument how this would benefit voters,” he replied to an Associated Press questionnaire.

Bill Brady released his returns the last time he ran for governor, but won’t this time. Green Party gubernatorial candidate Rich Whitney also refuses…

“It’s time to stop looking at trendy gimmicks as a pathway to clean government, and time to look at the real public policies needed to establish it,” Whitney said.

* The Question: Do you think it’s important for candidates to release their tax returns? Explain.

- posted by Rich Miller


26 Comments
  1. - Skeptical Cynic - Monday, Nov 30, 09 @ 10:51 am:

    You asked this same question a month ago or so.


  2. - Just Observing - Monday, Nov 30, 09 @ 10:53 am:

    No… Rich Whitney said it best. I think all that is important is that candidates (or maybe upon being elected) disclose potential conflicts of interest. So, if a public official maintains ownership interest in, let’s say a construction firm, then steps can be taken to help ensure that the public official cannot direct contracts toward the firm.


  3. - David Ormsby - Monday, Nov 30, 09 @ 10:54 am:

    Yes.

    The release is a confidence-building between a candidate and the voters. Voters routinely harbor suspicions regarding the potential clash between politicians’ official duties and their personal financial interests.

    Refusing to release the returns, in light of its established practice, fuels suspicions in voters’ minds–legitimate or not–they have something to hide.

    It’s boneheaded, politically, to dodge the disclosure and wrap the refusal in weasel words.


  4. - John Bambenek - Monday, Nov 30, 09 @ 11:01 am:

    David-

    I find it amusing you’re agreeing with Adam Andrzejewski on a matter of policy ;)


  5. - Little Egypt - Monday, Nov 30, 09 @ 11:03 am:

    Yes. What are they afraid of? Perhaps that we, the voters, are not quite as naive as they hope. If they don’t want to fully disclose their finances, then don’t run for office. This isn’t the 1800’s and they better get used to a nagging press and the questions that will follow. Be able to run with the big dogs or stay on the porch and out of the campaign.


  6. - OneMan - Monday, Nov 30, 09 @ 11:12 am:

    It’s not a bad idea, I was rather entertained when I went to the Thompson center to look at Quinn’s and an aid watched me and took notes the entire time I was looking at the returns.

    He spelled my name really wrong btw on his notes.

    So if you are going to do it don’t be a tool about it, otherwise don’t bother.


  7. - ahoy - Monday, Nov 30, 09 @ 11:15 am:

    No, I think this flies in the face of privacy and has no public good. AS a voter I don’t need to know how much people make.


  8. - Rich Miller - Monday, Nov 30, 09 @ 11:19 am:

    ===You asked this same question a month ago or so.===

    Nope. I asked whether it should be required a month or so ago.


  9. - VanillaMan - Monday, Nov 30, 09 @ 11:26 am:

    I think it is important, but not compulsory. It is a campaign tactic that could end some personal issues, but in many cases, does not.

    Overall, I don’t recommend it unless the move fits the candidate’s image, or compliments it. If a candidate wishes to sell themselves as a regular fellow - releasing personal tax information is OK. If a candidate wishes to trump the importance of transparency - same thing.

    But in Giannoulais’ case, these things really don’t end the negative consequences of political opposition abusing his Broadway Bank ties. He is damned if he does - or does not. By releasing them, he runs the risk of pandering to the questions surrounding his financial past, and if he does not, he risks questions surrounding his Broadway Bank ties, anyway.

    Conclusion: it is a political tactic.


  10. - Louis G. Atsaves - Monday, Nov 30, 09 @ 11:28 am:

    No. There are other documents that can be filed disclosing potential conflicts of interest, including those current office holders and certain state employees need to file.


  11. - wordslinger - Monday, Nov 30, 09 @ 11:36 am:

    Mildly important, but not a necessarily a deal-breaker. A candidate who does gets more points for openness.

    I think, for the most part, you don’t need to see someone’s tax returns to get a sense if they’re susceptible to corruption. It’s not like anyone’s been going out of their way to hide that recently.


  12. - zatoichi - Monday, Nov 30, 09 @ 11:47 am:

    I fall on both sides of this while leaning to release the info. Releasing tax info has become a basic assumption of somehow showing honesty and a clean financial/conflict of interest. The privacy issue drifts into a ‘why do I need to know that’ area. A basic assumption is you have to have personal money because if you don’t, you probably do not have the contacts to run a major campaign. While I cannot think of a significant candidate who got dinged by something on their tax forms, I am also assuming if you got a trouble area, you need some new tax reps. The issue will come out anyhow. However people have come to expect it so if you do not want to do it, why you running? Refusing to release the tax forms strikes a Helmsley attitude of ‘taxes are for the little people’. If you want to be a public servant, you need to think real hard on how public you want to be.


  13. - DuPage Dan - Monday, Nov 30, 09 @ 1:01 pm:

    I think it is more important to know where a candidate is getting money - disclosure of campaign donations in real time.


  14. - Yellow Dog Democrat - Monday, Nov 30, 09 @ 1:24 pm:

    I think interviews with the wait staff in restaurants they frequent would be much more telling.

    Character is how you act when no one is looking.


  15. - MrJM - Monday, Nov 30, 09 @ 1:44 pm:

    Yes. Bob Schillerstrom is not just a GOP gubernatorial candidate he’s also Chairman of the DuPage County Board.

    Voters deserve to see if his returns show that he’s enriched himself at the taxpayer’s expense.

    (Ain’t it funny how the law ‘n’ order Republicans say, “If you’ve done nothing wrong, you’ve got nothing to hide” right up until it’s them doing the hiding.)

    – MrJM
    http://twitter.com/misterjayem


  16. - The Prophet - Monday, Nov 30, 09 @ 1:56 pm:

    Unless I missed something, this morning’s AP article in the Chicago Sun-Times managed to comment on all of the GOP gubernatorial candidates and their campaign stance regarding publicly revealing their income tax returns except for the GOP gubernatorial candidate Dan Proft? I may be a bit cynical and suspicious but I wonder if this was a deliberate slight on the Sun-Times part toward Proft or if his name was just inadvertantly overlooked? Incidentally, based on the AP article in other newspapers, Proft said that he was more than willing to show his income tax returns.
    I like Proft as a GOP candidate so maybe I am being a bit too thin-skinned on what seems to be an example of “ignore somebody and they will eventually go away”. If I am wrong or if I am overlooking something, I will apologize in advance for my error and my suspicious nature when it comes to politics. And yes, I feel that if an individual has nothing to hide and wants to run for public office, than the candidate’s belief in “transparency” for the voter and it’s practice is extremely important.


  17. - Thomas Westgard - Monday, Nov 30, 09 @ 2:44 pm:

    I think it’s important for candidates to release their tax forms. We have an extensive problem with corruption in this state, and we need to guard against misuse of public office for private gain. One piece of that puzzle is knowing where the officeholder stands to gain. And a tax form is the gold standard for the consequences of fraudulently misstating one’s assets.

    I also note what’s missing here - not only are they refusing to release a total disclosure, but they are refusing ANY disclosure. They could extensively redact the document as a middle ground. Another alternative would be to withhold the tax forms but provide an extensive and detailed written plan on transparency in government, accompanied by an affidavit regarding what they do and don’t own.

    There are many options to act as a proactive leader on the issue, rather than the lazy and cowardly course of simply saying no. So since they are not doing that, it leaves me thinking that these candidates are lying now and planning to steal later.


  18. - Downstate Commissioner - Monday, Nov 30, 09 @ 2:50 pm:

    Nah, not necessary. First of all, only the election junkies or scandal-monger press bother to go through them; second of all, everybody knows that all politicians are crooks anyway with accountants, so what’s the difference?
    (Before some thin-skinned idiot jumps to defend his candidate, I am a local elected official, which makes me a politician, which makes me a crook- simple logic. If you’re in politics, you live with the brand…true or not)


  19. - Downstate Commissioner - Monday, Nov 30, 09 @ 2:54 pm:

    Mr. Westgard, ALL candidates have to fill out and sign a financial disclosure statement and file with the election board; a copy of the receipt HAS to be filed with nominating papers: they can’t “refuse ANY disclosure.”


  20. - Hoffman hammering - Monday, Nov 30, 09 @ 3:12 pm:

    Here’s the Hoffman campaign hammering Alexi for saying that the $2.5 million he received from Broadway Bank was “minimal”: http://www.hoffmanforillinois.com/blog/details/minimal_amount


  21. - Nihilate - Monday, Nov 30, 09 @ 4:11 pm:

    I agree that thee tax returns dont need to be released. however, there should be something that lets voters know the candidate has paid theeir taxes correctly prior to running.


  22. - Ghost - Monday, Nov 30, 09 @ 4:16 pm:

    I pretty much follow Words sentiments….

    But I would add they should have to disclose who cuts/styles their hair; and all sermons from any religious services conducted at any church/temple they have attended for the last 5 years.

    Oh and whether they support the Sox or the Cubs should be disclosed as part of the petition filing process.


  23. - Rich Miller - Monday, Nov 30, 09 @ 4:21 pm:

    ===Oh and whether they support the Sox or the Cubs should be disclosed as part of the petition filing process. ===

    Now, that’s an important disclosure.


  24. - Anonymous - Monday, Nov 30, 09 @ 4:55 pm:

    ===
    …disclosure of campaign donations in real time.
    ===

    I think Gidwitz did that fairly effectively during his Gov race. Did anyone else? I kind of liked that.


  25. - Louis Howe - Monday, Nov 30, 09 @ 8:20 pm:

    Yes….disclosing the last 3 years tax returns would give voters insight into the source of the candidate income and the extent used to avoid paying taxes. It’s really a no brainer. Public office requires public discloser of income.


  26. - Anonymous - Tuesday, Dec 1, 09 @ 9:09 am:

    Oh, good. You saw that last post that someone had made and deleted it. Odd.


TrackBack URI

Sorry, comments for this post are now closed.


ON THE BLOG TODAY...
* Sunday update: Lt. Governor hopeful videos
* Reader comments closed for the weekend
* *** UPDATED x1 *** Afternoon campaign roundup
* More thoughts about Garrett's lite guv candidacy
* Question of the day
* Cohen claims his religion was a factor
* On the process
* K2 ban advances - And a Statehouse roundup
* Morning Shorts
* Sen. Susan Garrett a "top contender" for LG
** Yesterday's blog posts

Support The Capitol Fax Blog
Visit our advertisers...

Search This Blog...

Search the 96th General Assembly By Bill Number
(example: HB0001)

Search the 96th General Assembly By Keyword

Quick Links


Main Menu
Home
Illinois
YouTube
Pundit rankings
Obama
Subscriber Content
Durbin
Burris
Polls

Archives
March 2010
February 2010
January 2010
December 2009
November 2009
October 2009
September 2009
August 2009
July 2009
June 2009
May 2009
April 2009
March 2009
February 2009
January 2009
December 2008
November 2008
October 2008
September 2008
August 2008
July 2008
June 2008
May 2008
April 2008
March 2008
February 2008
January 2008
December 2007
November 2007
October 2007
September 2007
August 2007
July 2007
June 2007
May 2007
April 2007
March 2007
February 2007
January 2007
December 2006
November 2006
October 2006
September 2006
August 2006
July 2006
June 2006
May 2006
April 2006
March 2006
February 2006
January 2006
December 2005
April 2005
March 2005
February 2005
January 2005
December 2004
November 2004
October 2004

Blog*Spot Archives
November 2005
October 2005
September 2005
August 2005
July 2005
June 2005
May 2005

Syndication

RSS Feed 2.0
Comments RSS 2.0
WordPress
 

  
  » Review: Paper Boat Race for iPhone
  » BIS 3.0 Upgrade Hitting North America March 28th
  » Review: MouseWait 1.5
  » Review: Hellemental for iPhone
  » Review: Motorola Cliq XT smartphone

  » MakeMKV Rips DVDs and Blu-Rays With Just Two Clicks [Downloads]
  » Ask the Commenters Roundup [Hive Mind]
  » LED Deck Lighting Adds Some Zazz to Your Party [DIY]
  » IKEA SIGNUM Series Cheaply Manages Your Cables [Stuff We Like]
  » Consider Economies of Scale When Evaluating Money Saving Tips and Tricks [Saving Money]

» Jenks says he'll be a go for opener
» [Update] Bobby Jenks has MRI: No Structural Damage
» Pitching coach not worried about stats
» Jenks held out of Saturday's action
» Andruw goes deep against Padres

 
     


  » Line up to get your birthday present: a new driver....
  » Comment on: House Dems See Momentum in Home Stretc....
  » Mighty labor that produced a mouse - News-Gazette..
  » Madigan pushes for judicial experience amendment -....
  » Advocates: State needs more sunshine - Southtown S....
  » Madigan makes sure his party keeps control - The S....
  » In Missouri Senate race, meet the `outsiders’ - La....
  » True lap of employee luxury - The Courier News..
  » Lt. governor hopefuls 'audition' for job - WLS..
  » Fix It!: Can you get them to stop calling me? - Ka....


  » All-tournament team named in Class 4A basketball
  » All-tournament team named in Class 3A basketball
  » Illinois man's harmonicas hit the notes
  » Chicago suburbs awarded obesity prevention grant
  » Illinois to honor female veterans in Chicago
  » Weir Hears Cheers Not Jeers In Oak Lawn
  » Health Reform: Prayers & Protest Here
  » Il. Dems Hold Audition for Lt. Governor
  » Sixty Thousand CTA Farecards Expiring
  » Two Men Shot Near South Side School

  » MLS settle labor dispute
  » Gov. Quinn lobbies Caterpillar execs to build plant in Illinois
  » AMA backs President Obama's health care bill
  » Charlie Trotter ends Vegas run with restaurant closing
  » Democrats close in on lieutenant guv choice


  » Slain cop's brother killed, another hurt in S. Side shooting
  » No injuries in emergency landing at O'Hare
  » Witnesses held down man after he robbed woman at gunpoint
  » Kenyan, St. Charles native win Shamrock Shuffle
  » Death of 3-week-old ruled homicide, police investigating
  » Hundreds hit the road for rally on immigration
  » Cook Co. gets $16M to battle obesity
  » State to honor female veterans in Chicago
  » 4 injured in N. Side crash
  » Snow, rain through Sunday, but spring weather returns


  » Dems: We have the votes to pass healthcare bill
  » Autopsy: 3-week-old's death ruled a homicide
  » Quigley, Foster will vote for health care bill
  » Clergy sex abuse victims' group leaders head to Europe
  » Mike Quigley's statement in support of the health care bill
  » Bill Foster's statement in support of the health care bill
  » Slain cop's brother killed on South Side
  » Shamrock Shuffle shut down streets today
  » Summit man charged with weapons violations
  » Illinois to honor female veterans in Chicago


  » Protesters Want Immigration on Front Burner
  » Immigrants To Rally in East Chicago
  » AMA Backs Health Care Bill, Says It's Not Perfect
  » Teachers Fearful, Angry Over Budget Cuts
  » Durbin Believes Health Care Bill Will Pass
  » Some Illinois Democrats Still Unsure on Health Care
  » Supreme Court Takes Up Asian Carp Debate Again
  » Illinois Budget Deficit Could Hurt Odds of Winning Federal Money
  » Illinois Behind in Spending Federal Housing Dollars
  » Chicagoan Pleads Guilty to Terror Attack that Killed 160


  » DecaturCelebration to sell wristbands for food, drinks
  » Meadowbrook Road will remain closed
  » Crime Stoppers seeks information on burglary
  » Chicago suburbs awarded obesity prevention grant
  » Program to honor female veterans
  » Man cited after accident at MacArthur Boulevard, Lawrence Avenue
  » Two teens arrested after home allegedly burglarized
  » Woman extricated from car after two-vehicle collision
  » Springfield man faces traffic-related charges
  » Madigan pushes for judicial experience amendment


  » Bill would add criminals to lifetime registry
  » Men’s health conference draws good crowd
  » Local demonstrators march for end of wars
  » Smoke ’em if you got ’em — but not in public
  » Voice of the Reader: 3-21


» Foster says he'll vote for health care bill
» Democrats say they have the votes to pass health care bill
» Former Interior Secretary Udall dies at age 90
» Volcano erupts in Iceland, hundreds evacuated
» Grave robbers steal Cyprus Archbishops' remains


  » GOPUSA ILLINOIS Daily Clips - March 21, 2010
  » Our President, in "Preacher Mode"
  » GOPUSA ILLINOIS Daily Clips - March 20, 2010
  » GOPUSA ILLINOIS Daily Clips - March 19, 2010
  » Cuts could hurt Race to the Top application

» Foster to vote for health insurance reform bi..
» Republicans Raise Objections, Protesters Rais..
» Scenes from the Capitol in the final showdown..
» Debate Turns Nasty as House Gets Closer to Pa..
» Anti-abortion democrats say they'll vote yes ..
» Battle over healthcare overhaul is anything b..
» Stupak to vote for health bill - msnbc.com
» Over 200000 March FOR America - Change.org (b..
» Immigration rally draws thousands to Washingt..
» US gov't targets undocumented - The Militant

» Democrats grow confident ahead of health care.....
» Debate Turns Nasty as House Gets Closer to Pa.....
» Democrats Say They Have Votes to Pass Health .....
» Democrats grow confident ahead of health care.....
» CBS "FACE THE NATION" - Federal News Service .....

» Now that the Illinois Supreme Court has clear.....
» Sen. Burris confident health care reforms wil.....
» Anger around the Capitol - Politico (blog)...
» Senator discusses health care, jobs - Alton T.....
» Senators question flood mapping - Burlington .....

    » It's Been a Long Time Coming ...
    » Halvorson, Bean Will Both Support Health Care Bill (UPDATED)
    » Sweet Calls Out Lipinski on Diabetes and Congressional Health Care
    » Quigley a Tentative Yes
    » Illinois Governor 2010: Bill Brady Parties with Karl Rove
    » Illinois Legislature: Tom Cross Opposes Madigan Judicial Reform Amendment
    » Stupak becomes a "yes," changing the game once again
    » Quigley yes on health care if no abortion compromise
    » Obama issues executive order on abortion hoping to break health bill deadlock. Text.
    » Nothing is over until we decide it is


Header Photos...
Wayne Bretl & UIS


Hosted by MCS