Subscribe to Capitol Fax      Advertise Here     Contact Rich Miller
To subscribe to Capitol Fax, click here. Subscriptions are $350 per year. To advertise on the Capitol Fax Blog, please click here.
Stop the lending?

Tuesday, Feb 9, 2010

* Since December 1st of 2009, campaigns for all state and local offices received almost $10.9 million in loans, according to a search of the State Board of Elections website. That’s almost a quarter of the entire amount reported raised in all forms during that same time period ($44.8 million).

About $2.2 million of the total was lent by GOP gubernatorial candidate Andy McKenna’s wife alone. Another $1.5 million or so was lent by Scott Lee Cohen to his own lt. governor’s campaign. Republican lt. governor nominee Jason Plummer borrowed about $1.2 million from himself and his family businesses. Failed treasurer candidate Justin Oberman took out over $400,000 in loans from himself and others.

But it wasn’t all rich people who borrowed money. Gov. Pat Quinn, for instance, borrowed well over $700,000 since December 1st. The search shows that Sen. Kirk Dillard borrowed $650,000 from various individuals.

I have no problem with wealthy people running for office. It’s a free country and they have a right to spend their money. My problem is that they often loan themselves money. Here’s the rub: If they win, the cash they raise after they take office is going right into their own pockets. Not good at all.

I also have an issue with bigtime borrowing by non-wealthy candidates like Quinn and Dillard. I’ve never believed that campaign contributions automatically meant that the recipients were completely beholden. But borrowed money is different. What happens if Gov. Quinn, for instance, can’t pay that money back right away? Do those lenders have a special hold over him?

* The current law in place will, when it finally takes effect, bar loans like the ones Quinn and Dillard received this cycle. I’m pretty sure it would also bar loans like the ones from McKenna’s wife (although McKenna could’ve probably gotten around the law by loaning himself the money).

Banning big loans might cut down on vanity candidates like McKenna and Cohen. If they know there’s no legal way to get their money back after the election, maybe they won’t spend as much on themselves. After all, the first thing Cohen wanted when the pressure ramped up was to be made whole.

Getting rid of those self-loans could also head off potential trouble if any of these candidates eventually take office and start raising money to replenish their own personal bank accounts.

What say you?

- posted by Rich Miller


27 Comments
  1. - steve schnorf - Tuesday, Feb 9, 10 @ 10:08 am:

    Rich, I think the problem probably wouldn’t be solved by a solution. One lesson we learn over and again is that when we make fund-raising rules all we really do is start a new creativity contest on ways to circumvent them.


  2. - Northsider - Tuesday, Feb 9, 10 @ 10:13 am:

    It’s a valid concern, but I’m not sure there’s much that can be done. My guess is the Roberts Court would strike down restrictions on self-lending in a 5-4 heartbeat.


  3. - Downstater - Tuesday, Feb 9, 10 @ 10:13 am:

    Rich,
    There’s a second benefit for the lender that you haven’t mentioned. If I make a campaign donation - I’m never going to see that money back. Nor do I get to write it off on my taxes.

    If I make a loan to a campaign, and don’t get paid back, I can still write it off as a bad debt expense and take the deduction on my taxes.

    I’m glad they are closing the loophole.


  4. - way northsider - Tuesday, Feb 9, 10 @ 10:20 am:

    I agree. People should be able to donate money to their own campaigns but not loan money to their own campaigns. Same goes for close relatives.


  5. - Dude in Springfield - Tuesday, Feb 9, 10 @ 10:22 am:

    Rich- I like Walter Cronkite’s idea of limiting TV ads..and giving candidates free air time. The they wouldn’t need these loans cause campaigns would be much less expensive. Can’t we find a way to eliminate political ads??


  6. - Rich Miller - Tuesday, Feb 9, 10 @ 10:23 am:

    State law has no say over FCC-licensed TV stations.


  7. - Pot calling kettle - Tuesday, Feb 9, 10 @ 10:24 am:

    For candidates just starting out, a loan might be necessary to open up a campaign. Who wants to give money to a candidate with no palm cards, no fliers, and no bank account? To start an operation takes a couple thousand dollars, which can be a lot to someone with good ideas, but not a big income. Since the candidate is putting a lot of their time into the campaign and forgoing income, much of the investment can never be paid back. So, for some, the ability to take out a loan to kick off the campaign can be crucial because it allows some of that initial investment to be paid back.

    In addition, the campaign cycle is such that contributions typically don’t come in until June and later in the election year, while money needs to be spent starting a year earlier.

    That said, large loans are a bad idea for all candidates for the reasons you listed and because candidates should not end a campaign under water.


  8. - Macoupinite - Tuesday, Feb 9, 10 @ 10:30 am:

    I scanned the list and saw for Bill Brady only one $101,000 loan from Bill to his own campaign. Isn’t thatinteresting?


  9. - Corduroy Bob - Tuesday, Feb 9, 10 @ 10:31 am:

    Not sure how this works under state law, but paying oneself back at 10% interest — well above anything the market would bear — appears to have been a loophole in the federal law that Quinn exploited to his own benefit with his ‘96 Senate account.

    If we’re going to permit self-lending, we need to make sure that kind of laundering isn’t possible at the state level.


  10. - paddyrollingstone - Tuesday, Feb 9, 10 @ 10:34 am:

    I don’t think it matters all that much. Almost all of the loans you describe above appear to be close friends and family members. The “quid pro quo” ones that the question addresses, are all dependent upon who the candidate is. If Paul Simon and Rod both had loans from the same people, who do you think we really had to worry about?


  11. - trafficmatt - Tuesday, Feb 9, 10 @ 10:35 am:

    Rich,

    I don’t agree with you a lot, but on this one, I agree wholeheartedly. We have seen time and time and time again the “self-funders” get into a race and completely screw up the field and end up being terrible candidates. If a candidate believes they have a great message - fine - put your money where your mouth is, no loans.

    One of the previous commenters made a case for start up funds. I think a reasonable limit like $10k for an Assembly race and $50k for a State office might be ok.


  12. - Dirt Digger - Tuesday, Feb 9, 10 @ 10:38 am:

    Could do worse than to look at federal law for this matter:

    “The committee may use contributions to repay the candidate only up to $250,000 from contributions made after the date of the election.”

    In other words if the candidate somehow raises the full amount before election day and wants to repay the loan, great. Otherwise there is a repayment limit.


  13. - zatoichi - Tuesday, Feb 9, 10 @ 10:47 am:

    Three parts to this. If my campaign is fronted by my money, it seems the public support for my position is pretty thin. It’s basically an ego run because I can. On the other side, if a large amount of cash is made available (by whatever means) somehow it will be used. The rules just provide a path to avoid. Finally, if the candidates can write off those personal campaign loans as a deduction, why can’t that same tax benefit be given to non-family contributors?


  14. - Pot calling kettle - Tuesday, Feb 9, 10 @ 10:54 am:

    Limit the loan size and no interest.


  15. - Sue - Tuesday, Feb 9, 10 @ 11:25 am:

    Rich- as an aside on state borrowing- in light of the recent borrowing for pension contributions, has anyone done a calculation on the returns since the state borrowed 10 Billion back in 2002? Given the market volatility and declines on private equity and real estate, have the pension systems attained sufficient returns required to repay the loans along with the interest carry? As much as people complain about the state’s failure to routinely pay the necessary amounts into the pension systems, given the volatility, the plans might have not attained sufficient returns to warrant the additional contributions?


  16. - Arthur Andersen - Tuesday, Feb 9, 10 @ 12:20 pm:

    Rich, if I may, a response to “Sue’s” question. First, the hurdle rate for the pension funds on the POB cash is roughly 7%, not the 5% interest cost on the bonds, because the funds didn’t receive all of the bond proceeds, forcing them to in effect make up in returns what they didn’t receive in principal. (Recall that about 25% or a bit more of the bond proceeds went to pay current pension contributions, the first year’s interest on the bonds, and issuance costs.)
    Only one of the funds reports much detail about their investments from the bond cash. As of 9/30/09, their annualized return on the bonds is reported at 5.3%. (it’s probably a little better as of 12/31/09 after the good fourth quarter.) Answer: the funds are “attaining sufficient returns.”

    Sue’s last comment is poised as a question, which it’s not, but which requires response. The State owes the money whether the pension funds are having a good year or a bad one. It’s absurd, especially in Illinois, to say, “markets are volatile” hence we shouldn’t fund the pensions. I think the last guy with that concern wanted to solve it by investing all the pension bond money in the hedge fund his cousin worked for, but I could be mistaken.


  17. - Ghost - Tuesday, Feb 9, 10 @ 12:59 pm:

    Require contributors to specifically authorize their money to go towards paying back a loan to the canidate.

    Part of the problem with this loan process is many people may not be aware that they are really handing money back to the canidate, and not for the campaign.


  18. - Anon - Tuesday, Feb 9, 10 @ 1:08 pm:

    Rich, you posed the question regarding borrowed money by non-wealthy candidates such as Quinn and Dillard: “What happens if Gov. Quinn, for instance, can’t pay that money back right away? Do those lenders have a special hold over him?”

    I think that the answer to this is very different when you consider Gov. Quinn versus Sen. Dillard. The reason I believe it to be different is because Sen. Dillard has repeatedly and publicly made it known that he will not be raising money once he begins as Governor. Therefore, I feel that the individuals who did loan Dillard money have much less an expectation of a quick return. Perhaps it was a bad business decision on their behalf, but I think that Dillard has greatly mitigated the hold that lenders have over his potential governorship.


  19. - Adam Smith - Tuesday, Feb 9, 10 @ 2:25 pm:

    Intricate and always evolving Constitutional questions aside, candidate/family loans to campaigns are a non-issue.

    Loans allow less affluent people to jump start campaigns and not spend their entire 401k to do it. Prohibit loans and you further stack the deck for incumbents and super-rich self-funders.

    Prohibit interest payments, prohibit commercial loans, put a time-limit on payback if you want, but it is ridiculous to think that a candidate or close family member loaning money to a campaign can corrupt the process.

    And loans from contributor are no more corrupting than outright donations.


  20. - PEORIA - Tuesday, Feb 9, 10 @ 2:35 pm:

    Downstater- the point that you make about writing off campaign debt for tax purposes as ‘bad debt’ is actually inaccurate. Below is a link to an article discussing why.

    http://articles.latimes.com/1994-03-13/business/fi-42174_1_mortgage-deductions


  21. - BehindTheScenes - Tuesday, Feb 9, 10 @ 2:49 pm:

    I have always been told that a smart candidate does not put their own money into a campaign. I guess the corrolary to that adage would be a smart candidate doesn’t borrow money, either. (Beyond, of course, the “seed” money you loan or advance yourself when getting started.)

    What I’m really waiting to see is someone’s report on what candidates spent per vote. Should be some astonishing numbers…


  22. - wordslinger - Tuesday, Feb 9, 10 @ 3:58 pm:

    For candidates with money, loans are a nice hedge. If you lose, good luck getting paid back. But if you win, it should be pretty easy.

    I say put up or shut up. No loans.


  23. - Pot calling kettle - Tuesday, Feb 9, 10 @ 5:40 pm:

    No start-up loans would help keep many potential candidates off the ballot. It’s nice to say put up or shut up, but since a candidate will incur many costs that cannot be reimbursed, the inability to recoup a few thousand dollars of start-up money could be enough to keep them off of the ballot. It also ignores the realities of the election cycle, where the work starts long before the funding kicks in. Getting contributions before you file is extremely difficult, but that doesn’t mean there aren’t extensive costs. A good candidate can get the contributions to cover those costs after filing.

    If you want to stop excesses, limit the loan size and limit or disallow interest, especially for loans that do not come from a lending institution.


  24. - Quinn T.Sential - Tuesday, Feb 9, 10 @ 7:36 pm:

    I say, check the D-2’s for Anita Alvarez, and then follow the money.


  25. - Mighty M. Mouse - Tuesday, Feb 9, 10 @ 7:46 pm:

    >>

    Rich, I agree with your concern, and let me give you a specific example.

    If I’m not mistaken Gov. Quinn borrowed $100,000 from his own mother. He probably promised he would pay her back. Can you imagine just how uncaring, ruthless, and stone cold-blooded a person has to be to gamble $100,000 of his poor mother’s money on what proves to be the virtual equivalent of a coin flip? I doubt even Speaker Madigan would do that to his own mother, though I could see how others might think so.

    But now the worm has turned. That election was so close you could make the argument that his mother’s money made the difference. Now he owes her “bigtime” and in more than just one way. Now she’s totally got him by the short hairs and he’d probably do anything for her. Do we really want an elderly woman having that kind of power and influence over our ostensibly independent governor? What did she ever run for?


  26. - Rich Miller - Wednesday, Feb 10, 10 @ 12:30 am:

    MMM, Quinn also borrowed $300K from Ald. Ed Burke. Try to pay attention.


  27. - Mighty M. Mouse - Wednesday, Feb 10, 10 @ 2:14 am:

    The first duty of a politician is to get elected. The “sine qua non” of accomplishing anything as a politician is to get elected. Winners get the opportunity to accomplish great things. Quinn was fighting for his political life, he just barely won by a hair and he might well have lost no matter how powerful his last ads were if he hadn’t had those hundreds of thousands of dollars. Now he hopefully will attempt to govern honestly and wisely and try as best he can to make the right decisions for Illinois for the right reasons, only because he won. I agree with the majority. I’d rather take my chances on Pat Quinn’s integrity than on Dan Hynes’, all the loans notwithstanding.


TrackBack URI

Sorry, comments for this post are now closed.


ON THE BLOG TODAY...
* Helmets for kids goes down in flames - Thomson will be sold regardless
* Question of the day
* Supremes shoot down property tax exemption for hospital
* More on the Kirk-Obama kerfuffle
* On the brink
* Morning Shorts
* SUBSCRIBERS ONLY - Today's edition of Capitol Fax (use all CAPS in password)
** Yesterday's blog posts

Support The Capitol Fax Blog
Visit our advertisers...

Search This Blog...

Search the 96th General Assembly By Bill Number
(example: HB0001)

Search the 96th General Assembly By Keyword

Quick Links


Main Menu
Home
Illinois
YouTube
Pundit rankings
Obama
Subscriber Content
Durbin
Burris
Polls

Archives
March 2010
February 2010
January 2010
December 2009
November 2009
October 2009
September 2009
August 2009
July 2009
June 2009
May 2009
April 2009
March 2009
February 2009
January 2009
December 2008
November 2008
October 2008
September 2008
August 2008
July 2008
June 2008
May 2008
April 2008
March 2008
February 2008
January 2008
December 2007
November 2007
October 2007
September 2007
August 2007
July 2007
June 2007
May 2007
April 2007
March 2007
February 2007
January 2007
December 2006
November 2006
October 2006
September 2006
August 2006
July 2006
June 2006
May 2006
April 2006
March 2006
February 2006
January 2006
December 2005
April 2005
March 2005
February 2005
January 2005
December 2004
November 2004
October 2004

Blog*Spot Archives
November 2005
October 2005
September 2005
August 2005
July 2005
June 2005
May 2005

Syndication

RSS Feed 2.0
Comments RSS 2.0
WordPress
 

  
  » Push To Talk Now Available On Verizon BlackBerry Devices
  » BlackBerry Slider… Possibly Code Named “T”… Possibly Launching In April
  » AT&T happy to play it cool with LTE
  » Palm's Q3 FY2010 Results...
  » Review: V1 Golf for iPhone

  » The 100 Best Business Books of All Time
  » F-35 Lightning II Can Land In Your Driveway
  » Braille Rubik’s Cube Designed For The Blind
  » Best Offline Backup Tool? [Hive Five Call For Contenders]
  » Remains of the Day: "Piracy" Sounds Too Sexy Edition [For What It's Worth]

» Quentin driven to become better hitter
» Watch Out for De Aza
» Peavy deals full repertoire in second start
» Viciedo among five White Sox cuts
» Jenks says 'Next,' Ozzie on Ron Washington

 
     


  » Lawmakers split on charity care rules - Ottawa Tim....
  » Government in Illinois still too secretive - North....
  » Galesburg graduate wants No. 2 job - Peoria Journa....
  » Shop Talk: A Rose by Any Other Name - Roll Call On....
  » Nonprofit hospitals: Tax-exempt hospitals must pro....
  » Latest Articles - Lucianne.com..
  » Illinois budget crisis sharpens - World Socialist ....
  » Supreme Court upholds decision to strip Provena ......
  » Obama Administration Pushing Forward With Thomson ....
  » Pinnacle Security, Illinois AG reach deal - WLS..


  » Exhibit looks at enigmatic phase in Matisse's art
  » Illinois gets $15 million for water projects
  » Planning under way for Earth Hour 2010 in Illinois
  » MRSA survivors want it declared a health epidemic
  » Chicago terror suspect pleads guilty
  » Boeing puts 747-8 Freighter through test flight
  » Exelon threatens to shut New Jersey nuke plant
  » Huron Consulting elects new non-exec chairman
  » Navistar gets ratings upgrade from Fitch
  » Quinn plans to sign bill moving primary to March

  » Winners and losers: CBS should score with Woods at Masters
  » Chicago retail sales fell faster than ever in 2009
  » CME CEO Donohue's earned 16% more in 2009
  » Kraft wins big cheese award -- but has it earned shelf space alongside artisans?
  » Delta switching New York service to O'Hare from Midway


  » Guilty of terrorism
  » It's Blackies -- not that other place
  » Boender guilty on all 5 counts
  » Polycystic ovary syndrome study seeks patients
  » Warm welcome for speedskating champ
  » Husband charged with pimping his wife 'made her feel special'
  » Not your parents' science fair
  » Grand possibility for rail terminal site in South Loop
  » Prices at the pump up 4 cents, highest since Oct. 2008
  » Former Dem fund-raiser admits bank fraud


  » Man shot to death during argument in Austin
  » Vacant building partially collapses in Chinatown; no injuries
  » Teens charged in South Side carjacking
  » Police probe claim of racial profiling
  » Police: Gang shooting wounds 4 on South Side
  » Judge postpones ruling on 70-year-old killer
  » 4 people wounded in West Side shooting
  » Judge rejects lower bail for priest accused of sex assault
  » Chicago man pleads guilty in Mumbai terrorism case
  » Developer convicted of bribing alderman


  » Chicago Developer Convicted On All Counts of Bribing Alderman
  » Anti-War Protesters Marching in Chicago Tonight
  » Chicago Terror Suspect David Headley Pleads Guilty
  » Illinois Supreme Court Rules Provena Not Charitable Enough
  » Admitted Terrorist in Chicago Avoiding the Death Penalty
  » O'Hare Passenger Traffic Sees Big Drop in 2009
  » Chicagoan Pleads Guilty to Terror Attack that Killed 160
  » Obama Administration Pushing Forward With Thomson Prison Plan
  » No Details on CPS Clout Admissions, But Tightened Controls
  » Blagojevich Attorneys to Play Tapes When He Testifies


  » Allen Street closed today
  » Gunman may have felt slighted by Northern
  » Dental management contract focus of questions
  » 2 held in LaSalle tavern stabbing
  » Senate approves lease restriction measure
  » Match Day lines up prospective SIU doctors with residency programs
  » No more breakfast in bed for Cook County Jail inmates
  » Community jobs forum planned in Springfield
  » Feds to buy Illinois prison even without detainees
  » Two men arrested after allegedly fighting each other


  » Public defenders appointed in child abduction case
  » 0319 voice of the reader
  » Great losses, state tournaments, sad teacher layoffs
  » State Senate shoots down teen motorcyclist helmet law
  » Friends of Herrin City Library to host pancake breakfast Saturday


» Des Plaines author helps prevent burnout
» Invite birds, butterflies into your yard
» Keaggy to pick his guitar to aid Aurora charity
» Keenan directs play 47 years after she helped launch Glen Ellyn theater
» School raises money in student's memory


  » Cuts could hurt Race to the Top application
  » Nonprofit hospital not exempt from local tax
  » GOPUSA ILLINOIS Daily Clips - March 18, 2010
  » Primary date moved back
  » Sen. Hutchinson: "We haven't been doing that for the last 25-30 years"

» Democrats push toward Sunday vote on health c..
» Detainees or not, feds want Illinois prison -..
» POLITICO's guide to the undecideds - Politico
» Democrats' Momentum Building for Sunday Healt..
» Wavering Democrats milk minutes of fame - Pol..
» Health care vote likely this weekend - San Fr..
» Bean, Manzullo pan jobs bill - Northwest Hera..
» D&S @ Left Forum - Dollars & Sense (blog)
» Arsenal could gain from Thomson prison deal -..
» Feds want to buy Thomson even without Guantan..

» Guantanamo closure nears: report - Sydney Mor.....
» Ward P. Milliot Jr.: Democrats don't get it -.....
» Specter trying to regain seniority lost in pa.....
» Deal Near on Gitmo, Trials for Detainees - Wa.....
» GOP Plots Strategies to Nullify Health Bill -.....

» Pike site could attain national park status -.....
» Risky Business - UW Badger Herald...
» Liberals Push Gay Blood in Risky Policy Chang.....
» 16 senators press FEMA for answers on flood m.....
» Senator Roland Burris Joins SNMA for the Annu.....

    » Boone County Watchdog
    » Red Light Camera Protests Target Senators Cullerton, Millner Saturday
    » Southern Strategy
    » I don’t get it when it comes to motorcycle riders’ helmet opposition for kids
    » Pat Quinn has another choice for Lt. Governor
    » Friday Funnies
    » Could state Sen. Susan Garrett be lieutenant governor and still keep her seat?
    » Rush Waffling On Health Care Bill
    » Deep Thought: Reading
    » Lost Dog In Irving Park/Clarendon Area


Header Photos...
Wayne Bretl & UIS


Hosted by MCS